All datasets generated and used for this study are openly available on GitHub: https://github.com/HazelvdW/context-framed-listening.
This document runs all six NLP models on both data levels — aggregated combMIMC documents (Group A) and individual MIMC responses (Group B) — to provide a fully comparable cross-model, cross-level view for model selection decisions.
Why both levels for all models?
Running every model on both levels reveals two things that a partial comparison cannot: (1) whether a model’s behaviour changes substantially with input length and aggregation, and (2) whether the performance advantages of sentence-embedding models over TF-IDF/Word2Vec are consistent across scales. TF-IDF and Word2Vec are expected to perform poorly at the individual level due to sparse lexical overlap. Seeing that failure empirically, alongside the scores each model assigns to the same conceptually similar pairs, is the evidence needed to justify model choices.
Cross-level similarity scores are not directly comparable — the units differ (64 documents vs many individual responses). Cross-model comparisons are run within each group separately. The distributions section gives the best high-level view of how each model behaves across both levels.
All models × both levels:
| TF-IDF | W2V lvl2a |
W2V lvl1a |
BERT | BERTweet | para-MiniLM | MiniLM | mpnet | para-mpnet | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A — combMIMC | A1 | A2 | A3 | A4 | A5 | A6 | A7 | A8 | A9 |
| B — individual | B1 | B2 | B3 | B4 | B5 | B6 | B7 | B8 | B9 |
Using virtual environment '/Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/.virtualenvs/r-reticulate' ...+ /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/.virtualenvs/r-reticulate/bin/python -m pip install --upgrade --no-user pandas numpy scikit-learn scipy matplotlib seaborn sentence-transformers torch gensim/Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/.virtualenvs/r-reticulate/lib/python3.9/site-packages/urllib3/__init__.py:35: NotOpenSSLWarning: urllib3 v2 only supports OpenSSL 1.1.1+, currently the 'ssl' module is compiled with 'LibreSSL 2.8.3'. See: https://github.com/urllib3/urllib3/issues/3020
warnings.warn(Output directory: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparisonShowing top/bottom 10 pairs per modelPython 3.9.6 (default, Jan 9 2026, 11:03:41)
[Clang 17.0.0 (clang-1700.6.4.2)]---------------------------------------------------- numpy 2.0.2 OK
pandas 2.3.3 OK
scipy 1.13.1 OK
sklearn 1.6.1 OK
matplotlib 3.9.4 OK
seaborn 0.13.2 OK
sentence_transformers 5.1.2 OK
torch 2.8.0 OK
gensim 4.4.0 OK
All package versions OK.combMIMC_lvl2a: 64 documents | columns: ['context_word', 'genre_code', 'clip_name', 'ClipContext_pair', 'GenreContext_pair', 'textMIMC_lvl2a', 'text_original']combMIMC_lvl1a: 64 documents | columns: ['context_word', 'genre_code', 'clip_name', 'ClipContext_pair', 'GenreContext_pair', 'textMIMC_lvl1a', 'text_original']
dataMIMC_preprocessed: 1946 individual responses Original text column: 'descr_THOUGHT.text_spellchecked'Helper functions defined.Data: combMIMC_lvl2a.csv | Preprocessing: lvl2a (aggressive)
Bag-of-words similarity: texts are similar only if they share rare words. No understanding of meaning — “furious” and “angry” score zero similarity. Expected to be most meaningful at the aggregated level where documents are long enough for word overlap to be informative.
=================================================================A1 — TF-IDF (combMIMC_lvl2a)================================================================= Pairs: 2,016 | skipped — identical: 0 | short (<5 words): 0 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.3213 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / movie
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
Model A: mystery crime black white main character detective woman red dress seem old school endofinput character sit drink alone bad news receive endofinput lowkey speakeasy popular place quiet one hidden gem place antique furniture low light endofinput nothing specific come late night old character walk alo…
Model B: cosy endofinput bedroom study important exam various book open read endofinput youd expect hear hero enter villain lounge noir endofinput speakeasy black white brown filter whose name maybe detective drinking hard day endofinput character cafe dim warm yellowish lighting endofinput fresh start new o…
[2] Sim=0.3080 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / concert
── Original A: feels very busy like i am driving around doing something important something is happening going on or i have a task i need to do urgently | makes me think of those gaming bars where you drink and they have old games consoles like pac man etc or in a 70s 80s 90s themed bar | i imagined being in rave …
── Original B: i thought about an old sonic game i thought about the original sonic map and sonic running around i thought about the jumping noise that he makes | myself playing contra its a video game in my bedroom sitting on the floor with my back against my bed | a rave lots of strobe lighting and people jumpin…
Model A: feel busy drive around something important something happen go task need urgently endofinput drink old console pac man etc theme endofinput rave several lead strobe light everyones fun dance around partner endofinput feel rip straight level shovel knight dunno though never beat theyll laugh straight…
Model B: old sonic original sonic map sonic run around jumping noise endofinput contra bedroom sit floor back bed endofinput rave lot strobe lighting people jump huge room full people light strobe flashing light endofinput start start blade couple second switch classic grow family gamers bos metroid old doom…
[3] Sim=0.2920 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / concert
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
Model A: mystery crime black white main character detective woman red dress seem old school endofinput character sit drink alone bad news receive endofinput lowkey speakeasy popular place quiet one hidden gem place antique furniture low light endofinput nothing specific come late night old character walk alo…
Model B: restaurant maybe usa rather uk calm evening meal probably somewhere quite posh endofinput mind see similar one might see couple dancing nearby color woman stage take break air fill smell cigarette smoke body odour endofinput feel nice cozy nook endofinput give dim lit nightclub performer people side…
[4] Sim=0.2891 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Jaz_MED_07 / movie
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
Model A: restaurant maybe usa rather uk calm evening meal probably somewhere quite posh endofinput mind see similar one might see couple dancing nearby color woman stage take break air fill smell cigarette smoke body odour endofinput feel nice cozy nook endofinput give dim lit nightclub performer people side…
Model B: cosy endofinput bedroom study important exam various book open read endofinput youd expect hear hero enter villain lounge noir endofinput speakeasy black white brown filter whose name maybe detective drinking hard day endofinput character cafe dim warm yellowish lighting endofinput fresh start new o…
[5] Sim=0.2845 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Jaz_MED_07 / videogame
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
Model A: cosy endofinput bedroom study important exam various book open read endofinput youd expect hear hero enter villain lounge noir endofinput speakeasy black white brown filter whose name maybe detective drinking hard day endofinput character cafe dim warm yellowish lighting endofinput fresh start new o…
Model B: anything maybe end credit something something sad emotional youd hear reflect life drink alone endofinput fit character walk high end club specifically new york city fit slow move endofinput self old school slow dance friend sip glass wine endofinput classic lounge prohibition era speakeasy somethin…
[6] Sim=0.2837 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
Model A: mystery crime black white main character detective woman red dress seem old school endofinput character sit drink alone bad news receive endofinput lowkey speakeasy popular place quiet one hidden gem place antique furniture low light endofinput nothing specific come late night old character walk alo…
Model B: anything maybe end credit something something sad emotional youd hear reflect life drink alone endofinput fit character walk high end club specifically new york city fit slow move endofinput self old school slow dance friend sip glass wine endofinput classic lounge prohibition era speakeasy somethin…
[7] Sim=0.2818 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / videogame
── Original A: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
── Original B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
Model A: dynamic sway someone care sit drink alone life something important endofinput new york city cocktail flow old clientele everyone nicely dress atmospheric lighting endofinput self watch live feel nostalgic nod head rhythm endofinput felt old tv show someone sit alone wait someone never show endofinpu…
Model B: anything maybe end credit something something sad emotional youd hear reflect life drink alone endofinput fit character walk high end club specifically new york city fit slow move endofinput self old school slow dance friend sip glass wine endofinput classic lounge prohibition era speakeasy somethin…
[8] Sim=0.2811 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Jaz_MED_07 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
Model A: restaurant maybe usa rather uk calm evening meal probably somewhere quite posh endofinput mind see similar one might see couple dancing nearby color woman stage take break air fill smell cigarette smoke body odour endofinput feel nice cozy nook endofinput give dim lit nightclub performer people side…
Model B: anything maybe end credit something something sad emotional youd hear reflect life drink alone endofinput fit character walk high end club specifically new york city fit slow move endofinput self old school slow dance friend sip glass wine endofinput classic lounge prohibition era speakeasy somethin…
[9] Sim=0.2752 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs Ele_LOW_09 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
── Original B: very charged sounds like a song i have heard before in an advert about you would not steal a blank feels like its telling you something feels important or like you need to be paying attention | gave much more upbeat energy imagining a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around o…
Model A: car chase action endofinput drive fly car future weave traffic endofinput science fiction cyberpunk style space build massive fight endofinput seem adventure maybe blade runner endofinput thing dance night club everyone black shadow bluish white light flash endofinput relate overcome struggle victor…
Model B: charged hear advert steal blank feel tell something feel important need pay attention endofinput give much upbeat energy car racing street night neon light around high speed chase endofinput introduction gta back xbox turn go gta wait whole load hearing background endofinput dimly lit dance hall bri…
[10] Sim=0.2745 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Jaz_MED_02 / movie
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
Model A: restaurant maybe usa rather uk calm evening meal probably somewhere quite posh endofinput mind see similar one might see couple dancing nearby color woman stage take break air fill smell cigarette smoke body odour endofinput feel nice cozy nook endofinput give dim lit nightclub performer people side…
Model B: christmas two people posh restaurant endofinput slow dance endofinput see stage side curtain slow raise show beautifully dress woman endofinput smokey club enjoy vibe endofinput seem classic gentleman get home work smoke cigar taking hat endofinput felt new york light orange warm room full people re…
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.0501 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Ele_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: very heavy rock not for me somewhere that i do not belong did not enjoy | middle aged men who ride motorbikes with long grey beards mosh pits dark night time concert loud headbanging | i imagined my self watching a bunch of heavy metal songs with my favorite headset on | it felt like i was at a meta…
── Original B: i could see a loading screen for a video game an anime girl sitting on a seat in the window knees to her chest its cozy but also futuristic outside the window it seems to be raining above a cityscape we seem to be very high above the ground the clouds are blocking the view downwards | i felt a space…
Model A: heavy somewhere belong enjoy endofinput middle age men ride motorbike long grey beard mosh pit dark night time loud headbanging endofinput self watch bunch heavy favorite headset endofinput felt melodic death endofinput sort different kind expect bit shout hint endofinput cacophony noise synonymous …
Model B: see loading screen anime girl sit seat window knee chest cozy also futuristic outside window seem rain cityscape seem high ground cloud block view downwards endofinput felt spacey chill vibe endofinput give nostalgic feel cousin afternoon summer endofinput weird alien vibe kind surface planet nothin…
[2] Sim=0.0507 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good | not sure where this would fit cannot especially imagine it working very well | sort of reminds me of a few racing mobile games i used to play on my first real smartphone very nostalgic | tha…
Model A: restaurant maybe usa rather uk calm evening meal probably somewhere quite posh endofinput mind see similar one might see couple dancing nearby color woman stage take break air fill smell cigarette smoke body odour endofinput feel nice cozy nook endofinput give dim lit nightclub performer people side…
Model B: charge maybe something battle hype possibly end credit mean good endofinput sure fit especially work well endofinput sort racing mobile use first real smartphone nostalgic endofinput avenged sevenfold endofinput hero endofinput usually beginning adventure subway surf sport car racing endofinput soni…
[3] Sim=0.0543 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles | first thought was the greatest video game of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s jazz club or a prohibition era speakeasy | at first i could imagine a browser window with a cafe ambient video playing and then i coul…
── Original B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good | not sure where this would fit cannot especially imagine it working very well | sort of reminds me of a few racing mobile games i used to play on my first real smartphone very nostalgic | tha…
Model A: kid spend afternoon grandma jigsaw puzzle endofinput first great time la noir straight club prohibition era speakeasy endofinput first browser window cafe ambient see universtys starbucks full view saw inside though id step inside watch student sip coffee tap away laptop endofinput bring back ex par…
Model B: charge maybe something battle hype possibly end credit mean good endofinput sure fit especially work well endofinput sort racing mobile use first real smartphone nostalgic endofinput avenged sevenfold endofinput hero endofinput usually beginning adventure subway surf sport car racing endofinput soni…
[4] Sim=0.0545 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_21 / movie vs Met_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: very peppy like lift music again feels busy like you need to do something maybe walking through a shopping center listening to this in the background | fun supermarket shopping scene in a coming of age movie | reminds me of a tom jerry show i used to watch the sound track playing in the background w…
── Original B: i thought about being at corp nightclub in sheffield on a saturday night aka my worst nightmare grimy and music that i absolutely hate | i thought of a superhero movie but then when the vocals came in my mind went blank | our hero has reached a breaking point and plans to kick so major butt someone …
Model A: peppy lift feels busy need something maybe walk shopping center listen background endofinput fun supermarket shop come age endofinput tom jerry show use watch track background tom jerry mischievous usual endofinput cute little cafe simulator kind endofinput whimsical endofinput typical cartoon kid s…
Model B: corp nightclub sheffield saturday night aka bad nightmare grimy absolutely hate endofinput superhero vocal come mind go blank endofinput hero reach breaking point plan kick major butt someone mess wrong person pack bag put clothes medical supply weapon anything may need take big guy leave industrial…
[5] Sim=0.0574 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs Met_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good | not sure where this would fit cannot especially imagine it working very well | sort of reminds me of a few racing mobile games i used to play on my first real smartphone very nostalgic | tha…
Model A: mystery crime black white main character detective woman red dress seem old school endofinput character sit drink alone bad news receive endofinput lowkey speakeasy popular place quiet one hidden gem place antique furniture low light endofinput nothing specific come late night old character walk alo…
Model B: charge maybe something battle hype possibly end credit mean good endofinput sure fit especially work well endofinput sort racing mobile use first real smartphone nostalgic endofinput avenged sevenfold endofinput hero endofinput usually beginning adventure subway surf sport car racing endofinput soni…
[6] Sim=0.0590 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_21 / bar vs Met_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: phoning some company for help and then being put on hold for a long time while this music plays | it sounds like elevator music or the music you get on a call when you are put on hold would also fit a generic supermarket in a movie | music in some sort of speakeasy if you have ever watched broad cit…
── Original B: i thought about being at corp nightclub in sheffield on a saturday night aka my worst nightmare grimy and music that i absolutely hate | i thought of a superhero movie but then when the vocals came in my mind went blank | our hero has reached a breaking point and plans to kick so major butt someone …
Model A: phone company help put hold long time endofinput elevator get call put hold also fit generic supermarket endofinput sort speakeasy ever watch broad city theres episode abi turn gail speakeasy endofinput first thing old jetsons cartoon marimba marimba type front endofinput capture explore new place m…
Model B: corp nightclub sheffield saturday night aka bad nightmare grimy absolutely hate endofinput superhero vocal come mind go blank endofinput hero reach breaking point plan kick major butt someone mess wrong person pack bag put clothes medical supply weapon anything may need take big guy leave industrial…
[7] Sim=0.0594 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_19 / concert vs Ele_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: very dynamic could see people dancing to this in a bar or somewhere similar jazzy very fun and upbeat | jazz club cocktails and high end ladies in fancy dresses and men in suits potentially some people up dancing at the front in a swing style | i imagined my self in the audience watching a live orch…
── Original B: i could see a loading screen for a video game an anime girl sitting on a seat in the window knees to her chest its cozy but also futuristic outside the window it seems to be raining above a cityscape we seem to be very high above the ground the clouds are blocking the view downwards | i felt a space…
Model A: dynamic see people dance somewhere similar jazzy fun upbeat endofinput club cocktail high end lady fancy dress men suit potentially people dance front swing style endofinput self audience watch live orchestra pay close attention small detail munch bucket p endofinput sort style anime maybe baccano m…
Model B: see loading screen anime girl sit seat window knee chest cozy also futuristic outside window seem rain cityscape seem high ground cloud block view downwards endofinput felt spacey chill vibe endofinput give nostalgic feel cousin afternoon summer endofinput weird alien vibe kind surface planet nothin…
[8] Sim=0.0594 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_13 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: sounds quite magical and whimsical | playing a video game and entering a new zone area | it sounded like an extended version of a 90s console start up sound | i imagined an 80s esque piece abstract at first with a navy blue background fog and cold white blue ambient lighting the last 13th of the son…
── Original B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good | not sure where this would fit cannot especially imagine it working very well | sort of reminds me of a few racing mobile games i used to play on my first real smartphone very nostalgic | tha…
Model A: quite magical whimsical endofinput enter new zone area endofinput extended version console start endofinput esque abstract first navy blue background fog cold white blue ambient light last th seem fit musical musical come mind endofinput relate circumstance new romantic relationship endofinput love …
Model B: charge maybe something battle hype possibly end credit mean good endofinput sure fit especially work well endofinput sort racing mobile use first real smartphone nostalgic endofinput avenged sevenfold endofinput hero endofinput usually beginning adventure subway surf sport car racing endofinput soni…
[9] Sim=0.0595 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / concert vs Met_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: i thought about my dad being in a jazz concert my dad loved jazz and wherever i hear it i think about him this song brought feelings of nostalgia and curiosity | i imagined myself walking into an empty church building where the music instruments are being tested before church service | it did not hi…
── Original B: i thought about being at corp nightclub in sheffield on a saturday night aka my worst nightmare grimy and music that i absolutely hate | i thought of a superhero movie but then when the vocals came in my mind went blank | our hero has reached a breaking point and plans to kick so major butt someone …
Model A: dad dad love wherever hear bring feeling nostalgia curiosity endofinput walk empty church building test church service endofinput hit right away la noir detective try interview attractive suspect try hide truth endofinput even though one present huge orchestra background man huge stadium stage man l…
Model B: corp nightclub sheffield saturday night aka bad nightmare grimy absolutely hate endofinput superhero vocal come mind go blank endofinput hero reach breaking point plan kick major butt someone mess wrong person pack bag put clothes medical supply weapon anything may need take big guy leave industrial…
[10] Sim=0.0598 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / bar vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: the music felt really 80s and so it was an image of a 80s style hawaiian bar with hula style decor | the music evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends | it made me think about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this music sound | i imagined mys…
── Original B: when i was much younger playing guitar hero | sounds like boss fight music straight out a jrpg like yakuza | a heavy metal guitar hero game playing guitar hero on the wii | i could imagine the screen for guitar hero on display and someone playing with their friend | this music evokes the sense of fr…
Model A: felt really style hawaiian hula style decor endofinput evoke feeling want dance friend endofinput husband miss want dance laugh listen endofinput friend celebratory mood saxophonist give u special solo help u enjoy already happy night endofinput course somebody drink go severally great endofinput in…
Model B: much young hero endofinput bos fight straight jrpg yakuza endofinput heavy hero hero wii endofinput screen hero display someone friend endofinput evoke sense freedom adventure endofinput burst fireon top worldcare freejust let go feel rhythm endofinput combat multiplayer get ready battle feel fully …Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_A1_tfidf.png
lvl2a)Data: combMIMC_lvl2a.csv | Preprocessing: lvl2a (aggressive)
Static word embeddings averaged per document. Captures semantic relatedness (“furious” ≈ “angry”) unlike TF-IDF, but loses word order and sentence structure.
Pre-trained
word2vec-google-news-300vectors (~1.6 GB). Downloads once and caches.
=================================================================A2 — Word2Vec lvl2a (combMIMC_lvl2a)=================================================================Loaded Word2Vec from cache. Pairs: 2,016 | skipped — identical: 0 | short (<5 words): 0 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.9782 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / videogame
── Original A: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
── Original B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
Model A: dynamic sway someone care sit drink alone life something important endofinput new york city cocktail flow old clientele everyone nicely dress atmospheric lighting endofinput self watch live feel nostalgic nod head rhythm endofinput felt old tv show someone sit alone wait someone never show endofinpu…
Model B: anything maybe end credit something something sad emotional youd hear reflect life drink alone endofinput fit character walk high end club specifically new york city fit slow move endofinput self old school slow dance friend sip glass wine endofinput classic lounge prohibition era speakeasy somethin…
[2] Sim=0.9749 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / concert
── Original A: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
── Original B: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
Model A: dynamic sway someone care sit drink alone life something important endofinput new york city cocktail flow old clientele everyone nicely dress atmospheric lighting endofinput self watch live feel nostalgic nod head rhythm endofinput felt old tv show someone sit alone wait someone never show endofinpu…
Model B: restaurant maybe usa rather uk calm evening meal probably somewhere quite posh endofinput mind see similar one might see couple dancing nearby color woman stage take break air fill smell cigarette smoke body odour endofinput feel nice cozy nook endofinput give dim lit nightclub performer people side…
[3] Sim=0.9738 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Jaz_MED_07 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
Model A: restaurant maybe usa rather uk calm evening meal probably somewhere quite posh endofinput mind see similar one might see couple dancing nearby color woman stage take break air fill smell cigarette smoke body odour endofinput feel nice cozy nook endofinput give dim lit nightclub performer people side…
Model B: anything maybe end credit something something sad emotional youd hear reflect life drink alone endofinput fit character walk high end club specifically new york city fit slow move endofinput self old school slow dance friend sip glass wine endofinput classic lounge prohibition era speakeasy somethin…
[4] Sim=0.9732 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / bar
── Original A: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
── Original B: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
Model A: dynamic sway someone care sit drink alone life something important endofinput new york city cocktail flow old clientele everyone nicely dress atmospheric lighting endofinput self watch live feel nostalgic nod head rhythm endofinput felt old tv show someone sit alone wait someone never show endofinpu…
Model B: mystery crime black white main character detective woman red dress seem old school endofinput character sit drink alone bad news receive endofinput lowkey speakeasy popular place quiet one hidden gem place antique furniture low light endofinput nothing specific come late night old character walk alo…
[5] Sim=0.9731 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_14 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: sounds very dramatic very video game music | i imagined chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways | another piece that sounds like boss music in a jrpg or an arcade game that has a time trial on it like a light gun game | long haired metal fans listening to some sort metal music it felt sim…
── Original B: i thought about being in a rock concert with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the guitar solo | one of those white people music concerts where the artist plays a guitar …
Model A: dramatic endofinput chase someone twist small alleyway endofinput another bos jrpg arcade time trial light gun endofinput long haired fan listen sort felt similar fire flame endofinput thing browser window youtube spotify recommended track part mix endofinput relate moment joy dancing celebrate frie…
Model B: friend see look right leave middle huge body people see friend jump enjoy solo endofinput one white people artist go wild niche thing know fan endofinput crowd one big mass everyone surge forward lot light fire around stage dance endofinput kind last one thing someone use know love kiss part good sa…
[6] Sim=0.9730 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
Model A: mystery crime black white main character detective woman red dress seem old school endofinput character sit drink alone bad news receive endofinput lowkey speakeasy popular place quiet one hidden gem place antique furniture low light endofinput nothing specific come late night old character walk alo…
Model B: anything maybe end credit something something sad emotional youd hear reflect life drink alone endofinput fit character walk high end club specifically new york city fit slow move endofinput self old school slow dance friend sip glass wine endofinput classic lounge prohibition era speakeasy somethin…
[7] Sim=0.9713 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / concert
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
Model A: mystery crime black white main character detective woman red dress seem old school endofinput character sit drink alone bad news receive endofinput lowkey speakeasy popular place quiet one hidden gem place antique furniture low light endofinput nothing specific come late night old character walk alo…
Model B: restaurant maybe usa rather uk calm evening meal probably somewhere quite posh endofinput mind see similar one might see couple dancing nearby color woman stage take break air fill smell cigarette smoke body odour endofinput feel nice cozy nook endofinput give dim lit nightclub performer people side…
[8] Sim=0.9708 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_19 / bar vs Jaz_LOW_19 / movie
── Original A: this felt like i was in an american jazz bar i think american because i havent been to a british one and i have seen plenty of american ones in tv and film maybe i would be drinking a cocktail | at first it sounded like something out of a mario bros game and then when the main section came in it was…
── Original B: i thought about a super mario video game the tune was very similar to the background music in most mario games it made me think about super mario odyssey which was the last mario game that i played | those soccer games where you are picking your teams and setting up formation before the game itself …
Model A: felt american american havent british one see plenty american one tv maybe drink cocktail endofinput first something mario bros main section come sit endofinput see see people dance string flapper dress fly men slide lady around leg shoulder everyone smile fun endofinput slow first really start groo…
Model B: super mario tune similar background mario super mario odyssey last mario endofinput soccer pick team set formation start endofinput old set people dance couple throughout room quite lively fun endofinput well something first part low half ruin first part go pipe super mario collect coin level really…
[9] Sim=0.9699 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / bar vs Met_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: i thought of movies where they are at a concert like school of rock or something similar and they are in a mosh pit | i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold song was playing whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on …
── Original B: i imagined that i was watching a film that has a montage scene like an action comedy one i could not actively imagine being at a concert like this | a heavy metal gig or festival | when i hear this i think of my sister and i as kids listening to music like this banging our heads pretending to play a…
Model A: school something similar mosh pit endofinput see computer desk kid open spotify see avenge sevenfold whilst homework computer talk friend facebook time loud hear mother say walk lean take wired headphone plug computer tower listen endofinput early hard speed endofinput high school finally get perfor…
Model B: watch montage action comedy one actively endofinput heavy gig festival endofinput hear sister kid listen bang head pretend air hair get crazy always much fun battle endofinput dethklok thunderhorse great endofinput kid get bull finally get revenge guy mess endofinput discomfort really iron maiden ac…
[10] Sim=0.9697 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / movie vs Jaz_MED_07 / videogame
── Original A: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
── Original B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
Model A: christmas two people posh restaurant endofinput slow dance endofinput see stage side curtain slow raise show beautifully dress woman endofinput smokey club enjoy vibe endofinput seem classic gentleman get home work smoke cigar taking hat endofinput felt new york light orange warm room full people re…
Model B: anything maybe end credit something something sad emotional youd hear reflect life drink alone endofinput fit character walk high end club specifically new york city fit slow move endofinput self old school slow dance friend sip glass wine endofinput classic lounge prohibition era speakeasy somethin…
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.8114 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: a mix of things that should not be together does not sound right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a movie it would fit sounded confusing | the clip reminds me of a popular jason statham action movie i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or …
Model A: cosy endofinput bedroom study important exam various book open read endofinput youd expect hear hero enter villain lounge noir endofinput speakeasy black white brown filter whose name maybe detective drinking hard day endofinput character cafe dim warm yellowish lighting endofinput fresh start new o…
Model B: mix thing together right mesh well much go sure part fit confuse endofinput popular jason statham action watch year ago main actor chase bad guy cop endofinput someone put backing modern take mega man big fight modernize rom hack endofinput felt envision suspenseful bos fight endofinput quite fast u…
[2] Sim=0.8165 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / bar vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: the music felt really 80s and so it was an image of a 80s style hawaiian bar with hula style decor | the music evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends | it made me think about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this music sound | i imagined mys…
── Original B: a mix of things that should not be together does not sound right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a movie it would fit sounded confusing | the clip reminds me of a popular jason statham action movie i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or …
Model A: felt really style hawaiian hula style decor endofinput evoke feeling want dance friend endofinput husband miss want dance laugh listen endofinput friend celebratory mood saxophonist give u special solo help u enjoy already happy night endofinput course somebody drink go severally great endofinput in…
Model B: mix thing together right mesh well much go sure part fit confuse endofinput popular jason statham action watch year ago main actor chase bad guy cop endofinput someone put backing modern take mega man big fight modernize rom hack endofinput felt envision suspenseful bos fight endofinput quite fast u…
[3] Sim=0.8183 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / bar vs Met_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: the music felt really 80s and so it was an image of a 80s style hawaiian bar with hula style decor | the music evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends | it made me think about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this music sound | i imagined mys…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago | i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams do…
Model A: felt really style hawaiian hula style decor endofinput evoke feeling want dance friend endofinput husband miss want dance laugh listen endofinput friend celebratory mood saxophonist give u special solo help u enjoy already happy night endofinput course somebody drink go severally great endofinput in…
Model B: pokemon maybe battle maybe episode wouldve watch year ago endofinput see big futuristic bos well arm character flit around dodge slam sword attack whilst manage get attack bos slam sword character run along take bos endofinput enjoy seem mashup genre endofinput immediately scenario police chase race…
[4] Sim=0.8189 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Met_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago | i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams do…
Model A: cosy endofinput bedroom study important exam various book open read endofinput youd expect hear hero enter villain lounge noir endofinput speakeasy black white brown filter whose name maybe detective drinking hard day endofinput character cafe dim warm yellowish lighting endofinput fresh start new o…
Model B: pokemon maybe battle maybe episode wouldve watch year ago endofinput see big futuristic bos well arm character flit around dodge slam sword attack whilst manage get attack bos slam sword character run along take bos endofinput enjoy seem mashup genre endofinput immediately scenario police chase race…
[5] Sim=0.8277 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: cosy endofinput bedroom study important exam various book open read endofinput youd expect hear hero enter villain lounge noir endofinput speakeasy black white brown filter whose name maybe detective drinking hard day endofinput character cafe dim warm yellowish lighting endofinput fresh start new o…
Model B: friend mario kart try endofinput arcade machine endofinput pac man annoying irritating sort pixelated endofinput pixelated combination scroller move leave right paper mario fighting mortal kombat endofinput capture moment party celebration endofinput alive strong care freemind blowing endofinput fel…
[6] Sim=0.8279 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / bar vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: the music felt really 80s and so it was an image of a 80s style hawaiian bar with hula style decor | the music evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends | it made me think about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this music sound | i imagined mys…
── Original B: when i was much younger playing guitar hero | sounds like boss fight music straight out a jrpg like yakuza | a heavy metal guitar hero game playing guitar hero on the wii | i could imagine the screen for guitar hero on display and someone playing with their friend | this music evokes the sense of fr…
Model A: felt really style hawaiian hula style decor endofinput evoke feeling want dance friend endofinput husband miss want dance laugh listen endofinput friend celebratory mood saxophonist give u special solo help u enjoy already happy night endofinput course somebody drink go severally great endofinput in…
Model B: much young hero endofinput bos fight straight jrpg yakuza endofinput heavy hero hero wii endofinput screen hero display someone friend endofinput evoke sense freedom adventure endofinput burst fireon top worldcare freejust let go feel rhythm endofinput combat multiplayer get ready battle feel fully …
[7] Sim=0.8323 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Met_LOW_09 / videogame
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: i thought about playing guitar hero with friends in my friends garage this made me nostalgic to my junior high days where everything was easy there were no bills and i just spent time with friends doing dumb things | the music that starts just before an epic boss fight and the boss is revealed and s…
Model A: cosy endofinput bedroom study important exam various book open read endofinput youd expect hear hero enter villain lounge noir endofinput speakeasy black white brown filter whose name maybe detective drinking hard day endofinput character cafe dim warm yellowish lighting endofinput fresh start new o…
Model B: hero friend friend garage nostalgic junior high day everything easy bill spent time friend dumb thing endofinput start epic bos fight bos reveal start hunt main character endofinput avenged sevenfold crowd head bang light flash around fire endofinput felt old wwe early main menu cut famous real wwe …
[8] Sim=0.8329 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: when i was much younger playing guitar hero | sounds like boss fight music straight out a jrpg like yakuza | a heavy metal guitar hero game playing guitar hero on the wii | i could imagine the screen for guitar hero on display and someone playing with their friend | this music evokes the sense of fr…
Model A: cosy endofinput bedroom study important exam various book open read endofinput youd expect hear hero enter villain lounge noir endofinput speakeasy black white brown filter whose name maybe detective drinking hard day endofinput character cafe dim warm yellowish lighting endofinput fresh start new o…
Model B: much young hero endofinput bos fight straight jrpg yakuza endofinput heavy hero hero wii endofinput screen hero display someone friend endofinput evoke sense freedom adventure endofinput burst fireon top worldcare freejust let go feel rhythm endofinput combat multiplayer get ready battle feel fully …
[9] Sim=0.8342 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Met_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: i thought about being at corp nightclub in sheffield on a saturday night aka my worst nightmare grimy and music that i absolutely hate | i thought of a superhero movie but then when the vocals came in my mind went blank | our hero has reached a breaking point and plans to kick so major butt someone …
Model A: cosy endofinput bedroom study important exam various book open read endofinput youd expect hear hero enter villain lounge noir endofinput speakeasy black white brown filter whose name maybe detective drinking hard day endofinput character cafe dim warm yellowish lighting endofinput fresh start new o…
Model B: corp nightclub sheffield saturday night aka bad nightmare grimy absolutely hate endofinput superhero vocal come mind go blank endofinput hero reach breaking point plan kick major butt someone mess wrong person pack bag put clothes medical supply weapon anything may need take big guy leave industrial…
[10] Sim=0.8373 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Met_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good | not sure where this would fit cannot especially imagine it working very well | sort of reminds me of a few racing mobile games i used to play on my first real smartphone very nostalgic | tha…
Model A: cosy endofinput bedroom study important exam various book open read endofinput youd expect hear hero enter villain lounge noir endofinput speakeasy black white brown filter whose name maybe detective drinking hard day endofinput character cafe dim warm yellowish lighting endofinput fresh start new o…
Model B: charge maybe something battle hype possibly end credit mean good endofinput sure fit especially work well endofinput sort racing mobile use first real smartphone nostalgic endofinput avenged sevenfold endofinput hero endofinput usually beginning adventure subway surf sport car racing endofinput soni…Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_A2_w2v_lvl2a.png
lvl1a)Data: combMIMC_lvl1a.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
Same model as A2 on lighter-preprocessed text. Comparing A2 vs A3 isolates the preprocessing effect on Word2Vec. Comparing A3 vs A4 (BERT) isolates contextualisation, since both receive identical lvl1a input.
=================================================================A3 — Word2Vec lvl1a (combMIMC_lvl1a)================================================================= Pairs: 2,016 | skipped — identical: 0 | short (<5 words): 0 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.9882 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / bar vs Met_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: i thought of movies where they are at a concert like school of rock or something similar and they are in a mosh pit | i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold song was playing whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on …
── Original B: i imagined that i was watching a film that has a montage scene like an action comedy one i could not actively imagine being at a concert like this | a heavy metal gig or festival | when i hear this i think of my sister and i as kids listening to music like this banging our heads pretending to play a…
Model A: i of where they are at a school of or something similar and they are in a mosh pit endofinput i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold was whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on facebook at the time the is loud and …
Model B: i that i was watching a that has a montage an action comedy one i not actively being at a this endofinput a heavy gig or festival endofinput when i hear this i of my sister and i as kids listening to this banging our heads pretending to air our hair get all crazy but it was always so much fun to hav…
[2] Sim=0.9881 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_MED_19 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: i imagined that i was watching a film that has a montage scene like an action comedy one i could not actively imagine being at a concert like this | a heavy metal gig or festival | when i hear this i think of my sister and i as kids listening to music like this banging our heads pretending to play a…
── Original B: i thought about being in a rock concert with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the guitar solo | one of those white people music concerts where the artist plays a guitar …
Model A: i that i was watching a that has a montage an action comedy one i not actively being at a this endofinput a heavy gig or festival endofinput when i hear this i of my sister and i as kids listening to this banging our heads pretending to air our hair get all crazy but it was always so much fun to hav…
Model B: i about being in a with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the solo endofinput one of those white people where the artist a and they go wild but its a niche thing only kno…
[3] Sim=0.9873 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_MED_19 / movie vs Met_MED_20 / movie
── Original A: this scene reminded me of one of my favorite wrestlers his theme music during his entrance is extremely similar to this song i thought about watching him wrestling live with friends and having a great time | a music concert with drummers getting lit | i thought of a chase scene the protagonist is ru…
── Original B: driving my car really fast and recklessly while just about keeping it on the road | it sounded like anime credits or opening title sequence music | not a movie no idea what weird movie would have that music but a concert sounded like avenge sevenfold the sort of music video i used to see on kerrang …
Model A: this reminded me of one of my favorite wrestlers his theme during his entrance is extremely similar to this i about watching him wrestling live with friends and having a great time endofinput a with drummers getting lit endofinput i of a chase the protagonist is running through a city and jumping ov…
Model B: driving my car really fast and recklessly while just about keeping it on the road endofinput it anime credits or opening title sequence endofinput not a no idea what weird have that but a avenge sevenfold the sort of i used to see on kerrang endofinput the resonates my one lost in the night where i …
[4] Sim=0.9871 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / concert
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
Model A: i about a mystery or crime i about a black and white where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman the is in a red dress at a it seemed very old school to me endofinput a character sitting in a drinking all alone after a bad news he received endofinput it the that in a lowkey sp…
Model B: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
[5] Sim=0.9869 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / bar vs Met_MED_20 / movie
── Original A: i thought of movies where they are at a concert like school of rock or something similar and they are in a mosh pit | i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold song was playing whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on …
── Original B: driving my car really fast and recklessly while just about keeping it on the road | it sounded like anime credits or opening title sequence music | not a movie no idea what weird movie would have that music but a concert sounded like avenge sevenfold the sort of music video i used to see on kerrang …
Model A: i of where they are at a school of or something similar and they are in a mosh pit endofinput i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold was whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on facebook at the time the is loud and …
Model B: driving my car really fast and recklessly while just about keeping it on the road endofinput it anime credits or opening title sequence endofinput not a no idea what weird have that but a avenge sevenfold the sort of i used to see on kerrang endofinput the resonates my one lost in the night where i …
[6] Sim=0.9866 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Jaz_MED_02 / movie
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
Model A: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
Model B: i was of a in a christmas where two people are in a posh restaurant endofinput a or slow dance in a endofinput i can see a stage the on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to endofinput i myself in a smokey club just enjoying the vibes endofinput this see…
[7] Sim=0.9864 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / bar vs Met_MED_19 / movie
── Original A: i thought of movies where they are at a concert like school of rock or something similar and they are in a mosh pit | i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold song was playing whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on …
── Original B: this scene reminded me of one of my favorite wrestlers his theme music during his entrance is extremely similar to this song i thought about watching him wrestling live with friends and having a great time | a music concert with drummers getting lit | i thought of a chase scene the protagonist is ru…
Model A: i of where they are at a school of or something similar and they are in a mosh pit endofinput i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold was whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on facebook at the time the is loud and …
Model B: this reminded me of one of my favorite wrestlers his theme during his entrance is extremely similar to this i about watching him wrestling live with friends and having a great time endofinput a with drummers getting lit endofinput i of a chase the protagonist is running through a city and jumping ov…
[8] Sim=0.9863 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_14 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: sounds very dramatic very video game music | i imagined chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways | another piece that sounds like boss music in a jrpg or an arcade game that has a time trial on it like a light gun game | long haired metal fans listening to some sort metal music it felt sim…
── Original B: i thought about being in a rock concert with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the guitar solo | one of those white people music concerts where the artist plays a guitar …
Model A: very dramatic very endofinput i chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways endofinput another that boss in a jrpg or an arcade that has a time trial on it a light gun endofinput long haired fans listening to some sort it felt similar to that through the fire and flames endofinput the only th…
Model B: i about being in a with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the solo endofinput one of those white people where the artist a and they go wild but its a niche thing only kno…
[9] Sim=0.9861 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / movie vs Ele_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: well made quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad scene or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be | initially imagined it to be a piece playing over a sad moment of the movie however as the beat was added it fit more with …
── Original B: i thought about a memorial video because of the dark beat at the beginning it began to get more upbeat so it made me think more optimistic thoughts | those short minutes before the episode starts where they play the soundtrack that is what came to mind | sounds like a cutscene showing the main chara…
Model A: well quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be endofinput initially it to be a over a sad moment of the however as the beat was added it fit more with a coming of age endofinput me o…
Model B: i about a memorial because of the dark beat at the beginning it began to get more upbeat so it me more optimistic thoughts endofinput those short minutes before the episode starts where they the soundtrack that is what came to mind endofinput a cutscene showing the main character living their everyd…
[10] Sim=0.9861 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / concert vs Met_MED_19 / movie
── Original A: i thought about being in a rock concert with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the guitar solo | one of those white people music concerts where the artist plays a guitar …
── Original B: this scene reminded me of one of my favorite wrestlers his theme music during his entrance is extremely similar to this song i thought about watching him wrestling live with friends and having a great time | a music concert with drummers getting lit | i thought of a chase scene the protagonist is ru…
Model A: i about being in a with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the solo endofinput one of those white people where the artist a and they go wild but its a niche thing only kno…
Model B: this reminded me of one of my favorite wrestlers his theme during his entrance is extremely similar to this i about watching him wrestling live with friends and having a great time endofinput a with drummers getting lit endofinput i of a chase the protagonist is running through a city and jumping ov…
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.9117 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / bar vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: the music felt really 80s and so it was an image of a 80s style hawaiian bar with hula style decor | the music evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends | it made me think about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this music sound | i imagined mys…
── Original B: a mix of things that should not be together does not sound right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a movie it would fit sounded confusing | the clip reminds me of a popular jason statham action movie i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or …
Model A: the felt really 80s and so it was an of a 80s style hawaiian with hula style decor endofinput the evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends endofinput it me about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this endofinput i myself and a few friends in a …
Model B: a mix of things that should not be together does not right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a it fit confusing endofinput the me of a popular jason statham action i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or the cops endofinput this is what som…
[2] Sim=0.9141 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: a mix of things that should not be together does not sound right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a movie it would fit sounded confusing | the clip reminds me of a popular jason statham action movie i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or …
Model A: cosy endofinput in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read endofinput it was the youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains or lounge in a noir endofinput a in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i can not maybe a detective drinki…
Model B: a mix of things that should not be together does not right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a it fit confusing endofinput the me of a popular jason statham action i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or the cops endofinput this is what som…
[3] Sim=0.9163 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: cosy endofinput in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read endofinput it was the youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains or lounge in a noir endofinput a in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i can not maybe a detective drinki…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[4] Sim=0.9185 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / bar vs Met_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: the music felt really 80s and so it was an image of a 80s style hawaiian bar with hula style decor | the music evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends | it made me think about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this music sound | i imagined mys…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago | i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams do…
Model A: the felt really 80s and so it was an of a 80s style hawaiian with hula style decor endofinput the evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends endofinput it me about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this endofinput i myself and a few friends in a …
Model B: i was of a from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago endofinput i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams down his…
[5] Sim=0.9201 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / concert vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: very bland like lift music or something not something i would specifically think about or remember end credits again | middle aged people at the concert | i imagined walking in a clothing store forever 21 charlotte russe etc and hearing this song blasting from the speakers | it sounded like a bit pl…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: very bland lift or something not something i specifically about or end credits again endofinput middle aged people at the endofinput i walking in a clothing store forever 21 charlotte russe etc and hearing this blasting from the speakers endofinput it a bit played in a tv show or a very old not a at…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[6] Sim=0.9218 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Met_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago | i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams do…
Model A: cosy endofinput in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read endofinput it was the youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains or lounge in a noir endofinput a in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i can not maybe a detective drinki…
Model B: i was of a from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago endofinput i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams down his…
[7] Sim=0.9229 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles | first thought was the greatest video game of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s jazz club or a prohibition era speakeasy | at first i could imagine a browser window with a cafe ambient video playing and then i coul…
── Original B: a mix of things that should not be together does not sound right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a movie it would fit sounded confusing | the clip reminds me of a popular jason statham action movie i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or …
Model A: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles endofinput first was the greatest of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s club or a prohibition era speakeasy endofinput at first i a browser window with a cafe ambient and then i see my universtys starbucks in full vi…
Model B: a mix of things that should not be together does not right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a it fit confusing endofinput the me of a popular jason statham action i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or the cops endofinput this is what som…
[8] Sim=0.9238 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: the music felt really 80s and so it was an image of a 80s style hawaiian bar with hula style decor | the music evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends | it made me think about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this music sound | i imagined mys…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: the felt really 80s and so it was an of a 80s style hawaiian with hula style decor endofinput the evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends endofinput it me about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this endofinput i myself and a few friends in a …
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[9] Sim=0.9240 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: very bland like lift music or something not something i would specifically think about or remember end credits again | middle aged people at the concert | i imagined walking in a clothing store forever 21 charlotte russe etc and hearing this song blasting from the speakers | it sounded like a bit pl…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago | i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams do…
Model A: very bland lift or something not something i specifically about or end credits again endofinput middle aged people at the endofinput i walking in a clothing store forever 21 charlotte russe etc and hearing this blasting from the speakers endofinput it a bit played in a tv show or a very old not a at…
Model B: i was of a from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago endofinput i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams down his…
[10] Sim=0.9251 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: very bland like lift music or something not something i would specifically think about or remember end credits again | middle aged people at the concert | i imagined walking in a clothing store forever 21 charlotte russe etc and hearing this song blasting from the speakers | it sounded like a bit pl…
── Original B: a mix of things that should not be together does not sound right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a movie it would fit sounded confusing | the clip reminds me of a popular jason statham action movie i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or …
Model A: very bland lift or something not something i specifically about or end credits again endofinput middle aged people at the endofinput i walking in a clothing store forever 21 charlotte russe etc and hearing this blasting from the speakers endofinput it a bit played in a tv show or a very old not a at…
Model B: a mix of things that should not be together does not right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a it fit confusing endofinput the me of a popular jason statham action i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or the cops endofinput this is what som…Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_A3_w2v_lvl1a.png
Data: combMIMC_lvl1a.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
Contextualised embeddings with mean-pooling. Not fine-tuned for similarity, so the embedding space may not be optimally structured for cosine comparison — but it captures word meaning in context, unlike A3 (Word2Vec).
=================================================================A4 — BERT (combMIMC_lvl1a)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (64, 768) Pairs: 2,016 | skipped — identical: 0 | short (<5 words): 0 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.9834 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / bar vs Ele_MED_19 / movie
── Original A: this felt like i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing | a rainy day and a forest | i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the sky or is it t…
── Original B: well made quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad scene or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be | initially imagined it to be a piece playing over a sad moment of the movie however as the beat was added it fit more with …
Model A: this felt i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing endofinput a rainy day and a forest endofinput i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the s…
Model B: well quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be endofinput initially it to be a over a sad moment of the however as the beat was added it fit more with a coming of age endofinput me o…
[2] Sim=0.9815 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_LOW_02 / bar vs Jaz_MED_02 / bar
── Original A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged | made me imagine a high end bar with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young bar staff dressed in black and white | reminds me of back in the days my dad used to constantly play kenny…
── Original B: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
Model A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged endofinput me a high end with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young staff dressed in black and white endofinput me of back in the days my dad used to constantly kenny gs i wanted to …
Model B: very dynamic be swaying to the with someone you care about be sat with a drink alone about your life something important endofinput again in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting endofinput i my self watching a live and feeling nostalgic while n…
[3] Sim=0.9814 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / bar vs 80s_MED_13 / movie
── Original A: this felt like i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing | a rainy day and a forest | i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the sky or is it t…
── Original B: imagine it in a science fiction movie | i imagined the korean movies i used to binge watch when i was around the age of 14 to 16 i had just gotten back from school and after getting my assignments sorted out my favorite korean show was next in line | it sounded like it could be an introduction to so…
Model A: this felt i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing endofinput a rainy day and a forest endofinput i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the s…
Model B: it in a science fiction endofinput i the korean i used to binge watch when i was around the age of 14 to 16 i had just gotten back from school and after getting my assignments sorted out my favorite korean show was next in line endofinput it it be an introduction to some romantic tv show or endofinp…
[4] Sim=0.9813 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_21 / bar vs Jaz_LOW_21 / concert
── Original A: phoning some company for help and then being put on hold for a long time while this music plays | it sounds like elevator music or the music you get on a call when you are put on hold would also fit a generic supermarket in a movie | music in some sort of speakeasy if you have ever watched broad cit…
── Original B: a video game but not one in particular | i thought about a classic jazz band playing in a bar everyone is just enjoying the music and each others company had to think of a scene in my head because nothing came to me right away | for this i imagined a ragtime like scene in black and white with some c…
Model A: phoning some company for help and then being put on hold for a long time while this endofinput it elevator or the you get on a call when you are put on hold also fit a generic supermarket in a endofinput in some sort of speakeasy if you have ever watched broad city theres an episode where abi turns …
Model B: a but not one in particular endofinput i about a classic in a everyone is just enjoying the and each others company had to of a in my head because nothing came to me right away endofinput for this i a ragtime in black and white with some comedic aspects going on in a nice restaurant similar to the l…
[5] Sim=0.9810 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / movie vs Jaz_MED_07 / videogame
── Original A: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
── Original B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
Model A: i was of a in a christmas where two people are in a posh restaurant endofinput a or slow dance in a endofinput i can see a stage the on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to endofinput i myself in a smokey club just enjoying the vibes endofinput this see…
Model B: it did not a if anything maybe the end credits or something again something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a you reflect on your life while having a drink alone endofinput does not fit with what i for a but does me a character walking into a high end or club specifically in new york city…
[6] Sim=0.9804 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs Jaz_MED_02 / movie
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
Model A: i about a mystery or crime i about a black and white where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman the is in a red dress at a it seemed very old school to me endofinput a character sitting in a drinking all alone after a bad news he received endofinput it the that in a lowkey sp…
Model B: i was of a in a christmas where two people are in a posh restaurant endofinput a or slow dance in a endofinput i can see a stage the on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to endofinput i myself in a smokey club just enjoying the vibes endofinput this see…
[7] Sim=0.9799 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_MED_13 / movie vs Ele_MED_19 / movie
── Original A: imagine it in a science fiction movie | i imagined the korean movies i used to binge watch when i was around the age of 14 to 16 i had just gotten back from school and after getting my assignments sorted out my favorite korean show was next in line | it sounded like it could be an introduction to so…
── Original B: well made quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad scene or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be | initially imagined it to be a piece playing over a sad moment of the movie however as the beat was added it fit more with …
Model A: it in a science fiction endofinput i the korean i used to binge watch when i was around the age of 14 to 16 i had just gotten back from school and after getting my assignments sorted out my favorite korean show was next in line endofinput it it be an introduction to some romantic tv show or endofinp…
Model B: well quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be endofinput initially it to be a over a sad moment of the however as the beat was added it fit more with a coming of age endofinput me o…
[8] Sim=0.9799 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / movie
── Original A: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
── Original B: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
Model A: very dynamic be swaying to the with someone you care about be sat with a drink alone about your life something important endofinput again in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting endofinput i my self watching a live and feeling nostalgic while n…
Model B: cosy endofinput in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read endofinput it was the youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains or lounge in a noir endofinput a in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i can not maybe a detective drinki…
[9] Sim=0.9799 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_14 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: sounds very dramatic very video game music | i imagined chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways | another piece that sounds like boss music in a jrpg or an arcade game that has a time trial on it like a light gun game | long haired metal fans listening to some sort metal music it felt sim…
── Original B: i thought about being in a rock concert with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the guitar solo | one of those white people music concerts where the artist plays a guitar …
Model A: very dramatic very endofinput i chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways endofinput another that boss in a jrpg or an arcade that has a time trial on it a light gun endofinput long haired fans listening to some sort it felt similar to that through the fire and flames endofinput the only th…
Model B: i about being in a with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the solo endofinput one of those white people where the artist a and they go wild but its a niche thing only kno…
[10] Sim=0.9798 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_13 / concert vs 80s_MED_13 / movie
── Original A: sounds quite magical and whimsical | playing a video game and entering a new zone area | it sounded like an extended version of a 90s console start up sound | i imagined an 80s esque piece abstract at first with a navy blue background fog and cold white blue ambient lighting the last 13th of the son…
── Original B: imagine it in a science fiction movie | i imagined the korean movies i used to binge watch when i was around the age of 14 to 16 i had just gotten back from school and after getting my assignments sorted out my favorite korean show was next in line | it sounded like it could be an introduction to so…
Model A: quite magical and whimsical endofinput a and entering a new zone area endofinput it an extended version of a 90s console start up endofinput i an 80s esque abstract at first with a navy blue background fog and cold white blue ambient lighting the last 13th of the seemed fit for a musical but no musi…
Model B: it in a science fiction endofinput i the korean i used to binge watch when i was around the age of 14 to 16 i had just gotten back from school and after getting my assignments sorted out my favorite korean show was next in line endofinput it it be an introduction to some romantic tv show or endofinp…
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.9095 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[2] Sim=0.9114 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds futuristic ambient | the music relates to moments where one is traveling solo to explore new things | serenepeacefulthoughtful and peaceful | i felt at peace while listening to this it made me calm and feel present in the moment | this one reminds me of a nigerian movie i watched some time ba…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: futuristic ambient endofinput the relates to moments where one is traveling solo to explore new things endofinput serenepeacefulthoughtful and peaceful endofinput i felt at peace while listening to this it me calm and feel present in the moment endofinput this one me of a nigerian i watched some tim…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[3] Sim=0.9135 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: cosy endofinput in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read endofinput it was the youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains or lounge in a noir endofinput a in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i can not maybe a detective drinki…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[4] Sim=0.9136 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / movie vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: i was of a in a christmas where two people are in a posh restaurant endofinput a or slow dance in a endofinput i can see a stage the on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to endofinput i myself in a smokey club just enjoying the vibes endofinput this see…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[5] Sim=0.9182 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: the music felt really 80s and so it was an image of a 80s style hawaiian bar with hula style decor | the music evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends | it made me think about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this music sound | i imagined mys…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: the felt really 80s and so it was an of a 80s style hawaiian with hula style decor endofinput the evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends endofinput it me about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this endofinput i myself and a few friends in a …
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[6] Sim=0.9194 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / movie vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
── Original B: when i was much younger playing guitar hero | sounds like boss fight music straight out a jrpg like yakuza | a heavy metal guitar hero game playing guitar hero on the wii | i could imagine the screen for guitar hero on display and someone playing with their friend | this music evokes the sense of fr…
Model A: i was of a in a christmas where two people are in a posh restaurant endofinput a or slow dance in a endofinput i can see a stage the on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to endofinput i myself in a smokey club just enjoying the vibes endofinput this see…
Model B: when i was much younger hero endofinput boss fight straight out a jrpg yakuza endofinput a heavy hero hero on the wii endofinput i the screen for hero on display and someone with their friend endofinput this evokes the sense of freedom and adventure endofinput bursting with fireon top of the worldca…
[7] Sim=0.9200 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: very dynamic be swaying to the with someone you care about be sat with a drink alone about your life something important endofinput again in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting endofinput i my self watching a live and feeling nostalgic while n…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[8] Sim=0.9200 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: when i was much younger playing guitar hero | sounds like boss fight music straight out a jrpg like yakuza | a heavy metal guitar hero game playing guitar hero on the wii | i could imagine the screen for guitar hero on display and someone playing with their friend | this music evokes the sense of fr…
Model A: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
Model B: when i was much younger hero endofinput boss fight straight out a jrpg yakuza endofinput a heavy hero hero on the wii endofinput i the screen for hero on display and someone with their friend endofinput this evokes the sense of freedom and adventure endofinput bursting with fireon top of the worldca…
[9] Sim=0.9204 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: i about a mystery or crime i about a black and white where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman the is in a red dress at a it seemed very old school to me endofinput a character sitting in a drinking all alone after a bad news he received endofinput it the that in a lowkey sp…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[10] Sim=0.9212 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / concert vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like minecraft | late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window | sounds like the music youd hear in an indie game | i imagined a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes | the music r…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: minecraft endofinput late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window endofinput the youd hear in an indie endofinput i a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes endofinput the of shared and c…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_A4_bert.png
Data: combMIMC_lvl1a.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
BERTweet (vinai/bertweet-base) is a RoBERTa-based model pretrained on 850M English tweets. Its vocabulary and pretraining domain are oriented toward short, informal text — making it a meaningful contrast to bert-base-uncased (pretrained on books and Wikipedia) when applied to short individual MIMC descriptions. Max sequence length is 128 tokens. Like BERT, it is not fine-tuned for similarity, so embeddings are mean-pooled and compared via cosine similarity. Comparing A4 vs A5 isolates pretraining domain (formal vs informal text) while keeping architecture and similarity method constant.
=================================================================A5 — BERTweet (combMIMC_lvl1a)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (64, 768) Pairs: 2,016 | skipped — identical: 0 | short (<5 words): 0 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.9725 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs 80s_LOW_02 / movie
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: sounds like a movie scene set in a big city where the main character is depressed or wandering the streets at night | i could see a camera panning around a raining city somewhere hidden along the street is a bar where a detective is having a drink hes down on his luck and think the culprit is going …
Model A: i about a mystery or crime i about a black and white where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman the is in a red dress at a it seemed very old school to me endofinput a character sitting in a drinking all alone after a bad news he received endofinput it the that in a lowkey sp…
Model B: a set in a big city where the main character is depressed or wandering the streets at night endofinput i see a camera panning around a raining city somewhere hidden along the street is a where a detective is having a drink hes down on his luck and the culprit is going to get away but a woman is abou…
[2] Sim=0.9707 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Ele_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
── Original B: sounds like minecraft | late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window | sounds like the music youd hear in an indie game | i imagined a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes | the music r…
Model A: very dynamic be swaying to the with someone you care about be sat with a drink alone about your life something important endofinput again in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting endofinput i my self watching a live and feeling nostalgic while n…
Model B: minecraft endofinput late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window endofinput the youd hear in an indie endofinput i a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes endofinput the of shared and c…
[3] Sim=0.9692 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_21 / concert vs Jaz_MED_07 / concert
── Original A: a video game but not one in particular | i thought about a classic jazz band playing in a bar everyone is just enjoying the music and each others company had to think of a scene in my head because nothing came to me right away | for this i imagined a ragtime like scene in black and white with some c…
── Original B: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
Model A: a but not one in particular endofinput i about a classic in a everyone is just enjoying the and each others company had to of a in my head because nothing came to me right away endofinput for this i a ragtime in black and white with some comedic aspects going on in a nice restaurant similar to the l…
Model B: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
[4] Sim=0.9689 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / bar vs 80s_MED_08 / movie
── Original A: the music felt really 80s and so it was an image of a 80s style hawaiian bar with hula style decor | the music evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends | it made me think about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this music sound | i imagined mys…
── Original B: sounds like something from a sitcom | watching a kids show with my young child and then they start dancing | the music evokes the feeling of longing in a new place or destination | soothinginteresting laughter | i felt like i was a character in a movie and positive things were just happening to me s…
Model A: the felt really 80s and so it was an of a 80s style hawaiian with hula style decor endofinput the evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends endofinput it me about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this endofinput i myself and a few friends in a …
Model B: something from a sitcom endofinput watching a kids show with my young child and then they start dancing endofinput the evokes the feeling of longing in a new place or destination endofinput soothinginteresting laughter endofinput i felt i was a character in a and positive things were just happening …
[5] Sim=0.9684 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Jaz_MED_02 / movie
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
Model A: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
Model B: i was of a in a christmas where two people are in a posh restaurant endofinput a or slow dance in a endofinput i can see a stage the on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to endofinput i myself in a smokey club just enjoying the vibes endofinput this see…
[6] Sim=0.9679 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / concert
── Original A: this made me think about europe or a specific country where electric music is popular i thought about an outside concert where people are jumping up and down | dark room with some strobe lighting and a dance floor with a dj sitting behind it theres a lot of people and its really crowded everyone is …
── Original B: i thought about an old sonic game i thought about the original sonic map and sonic running around i thought about the jumping noise that he makes | myself playing contra its a video game in my bedroom sitting on the floor with my back against my bed | a rave lots of strobe lighting and people jumpin…
Model A: this me about europe or a specific country where electric is popular i about an outside where people are jumping up and down endofinput dark room with some strobe lighting and a dance floor with a dj sitting behind it theres a lot of people and its really crowded everyone is drinking or sitting next…
Model B: i about an old sonic i about the original sonic map and sonic running around i about the jumping noise that he endofinput myself contra its a in my bedroom sitting on the floor with my back against my bed endofinput a rave lots of strobe lighting and people jumping up and down its a huge room and it…
[7] Sim=0.9678 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / concert vs 80s_MED_08 / movie
── Original A: sounds very dramatic very video game music | i imagined chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways | another piece that sounds like boss music in a jrpg or an arcade game that has a time trial on it like a light gun game | long haired metal fans listening to some sort metal music it felt sim…
── Original B: sounds like something from a sitcom | watching a kids show with my young child and then they start dancing | the music evokes the feeling of longing in a new place or destination | soothinginteresting laughter | i felt like i was a character in a movie and positive things were just happening to me s…
Model A: very dramatic very endofinput i chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways endofinput another that boss in a jrpg or an arcade that has a time trial on it a light gun endofinput long haired fans listening to some sort it felt similar to that through the fire and flames endofinput the only th…
Model B: something from a sitcom endofinput watching a kids show with my young child and then they start dancing endofinput the evokes the feeling of longing in a new place or destination endofinput soothinginteresting laughter endofinput i felt i was a character in a and positive things were just happening …
[8] Sim=0.9677 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / bar vs Ele_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: sounds futuristic ambient | the music relates to moments where one is traveling solo to explore new things | serenepeacefulthoughtful and peaceful | i felt at peace while listening to this it made me calm and feel present in the moment | this one reminds me of a nigerian movie i watched some time ba…
── Original B: sounds like minecraft | late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window | sounds like the music youd hear in an indie game | i imagined a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes | the music r…
Model A: futuristic ambient endofinput the relates to moments where one is traveling solo to explore new things endofinput serenepeacefulthoughtful and peaceful endofinput i felt at peace while listening to this it me calm and feel present in the moment endofinput this one me of a nigerian i watched some tim…
Model B: minecraft endofinput late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window endofinput the youd hear in an indie endofinput i a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes endofinput the of shared and c…
[9] Sim=0.9665 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / concert vs 80s_LOW_06 / videogame
── Original A: i see a roller rink from the 80s bright colors people are talking and laughing the music is loud lights are dark and everything feels alive i can almost feel the air brushing past my face i as i skate around | it made me think of something retro mixed with something new age | this reminded me of the…
── Original B: a car ride in the 80s | i can see the camera panning around a somewhat busy street in an anime game it flies by people who are laughing and having fun were getting clips of different store fronts on the street introducing us to the new area | it reminded me of an old television type of theme song | …
Model A: i see a roller rink from the 80s bright colors people are talking and laughing the is loud lights are dark and everything feels alive i can almost feel the air brushing past my face i as i skate around endofinput it me of something retro mixed with something new age endofinput this reminded me of th…
Model B: a car ride in the 80s endofinput i can see the camera panning around a somewhat busy street in an anime it flies by people who are laughing and having fun were getting of different store fronts on the street introducing us to the new area endofinput it reminded me of an old television type of theme …
[10] Sim=0.9663 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / concert vs Ele_LOW_09 / videogame
── Original A: i felt like i was at a drum and bass concert i do not like that music or similar like in the clip and have never had enough energy to enjoy such a concert so it felt more annoying than emotionally good | a festival with strobe lights and a huge crowd | i can see a stage and a bunch of people in fron…
── Original B: very charged sounds like a song i have heard before in an advert about you would not steal a blank feels like its telling you something feels important or like you need to be paying attention | gave much more upbeat energy imagining a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around o…
Model A: i felt i was at a and bass i do not that or similar in the and have never had enough energy to enjoy such a so it felt more annoying than emotionally good endofinput a festival with strobe lights and a huge crowd endofinput i can see a stage and a bunch of people in front of me at an edm people are …
Model B: very charged a i have heard before in an advert about you not steal a blank feels its telling you something feels important or you need to be paying attention endofinput gave much more upbeat energy a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around or a high speed chase endofinput me…
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.8649 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / concert vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about being in a rock concert with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the guitar solo | one of those white people music concerts where the artist plays a guitar …
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: i about being in a with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the solo endofinput one of those white people where the artist a and they go wild but its a niche thing only kno…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[2] Sim=0.8738 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_19 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: very upbeat and metal i would never hear this in a bar it sounds like a rock concert or maybe end credits for a video game or something way too much going on to be played in a bar | cannot especially imagine this in a bar would more fit a club | its not even that i have a thought of where it should …
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: very upbeat and i never hear this in a it a or maybe end credits for a or something way too much going on to be played in a endofinput can not especially this in a more fit a club endofinput its not even that i have a of where it should be i just do not that in a its more at home in a hero than a if…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[3] Sim=0.8834 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_19 / bar vs Ele_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: very upbeat and metal i would never hear this in a bar it sounds like a rock concert or maybe end credits for a video game or something way too much going on to be played in a bar | cannot especially imagine this in a bar would more fit a club | its not even that i have a thought of where it should …
── Original B: i thought about a memorial video because of the dark beat at the beginning it began to get more upbeat so it made me think more optimistic thoughts | those short minutes before the episode starts where they play the soundtrack that is what came to mind | sounds like a cutscene showing the main chara…
Model A: very upbeat and i never hear this in a it a or maybe end credits for a or something way too much going on to be played in a endofinput can not especially this in a more fit a club endofinput its not even that i have a of where it should be i just do not that in a its more at home in a hero than a if…
Model B: i about a memorial because of the dark beat at the beginning it began to get more upbeat so it me more optimistic thoughts endofinput those short minutes before the episode starts where they the soundtrack that is what came to mind endofinput a cutscene showing the main character living their everyd…
[4] Sim=0.8894 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_19 / bar vs Jaz_MED_02 / concert
── Original A: very upbeat and metal i would never hear this in a bar it sounds like a rock concert or maybe end credits for a video game or something way too much going on to be played in a bar | cannot especially imagine this in a bar would more fit a club | its not even that i have a thought of where it should …
── Original B: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles | first thought was the greatest video game of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s jazz club or a prohibition era speakeasy | at first i could imagine a browser window with a cafe ambient video playing and then i coul…
Model A: very upbeat and i never hear this in a it a or maybe end credits for a or something way too much going on to be played in a endofinput can not especially this in a more fit a club endofinput its not even that i have a of where it should be i just do not that in a its more at home in a hero than a if…
Model B: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles endofinput first was the greatest of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s club or a prohibition era speakeasy endofinput at first i a browser window with a cafe ambient and then i see my universtys starbucks in full vi…
[5] Sim=0.8899 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / concert vs 80s_MED_08 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about being in a rock concert with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the guitar solo | one of those white people music concerts where the artist plays a guitar …
── Original B: overly upbeat no real emotions peppy too much | i imagined my self playing a nostalgic mobile game while this song plays as a sound track while i am going through the tutorial | that sounds like the opening theme or closing theme not sure now to some 80s sitcom not gonna specify which you can really…
Model A: i about being in a with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the solo endofinput one of those white people where the artist a and they go wild but its a niche thing only kno…
Model B: overly upbeat no real emotions peppy too much endofinput i my self a nostalgic mobile while this as a track while i am going through the tutorial endofinput that the opening theme or closing theme not sure now to some 80s sitcom not gon na specify which you can really just take your pic they all had…
[6] Sim=0.8929 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about being in a rock concert with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the guitar solo | one of those white people music concerts where the artist plays a guitar …
── Original B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good | not sure where this would fit cannot especially imagine it working very well | sort of reminds me of a few racing mobile games i used to play on my first real smartphone very nostalgic | tha…
Model A: i about being in a with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the solo endofinput one of those white people where the artist a and they go wild but its a niche thing only kno…
Model B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good endofinput not sure where this fit can not especially it working very well endofinput sort of me of a few racing mobile i used to on my first real smartphone very nostalgic endofinput that a w…
[7] Sim=0.8936 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_MED_20 / bar vs Met_MED_19 / bar
── Original A: sounds futuristic ambient | the music relates to moments where one is traveling solo to explore new things | serenepeacefulthoughtful and peaceful | i felt at peace while listening to this it made me calm and feel present in the moment | this one reminds me of a nigerian movie i watched some time ba…
── Original B: very upbeat and metal i would never hear this in a bar it sounds like a rock concert or maybe end credits for a video game or something way too much going on to be played in a bar | cannot especially imagine this in a bar would more fit a club | its not even that i have a thought of where it should …
Model A: futuristic ambient endofinput the relates to moments where one is traveling solo to explore new things endofinput serenepeacefulthoughtful and peaceful endofinput i felt at peace while listening to this it me calm and feel present in the moment endofinput this one me of a nigerian i watched some tim…
Model B: very upbeat and i never hear this in a it a or maybe end credits for a or something way too much going on to be played in a endofinput can not especially this in a more fit a club endofinput its not even that i have a of where it should be i just do not that in a its more at home in a hero than a if…
[8] Sim=0.8939 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i think about being in a bar and doing something with a lot of action involved i think about playing a sport or playing basketball with friends i also think about running on a treadmill and i also think about lifting weights | this prompted the image of a fight scene both people engaged in heavy com…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: i about being in a and doing something with a lot of action involved i about a sport or basketball with friends i also about running on a treadmill and i also about lifting weights endofinput this prompted the of a fight both people engaged in heavy combat using swords i did not a more a dimly lit r…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[9] Sim=0.8944 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i thought of movies where they are at a concert like school of rock or something similar and they are in a mosh pit | i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold song was playing whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on …
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: i of where they are at a school of or something similar and they are in a mosh pit endofinput i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold was whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on facebook at the time the is loud and …
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[10] Sim=0.8945 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_19 / bar vs 80s_MED_13 / movie
── Original A: very upbeat and metal i would never hear this in a bar it sounds like a rock concert or maybe end credits for a video game or something way too much going on to be played in a bar | cannot especially imagine this in a bar would more fit a club | its not even that i have a thought of where it should …
── Original B: imagine it in a science fiction movie | i imagined the korean movies i used to binge watch when i was around the age of 14 to 16 i had just gotten back from school and after getting my assignments sorted out my favorite korean show was next in line | it sounded like it could be an introduction to so…
Model A: very upbeat and i never hear this in a it a or maybe end credits for a or something way too much going on to be played in a endofinput can not especially this in a more fit a club endofinput its not even that i have a of where it should be i just do not that in a its more at home in a hero than a if…
Model B: it in a science fiction endofinput i the korean i used to binge watch when i was around the age of 14 to 16 i had just gotten back from school and after getting my assignments sorted out my favorite korean show was next in line endofinput it it be an introduction to some romantic tv show or endofinp…Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_A5_bertweet.png
Data: combMIMC_lvl1a.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
paraphrase-MiniLM-L6-v2 shares the MiniLM-L6 architecture with A7 but is fine-tuned specifically on paraphrase pairs rather than general semantic similarity pairs. Comparing A6 vs A7 (MiniLM) isolates the effect of fine-tuning objective (paraphrase detection vs broad semantic similarity) while holding architecture constant. Comparing A6 vs A9 (paraphrase-mpnet) isolates the architecture effect within the paraphrase objective.
=================================================================A6 — paraphrase-MiniLM-L6-v2 (combMIMC_lvl1a)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (64, 384) Pairs: 2,016 | skipped — identical: 0 | short (<5 words): 0 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.7614 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Jaz_MED_02 / movie
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
Model A: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
Model B: i was of a in a christmas where two people are in a posh restaurant endofinput a or slow dance in a endofinput i can see a stage the on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to endofinput i myself in a smokey club just enjoying the vibes endofinput this see…
[2] Sim=0.7488 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs Met_MED_20 / movie
── Original A: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
── Original B: driving my car really fast and recklessly while just about keeping it on the road | it sounded like anime credits or opening title sequence music | not a movie no idea what weird movie would have that music but a concert sounded like avenge sevenfold the sort of music video i used to see on kerrang …
Model A: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
Model B: driving my car really fast and recklessly while just about keeping it on the road endofinput it anime credits or opening title sequence endofinput not a no idea what weird have that but a avenge sevenfold the sort of i used to see on kerrang endofinput the resonates my one lost in the night where i …
[3] Sim=0.7421 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_MED_13 / concert vs Ele_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: sounds quite magical and whimsical | playing a video game and entering a new zone area | it sounded like an extended version of a 90s console start up sound | i imagined an 80s esque piece abstract at first with a navy blue background fog and cold white blue ambient lighting the last 13th of the son…
── Original B: sounds like minecraft | late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window | sounds like the music youd hear in an indie game | i imagined a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes | the music r…
Model A: quite magical and whimsical endofinput a and entering a new zone area endofinput it an extended version of a 90s console start up endofinput i an 80s esque abstract at first with a navy blue background fog and cold white blue ambient lighting the last 13th of the seemed fit for a musical but no musi…
Model B: minecraft endofinput late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window endofinput the youd hear in an indie endofinput i a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes endofinput the of shared and c…
[4] Sim=0.7390 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_MED_19 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / concert
── Original A: sounds like minecraft | late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window | sounds like the music youd hear in an indie game | i imagined a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes | the music r…
── Original B: sounds very dramatic very video game music | i imagined chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways | another piece that sounds like boss music in a jrpg or an arcade game that has a time trial on it like a light gun game | long haired metal fans listening to some sort metal music it felt sim…
Model A: minecraft endofinput late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window endofinput the youd hear in an indie endofinput i a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes endofinput the of shared and c…
Model B: very dramatic very endofinput i chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways endofinput another that boss in a jrpg or an arcade that has a time trial on it a light gun endofinput long haired fans listening to some sort it felt similar to that through the fire and flames endofinput the only th…
[5] Sim=0.7328 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / movie vs 80s_LOW_06 / videogame
── Original A: driving my car really fast and recklessly while just about keeping it on the road | it sounded like anime credits or opening title sequence music | not a movie no idea what weird movie would have that music but a concert sounded like avenge sevenfold the sort of music video i used to see on kerrang …
── Original B: a car ride in the 80s | i can see the camera panning around a somewhat busy street in an anime game it flies by people who are laughing and having fun were getting clips of different store fronts on the street introducing us to the new area | it reminded me of an old television type of theme song | …
Model A: driving my car really fast and recklessly while just about keeping it on the road endofinput it anime credits or opening title sequence endofinput not a no idea what weird have that but a avenge sevenfold the sort of i used to see on kerrang endofinput the resonates my one lost in the night where i …
Model B: a car ride in the 80s endofinput i can see the camera panning around a somewhat busy street in an anime it flies by people who are laughing and having fun were getting of different store fronts on the street introducing us to the new area endofinput it reminded me of an old television type of theme …
[6] Sim=0.7310 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
── Original B: when i was much younger playing guitar hero | sounds like boss fight music straight out a jrpg like yakuza | a heavy metal guitar hero game playing guitar hero on the wii | i could imagine the screen for guitar hero on display and someone playing with their friend | this music evokes the sense of fr…
Model A: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
Model B: when i was much younger hero endofinput boss fight straight out a jrpg yakuza endofinput a heavy hero hero on the wii endofinput i the screen for hero on display and someone with their friend endofinput this evokes the sense of freedom and adventure endofinput bursting with fireon top of the worldca…
[7] Sim=0.7195 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / videogame
── Original A: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
── Original B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
Model A: very dynamic be swaying to the with someone you care about be sat with a drink alone about your life something important endofinput again in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting endofinput i my self watching a live and feeling nostalgic while n…
Model B: it did not a if anything maybe the end credits or something again something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a you reflect on your life while having a drink alone endofinput does not fit with what i for a but does me a character walking into a high end or club specifically in new york city…
[8] Sim=0.7183 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs Jaz_LOW_19 / videogame
── Original A: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
── Original B: sounds like jazz like something from monsters inc | celebrating with friends at a party | its almost like two separate pieces of music but as two pieces theyd fit into a jrpg like persona or as one piece it could easily be some nintendo games menu music | at first i thought of a mario bros video gam…
Model A: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
Model B: something from monsters inc endofinput celebrating with friends at a party endofinput its almost two separate of but as two theyd fit into a jrpg persona or as one it easily be some nintendo menu endofinput at first i of a mario bros reboot because the beginning strongly a sped up yet pitched down f…
[9] Sim=0.7169 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / concert vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: sounds very dramatic very video game music | i imagined chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways | another piece that sounds like boss music in a jrpg or an arcade game that has a time trial on it like a light gun game | long haired metal fans listening to some sort metal music it felt sim…
── Original B: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
Model A: very dramatic very endofinput i chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways endofinput another that boss in a jrpg or an arcade that has a time trial on it a light gun endofinput long haired fans listening to some sort it felt similar to that through the fire and flames endofinput the only th…
Model B: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
[10] Sim=0.7163 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs 80s_LOW_02 / movie
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: sounds like a movie scene set in a big city where the main character is depressed or wandering the streets at night | i could see a camera panning around a raining city somewhere hidden along the street is a bar where a detective is having a drink hes down on his luck and think the culprit is going …
Model A: i about a mystery or crime i about a black and white where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman the is in a red dress at a it seemed very old school to me endofinput a character sitting in a drinking all alone after a bad news he received endofinput it the that in a lowkey sp…
Model B: a set in a big city where the main character is depressed or wandering the streets at night endofinput i see a camera panning around a raining city somewhere hidden along the street is a where a detective is having a drink hes down on his luck and the culprit is going to get away but a woman is abou…
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.1532 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / bar vs Jaz_LOW_19 / movie
── Original A: i thought of movies where they are at a concert like school of rock or something similar and they are in a mosh pit | i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold song was playing whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on …
── Original B: i thought about a super mario video game the tune was very similar to the background music in most mario games it made me think about super mario odyssey which was the last mario game that i played | those soccer games where you are picking your teams and setting up formation before the game itself …
Model A: i of where they are at a school of or something similar and they are in a mosh pit endofinput i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold was whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on facebook at the time the is loud and …
Model B: i about a super mario the tune was very similar to the background in most mario it me about super mario odyssey which was the last mario that i played endofinput those soccer where you are picking your teams and setting up formation before the itself starts endofinput an old set in the 20s with peop…
[2] Sim=0.1585 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_LOW_02 / concert vs Ele_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: i thought about my dad being in a jazz concert my dad loved jazz and wherever i hear it i think about him this song brought feelings of nostalgia and curiosity | i imagined myself walking into an empty church building where the music instruments are being tested before church service | it did not hi…
── Original B: feels like you are underwater in the sea very calming very relaxing floating around in water | vividly reminds me of a mobile phone ad that i used to get back during covid while watching my favorite streamers | this is the kind of background music you hear when some big tech company makes some major…
Model A: i about my dad being in a my dad loved and wherever i hear it i about him this brought feelings of nostalgia and curiosity endofinput i myself walking into an empty church building where the are being tested before church service endofinput it did not hit me right away but this me of the la noir a w…
Model B: feels you are underwater in the sea very calming very relaxing floating around in water endofinput vividly me of a mobile phone ad that i used to get back during covid while watching my favorite streamers endofinput this is the kind of background you hear when some big tech company some major innova…
[3] Sim=0.1589 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / movie vs Ele_LOW_09 / videogame
── Original A: the thoughts about animals swimming came into my head i saw myself in an aquarium and watching a seal and turtle swim around the music made me pensive as well as i watched the animals swim around | its a scene where something sad has happened and the protagonist is trying to move on very solemn but …
── Original B: very charged sounds like a song i have heard before in an advert about you would not steal a blank feels like its telling you something feels important or like you need to be paying attention | gave much more upbeat energy imagining a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around o…
Model A: the thoughts about animals swimming came into my head i saw myself in an aquarium and watching a seal and turtle swim around the me pensive as well as i watched the animals swim around endofinput its a where something sad has happened and the protagonist is trying to move on very solemn but the back…
Model B: very charged a i have heard before in an advert about you not steal a blank feels its telling you something feels important or you need to be paying attention endofinput gave much more upbeat energy a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around or a high speed chase endofinput me…
[4] Sim=0.1928 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / bar vs Ele_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: i think about an old 80s movie that takes place in a bar i think about a couple dancing and having a good time this music brings feelings of nostalgia and good times | sounds like a jazz bar but particularly the outdoor seating area everyone is having cocktails or wine and its a warm evening with a …
── Original B: feels like you are underwater in the sea very calming very relaxing floating around in water | vividly reminds me of a mobile phone ad that i used to get back during covid while watching my favorite streamers | this is the kind of background music you hear when some big tech company makes some major…
Model A: i about an old 80s that takes place in a i about a couple dancing and having a good time this brings feelings of nostalgia and good times endofinput a but particularly the outdoor seating area everyone is having cocktails or wine and its a warm evening with a slight breeze cobblestone streets endofi…
Model B: feels you are underwater in the sea very calming very relaxing floating around in water endofinput vividly me of a mobile phone ad that i used to get back during covid while watching my favorite streamers endofinput this is the kind of background you hear when some big tech company some major innova…
[5] Sim=0.1987 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / bar vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: i think about an old 80s movie that takes place in a bar i think about a couple dancing and having a good time this music brings feelings of nostalgia and good times | sounds like a jazz bar but particularly the outdoor seating area everyone is having cocktails or wine and its a warm evening with a …
── Original B: a mix of things that should not be together does not sound right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a movie it would fit sounded confusing | the clip reminds me of a popular jason statham action movie i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or …
Model A: i about an old 80s that takes place in a i about a couple dancing and having a good time this brings feelings of nostalgia and good times endofinput a but particularly the outdoor seating area everyone is having cocktails or wine and its a warm evening with a slight breeze cobblestone streets endofi…
Model B: a mix of things that should not be together does not right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a it fit confusing endofinput the me of a popular jason statham action i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or the cops endofinput this is what som…
[6] Sim=0.2081 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / concert vs Jaz_MED_02 / movie
── Original A: feels like you are underwater in the sea very calming very relaxing floating around in water | vividly reminds me of a mobile phone ad that i used to get back during covid while watching my favorite streamers | this is the kind of background music you hear when some big tech company makes some major…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
Model A: feels you are underwater in the sea very calming very relaxing floating around in water endofinput vividly me of a mobile phone ad that i used to get back during covid while watching my favorite streamers endofinput this is the kind of background you hear when some big tech company some major innova…
Model B: i was of a in a christmas where two people are in a posh restaurant endofinput a or slow dance in a endofinput i can see a stage the on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to endofinput i myself in a smokey club just enjoying the vibes endofinput this see…
[7] Sim=0.2166 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_19 / bar vs Met_MED_20 / bar
── Original A: this felt like i was in an american jazz bar i think american because i havent been to a british one and i have seen plenty of american ones in tv and film maybe i would be drinking a cocktail | at first it sounded like something out of a mario bros game and then when the main section came in it was…
── Original B: i thought of movies where they are at a concert like school of rock or something similar and they are in a mosh pit | i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold song was playing whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on …
Model A: this felt i was in an american i american because i havent been to a british one and i have seen plenty of american ones in tv and maybe i be drinking a cocktail endofinput at first it something out of a mario bros and then when the main section came in it was sitting in a endofinput i can see a fro…
Model B: i of where they are at a school of or something similar and they are in a mosh pit endofinput i can see myself at the computer desk as a kid opening up spotify to see what avenged sevenfold was whilst doing homework on the computer and talking to some friends on facebook at the time the is loud and …
[8] Sim=0.2171 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_19 / movie
── Original A: feels like you are underwater in the sea very calming very relaxing floating around in water | vividly reminds me of a mobile phone ad that i used to get back during covid while watching my favorite streamers | this is the kind of background music you hear when some big tech company makes some major…
── Original B: i thought about a super mario video game the tune was very similar to the background music in most mario games it made me think about super mario odyssey which was the last mario game that i played | those soccer games where you are picking your teams and setting up formation before the game itself …
Model A: feels you are underwater in the sea very calming very relaxing floating around in water endofinput vividly me of a mobile phone ad that i used to get back during covid while watching my favorite streamers endofinput this is the kind of background you hear when some big tech company some major innova…
Model B: i about a super mario the tune was very similar to the background in most mario it me about super mario odyssey which was the last mario that i played endofinput those soccer where you are picking your teams and setting up formation before the itself starts endofinput an old set in the 20s with peop…
[9] Sim=0.2186 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago | i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams do…
Model A: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
Model B: i was of a from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago endofinput i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams down his…
[10] Sim=0.2253 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / concert vs Jaz_MED_02 / videogame
── Original A: feels like you are underwater in the sea very calming very relaxing floating around in water | vividly reminds me of a mobile phone ad that i used to get back during covid while watching my favorite streamers | this is the kind of background music you hear when some big tech company makes some major…
── Original B: slow jazz like this makes me think about the holiday season it makes me think of a couple sitting close to a warm fire and staring into it it makes me think of family being together in cozy sweaters and enjoying each others company | choir in a church playing just before the pastor starts preaching …
Model A: feels you are underwater in the sea very calming very relaxing floating around in water endofinput vividly me of a mobile phone ad that i used to get back during covid while watching my favorite streamers endofinput this is the kind of background you hear when some big tech company some major innova…
Model B: slow this me about the holiday season it me of a couple sitting close to a warm fire and staring into it it me of family being together in cozy sweaters and enjoying each others company endofinput choir in a church just before the pastor starts preaching endofinput a with a in the corner dim lightin…Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_A6_para_minilm.png
Data: combMIMC_lvl1a.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
Fine-tuned for semantic similarity on 1B+ sentence pairs. The embedding space is trained so cosine similarity directly reflects semantic closeness. Running on combMIMC shows whether similarity fine-tuning changes behaviour at document scale vs individual scale (compare A7 vs B7).
=================================================================A7 — all-MiniLM-L6-v2 (combMIMC_lvl1a)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (64, 384) Pairs: 2,016 | skipped — identical: 0 | short (<5 words): 0 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.7548 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_LOW_02 / bar vs Ele_MED_19 / bar
── Original A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged | made me imagine a high end bar with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young bar staff dressed in black and white | reminds me of back in the days my dad used to constantly play kenny…
── Original B: this felt like i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing | a rainy day and a forest | i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the sky or is it t…
Model A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged endofinput me a high end with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young staff dressed in black and white endofinput me of back in the days my dad used to constantly kenny gs i wanted to …
Model B: this felt i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing endofinput a rainy day and a forest endofinput i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the s…
[2] Sim=0.7307 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_13 / bar vs 80s_LOW_06 / concert
── Original A: i could only think about sitting on the couch as a kid and this would be the type of song the would play during the credits of an old vhs movie | it sounded like perfect music for an introduction into a movie or video game it was cool and somber | this gave me a disco 80s vibe i imagined vibrant col…
── Original B: very bland like lift music or something not something i would specifically think about or remember end credits again | middle aged people at the concert | i imagined walking in a clothing store forever 21 charlotte russe etc and hearing this song blasting from the speakers | it sounded like a bit pl…
Model A: i only about sitting on the couch as a kid and this be the type of the during the credits of an old vhs endofinput it perfect for an introduction into a or it was cool and somber endofinput this gave me a disco 80s vibe i vibrant colors and afros endofinput a setting not much more came to my mind ap…
Model B: very bland lift or something not something i specifically about or end credits again endofinput middle aged people at the endofinput i walking in a clothing store forever 21 charlotte russe etc and hearing this blasting from the speakers endofinput it a bit played in a tv show or a very old not a at…
[3] Sim=0.7209 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_LOW_06 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / concert
── Original A: very bland like lift music or something not something i would specifically think about or remember end credits again | middle aged people at the concert | i imagined walking in a clothing store forever 21 charlotte russe etc and hearing this song blasting from the speakers | it sounded like a bit pl…
── Original B: sounds very dramatic very video game music | i imagined chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways | another piece that sounds like boss music in a jrpg or an arcade game that has a time trial on it like a light gun game | long haired metal fans listening to some sort metal music it felt sim…
Model A: very bland lift or something not something i specifically about or end credits again endofinput middle aged people at the endofinput i walking in a clothing store forever 21 charlotte russe etc and hearing this blasting from the speakers endofinput it a bit played in a tv show or a very old not a at…
Model B: very dramatic very endofinput i chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways endofinput another that boss in a jrpg or an arcade that has a time trial on it a light gun endofinput long haired fans listening to some sort it felt similar to that through the fire and flames endofinput the only th…
[4] Sim=0.7191 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / concert vs 80s_MED_08 / videogame
── Original A: sounds very dramatic very video game music | i imagined chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways | another piece that sounds like boss music in a jrpg or an arcade game that has a time trial on it like a light gun game | long haired metal fans listening to some sort metal music it felt sim…
── Original B: overly upbeat no real emotions peppy too much | i imagined my self playing a nostalgic mobile game while this song plays as a sound track while i am going through the tutorial | that sounds like the opening theme or closing theme not sure now to some 80s sitcom not gonna specify which you can really…
Model A: very dramatic very endofinput i chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways endofinput another that boss in a jrpg or an arcade that has a time trial on it a light gun endofinput long haired fans listening to some sort it felt similar to that through the fire and flames endofinput the only th…
Model B: overly upbeat no real emotions peppy too much endofinput i my self a nostalgic mobile while this as a track while i am going through the tutorial endofinput that the opening theme or closing theme not sure now to some 80s sitcom not gon na specify which you can really just take your pic they all had…
[5] Sim=0.7152 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / concert vs Ele_MED_19 / movie
── Original A: sounds very dramatic very video game music | i imagined chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways | another piece that sounds like boss music in a jrpg or an arcade game that has a time trial on it like a light gun game | long haired metal fans listening to some sort metal music it felt sim…
── Original B: well made quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad scene or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be | initially imagined it to be a piece playing over a sad moment of the movie however as the beat was added it fit more with …
Model A: very dramatic very endofinput i chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways endofinput another that boss in a jrpg or an arcade that has a time trial on it a light gun endofinput long haired fans listening to some sort it felt similar to that through the fire and flames endofinput the only th…
Model B: well quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be endofinput initially it to be a over a sad moment of the however as the beat was added it fit more with a coming of age endofinput me o…
[6] Sim=0.7084 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / bar vs 80s_MED_13 / concert
── Original A: sounds futuristic ambient | the music relates to moments where one is traveling solo to explore new things | serenepeacefulthoughtful and peaceful | i felt at peace while listening to this it made me calm and feel present in the moment | this one reminds me of a nigerian movie i watched some time ba…
── Original B: sounds quite magical and whimsical | playing a video game and entering a new zone area | it sounded like an extended version of a 90s console start up sound | i imagined an 80s esque piece abstract at first with a navy blue background fog and cold white blue ambient lighting the last 13th of the son…
Model A: futuristic ambient endofinput the relates to moments where one is traveling solo to explore new things endofinput serenepeacefulthoughtful and peaceful endofinput i felt at peace while listening to this it me calm and feel present in the moment endofinput this one me of a nigerian i watched some tim…
Model B: quite magical and whimsical endofinput a and entering a new zone area endofinput it an extended version of a 90s console start up endofinput i an 80s esque abstract at first with a navy blue background fog and cold white blue ambient lighting the last 13th of the seemed fit for a musical but no musi…
[7] Sim=0.7041 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_LOW_02 / bar vs Ele_MED_20 / bar
── Original A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged | made me imagine a high end bar with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young bar staff dressed in black and white | reminds me of back in the days my dad used to constantly play kenny…
── Original B: sounds futuristic ambient | the music relates to moments where one is traveling solo to explore new things | serenepeacefulthoughtful and peaceful | i felt at peace while listening to this it made me calm and feel present in the moment | this one reminds me of a nigerian movie i watched some time ba…
Model A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged endofinput me a high end with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young staff dressed in black and white endofinput me of back in the days my dad used to constantly kenny gs i wanted to …
Model B: futuristic ambient endofinput the relates to moments where one is traveling solo to explore new things endofinput serenepeacefulthoughtful and peaceful endofinput i felt at peace while listening to this it me calm and feel present in the moment endofinput this one me of a nigerian i watched some tim…
[8] Sim=0.7008 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / bar vs Ele_MED_19 / movie
── Original A: this felt like i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing | a rainy day and a forest | i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the sky or is it t…
── Original B: well made quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad scene or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be | initially imagined it to be a piece playing over a sad moment of the movie however as the beat was added it fit more with …
Model A: this felt i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing endofinput a rainy day and a forest endofinput i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the s…
Model B: well quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be endofinput initially it to be a over a sad moment of the however as the beat was added it fit more with a coming of age endofinput me o…
[9] Sim=0.7005 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_13 / bar vs 80s_MED_13 / videogame
── Original A: i could only think about sitting on the couch as a kid and this would be the type of song the would play during the credits of an old vhs movie | it sounded like perfect music for an introduction into a movie or video game it was cool and somber | this gave me a disco 80s vibe i imagined vibrant col…
── Original B: i thought about a 90s disney movie it gave me those 90s vibes it reminded me of when i was a kid and when i would watch these movies with my big sister | after i completed the stage any button i press on the controller it makes the sounds i kept hearing | a relaxing beach scene clear blue water very…
Model A: i only about sitting on the couch as a kid and this be the type of the during the credits of an old vhs endofinput it perfect for an introduction into a or it was cool and somber endofinput this gave me a disco 80s vibe i vibrant colors and afros endofinput a setting not much more came to my mind ap…
Model B: i about a 90s disney it gave me those 90s vibes it reminded me of when i was a kid and when i watch these with my big sister endofinput after i completed the stage any button i press on the controller it the i kept hearing endofinput a relaxing beach clear blue water very sunny and sandy beaches the…
[10] Sim=0.6982 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_MED_13 / concert vs Ele_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: sounds quite magical and whimsical | playing a video game and entering a new zone area | it sounded like an extended version of a 90s console start up sound | i imagined an 80s esque piece abstract at first with a navy blue background fog and cold white blue ambient lighting the last 13th of the son…
── Original B: sounds like minecraft | late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window | sounds like the music youd hear in an indie game | i imagined a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes | the music r…
Model A: quite magical and whimsical endofinput a and entering a new zone area endofinput it an extended version of a 90s console start up endofinput i an 80s esque abstract at first with a navy blue background fog and cold white blue ambient lighting the last 13th of the seemed fit for a musical but no musi…
Model B: minecraft endofinput late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window endofinput the youd hear in an indie endofinput i a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes endofinput the of shared and c…
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.1373 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs Jaz_MED_02 / videogame
── Original A: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
── Original B: slow jazz like this makes me think about the holiday season it makes me think of a couple sitting close to a warm fire and staring into it it makes me think of family being together in cozy sweaters and enjoying each others company | choir in a church playing just before the pastor starts preaching …
Model A: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
Model B: slow this me about the holiday season it me of a couple sitting close to a warm fire and staring into it it me of family being together in cozy sweaters and enjoying each others company endofinput choir in a church just before the pastor starts preaching endofinput a with a in the corner dim lightin…
[2] Sim=0.1402 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / movie vs Ele_LOW_09 / videogame
── Original A: the thoughts about animals swimming came into my head i saw myself in an aquarium and watching a seal and turtle swim around the music made me pensive as well as i watched the animals swim around | its a scene where something sad has happened and the protagonist is trying to move on very solemn but …
── Original B: very charged sounds like a song i have heard before in an advert about you would not steal a blank feels like its telling you something feels important or like you need to be paying attention | gave much more upbeat energy imagining a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around o…
Model A: the thoughts about animals swimming came into my head i saw myself in an aquarium and watching a seal and turtle swim around the me pensive as well as i watched the animals swim around endofinput its a where something sad has happened and the protagonist is trying to move on very solemn but the back…
Model B: very charged a i have heard before in an advert about you not steal a blank feels its telling you something feels important or you need to be paying attention endofinput gave much more upbeat energy a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around or a high speed chase endofinput me…
[3] Sim=0.1421 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / movie vs Ele_LOW_09 / videogame
── Original A: i think about an old sitcom this sounds like it would be in the opening it feels like this song could be about a familial show where there are many happy moments | it sounds like the track of the end credits scene in a happy family movie everyone is shown to be laughing and having fun whilst the cre…
── Original B: very charged sounds like a song i have heard before in an advert about you would not steal a blank feels like its telling you something feels important or like you need to be paying attention | gave much more upbeat energy imagining a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around o…
Model A: i about an old sitcom this it be in the opening it feels this be about a familial show where there are many happy moments endofinput it the track of the end credits in a happy family everyone is shown to be laughing and having fun whilst the credits roll endofinput this me of a 90s tv show where the…
Model B: very charged a i have heard before in an advert about you not steal a blank feels its telling you something feels important or you need to be paying attention endofinput gave much more upbeat energy a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around or a high speed chase endofinput me…
[4] Sim=0.1451 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_02 / videogame vs Met_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: slow jazz like this makes me think about the holiday season it makes me think of a couple sitting close to a warm fire and staring into it it makes me think of family being together in cozy sweaters and enjoying each others company | choir in a church playing just before the pastor starts preaching …
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago | i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams do…
Model A: slow this me about the holiday season it me of a couple sitting close to a warm fire and staring into it it me of family being together in cozy sweaters and enjoying each others company endofinput choir in a church just before the pastor starts preaching endofinput a with a in the corner dim lightin…
Model B: i was of a from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago endofinput i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams down his…
[5] Sim=0.1606 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / concert vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about my dad being in a jazz concert my dad loved jazz and wherever i hear it i think about him this song brought feelings of nostalgia and curiosity | i imagined myself walking into an empty church building where the music instruments are being tested before church service | it did not hi…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: i about my dad being in a my dad loved and wherever i hear it i about him this brought feelings of nostalgia and curiosity endofinput i myself walking into an empty church building where the are being tested before church service endofinput it did not hit me right away but this me of the la noir a w…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[6] Sim=0.1680 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good | not sure where this would fit cannot especially imagine it working very well | sort of reminds me of a few racing mobile games i used to play on my first real smartphone very nostalgic | tha…
Model A: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
Model B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good endofinput not sure where this fit can not especially it working very well endofinput sort of me of a few racing mobile i used to on my first real smartphone very nostalgic endofinput that a w…
[7] Sim=0.1727 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / movie vs Jaz_MED_02 / videogame
── Original A: i was thinking of being at a warehouse project gig with someone playing old synthy house music it felt fun and enjoyable | i can see undertale on my computer screen i am fighting sans but the music is not quite right i am not running my usual pacifist run so i have to attack him the sounds of my hit…
── Original B: slow jazz like this makes me think about the holiday season it makes me think of a couple sitting close to a warm fire and staring into it it makes me think of family being together in cozy sweaters and enjoying each others company | choir in a church playing just before the pastor starts preaching …
Model A: i was of being at a warehouse project gig with someone old synthy house it felt fun and enjoyable endofinput i can see undertale on my computer screen i am fighting sans but the is not quite right i am not running my usual pacifist run so i have to attack him the of my hitting him are satisfying hes…
Model B: slow this me about the holiday season it me of a couple sitting close to a warm fire and staring into it it me of family being together in cozy sweaters and enjoying each others company endofinput choir in a church just before the pastor starts preaching endofinput a with a in the corner dim lightin…
[8] Sim=0.1730 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Met_LOW_09 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: i thought about playing guitar hero with friends in my friends garage this made me nostalgic to my junior high days where everything was easy there were no bills and i just spent time with friends doing dumb things | the music that starts just before an epic boss fight and the boss is revealed and s…
Model A: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
Model B: i about hero with friends in my friends garage this me nostalgic to my junior high days where everything was easy there were no bills and i just spent time with friends doing dumb things endofinput the that starts just before an epic boss fight and the boss is revealed and starts hunting down the ma…
[9] Sim=0.1749 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: i about a mystery or crime i about a black and white where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman the is in a red dress at a it seemed very old school to me endofinput a character sitting in a drinking all alone after a bad news he received endofinput it the that in a lowkey sp…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[10] Sim=0.1809 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_19 / bar vs Ele_LOW_09 / videogame
── Original A: this felt like i was in an american jazz bar i think american because i havent been to a british one and i have seen plenty of american ones in tv and film maybe i would be drinking a cocktail | at first it sounded like something out of a mario bros game and then when the main section came in it was…
── Original B: very charged sounds like a song i have heard before in an advert about you would not steal a blank feels like its telling you something feels important or like you need to be paying attention | gave much more upbeat energy imagining a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around o…
Model A: this felt i was in an american i american because i havent been to a british one and i have seen plenty of american ones in tv and maybe i be drinking a cocktail endofinput at first it something out of a mario bros and then when the main section came in it was sitting in a endofinput i can see a fro…
Model B: very charged a i have heard before in an advert about you not steal a blank feels its telling you something feels important or you need to be paying attention endofinput gave much more upbeat energy a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around or a high speed chase endofinput me…Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_A7_minilm.png
Data: combMIMC_lvl1a.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
Highest-quality general-purpose sentence-embedding model. 768-dimensional embeddings, max 512 tokens. Quality ceiling for the sentence-transformer family.
=================================================================A8 — all-mpnet-base-v2 (combMIMC_lvl1a)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (64, 768) Pairs: 2,016 | skipped — identical: 0 | short (<5 words): 0 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.8993 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / bar vs Ele_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: this felt like i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing | a rainy day and a forest | i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the sky or is it t…
── Original B: sounds like minecraft | late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window | sounds like the music youd hear in an indie game | i imagined a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes | the music r…
Model A: this felt i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing endofinput a rainy day and a forest endofinput i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the s…
Model B: minecraft endofinput late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window endofinput the youd hear in an indie endofinput i a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes endofinput the of shared and c…
[2] Sim=0.8859 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / concert vs Ele_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: i thought about an old sonic game i thought about the original sonic map and sonic running around i thought about the jumping noise that he makes | myself playing contra its a video game in my bedroom sitting on the floor with my back against my bed | a rave lots of strobe lighting and people jumpin…
── Original B: i was thinking of being at a warehouse project gig with someone playing old synthy house music it felt fun and enjoyable | i can see undertale on my computer screen i am fighting sans but the music is not quite right i am not running my usual pacifist run so i have to attack him the sounds of my hit…
Model A: i about an old sonic i about the original sonic map and sonic running around i about the jumping noise that he endofinput myself contra its a in my bedroom sitting on the floor with my back against my bed endofinput a rave lots of strobe lighting and people jumping up and down its a huge room and it…
Model B: i was of being at a warehouse project gig with someone old synthy house it felt fun and enjoyable endofinput i can see undertale on my computer screen i am fighting sans but the is not quite right i am not running my usual pacifist run so i have to attack him the of my hitting him are satisfying hes…
[3] Sim=0.8787 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_21 / bar vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: phoning some company for help and then being put on hold for a long time while this music plays | it sounds like elevator music or the music you get on a call when you are put on hold would also fit a generic supermarket in a movie | music in some sort of speakeasy if you have ever watched broad cit…
── Original B: in a jazz bar again or maybe just a cocktail bar sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time | the song reminds me of goofy old cartoons and makes me think of the looney toons | i think this is what elevator music should be and sound like i enjoyed this very much | instantly the chuckle brothers ca…
Model A: phoning some company for help and then being put on hold for a long time while this endofinput it elevator or the you get on a call when you are put on hold also fit a generic supermarket in a endofinput in some sort of speakeasy if you have ever watched broad city theres an episode where abi turns …
Model B: in a again or maybe just a cocktail sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time endofinput the me of goofy old cartoons and me of the looney toons endofinput i this is what elevator should be and i enjoyed this very much endofinput instantly the chuckle brothers came tor mind and then a cat cafe wh…
[4] Sim=0.8733 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Ele_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
── Original B: sounds like minecraft | late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window | sounds like the music youd hear in an indie game | i imagined a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes | the music r…
Model A: very dynamic be swaying to the with someone you care about be sat with a drink alone about your life something important endofinput again in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting endofinput i my self watching a live and feeling nostalgic while n…
Model B: minecraft endofinput late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window endofinput the youd hear in an indie endofinput i a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes endofinput the of shared and c…
[5] Sim=0.8709 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Jaz_MED_02 / concert
── Original A: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
── Original B: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles | first thought was the greatest video game of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s jazz club or a prohibition era speakeasy | at first i could imagine a browser window with a cafe ambient video playing and then i coul…
Model A: very dynamic be swaying to the with someone you care about be sat with a drink alone about your life something important endofinput again in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting endofinput i my self watching a live and feeling nostalgic while n…
Model B: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles endofinput first was the greatest of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s club or a prohibition era speakeasy endofinput at first i a browser window with a cafe ambient and then i see my universtys starbucks in full vi…
[6] Sim=0.8649 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_09 / concert vs Met_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: i felt like i was at a drum and bass concert i do not like that music or similar like in the clip and have never had enough energy to enjoy such a concert so it felt more annoying than emotionally good | a festival with strobe lights and a huge crowd | i can see a stage and a bunch of people in fron…
── Original B: i imagined that i was watching a film that has a montage scene like an action comedy one i could not actively imagine being at a concert like this | a heavy metal gig or festival | when i hear this i think of my sister and i as kids listening to music like this banging our heads pretending to play a…
Model A: i felt i was at a and bass i do not that or similar in the and have never had enough energy to enjoy such a so it felt more annoying than emotionally good endofinput a festival with strobe lights and a huge crowd endofinput i can see a stage and a bunch of people in front of me at an edm people are …
Model B: i that i was watching a that has a montage an action comedy one i not actively being at a this endofinput a heavy gig or festival endofinput when i hear this i of my sister and i as kids listening to this banging our heads pretending to air our hair get all crazy but it was always so much fun to hav…
[7] Sim=0.8641 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_14 / concert vs Met_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: sounds very dramatic very video game music | i imagined chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways | another piece that sounds like boss music in a jrpg or an arcade game that has a time trial on it like a light gun game | long haired metal fans listening to some sort metal music it felt sim…
── Original B: i imagined that i was watching a film that has a montage scene like an action comedy one i could not actively imagine being at a concert like this | a heavy metal gig or festival | when i hear this i think of my sister and i as kids listening to music like this banging our heads pretending to play a…
Model A: very dramatic very endofinput i chasing someone down some twisting small alleyways endofinput another that boss in a jrpg or an arcade that has a time trial on it a light gun endofinput long haired fans listening to some sort it felt similar to that through the fire and flames endofinput the only th…
Model B: i that i was watching a that has a montage an action comedy one i not actively being at a this endofinput a heavy gig or festival endofinput when i hear this i of my sister and i as kids listening to this banging our heads pretending to air our hair get all crazy but it was always so much fun to hav…
[8] Sim=0.8626 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / concert vs Ele_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: i see a roller rink from the 80s bright colors people are talking and laughing the music is loud lights are dark and everything feels alive i can almost feel the air brushing past my face i as i skate around | it made me think of something retro mixed with something new age | this reminded me of the…
── Original B: i could see a loading screen for a video game an anime girl sitting on a seat in the window knees to her chest its cozy but also futuristic outside the window it seems to be raining above a cityscape we seem to be very high above the ground the clouds are blocking the view downwards | i felt a space…
Model A: i see a roller rink from the 80s bright colors people are talking and laughing the is loud lights are dark and everything feels alive i can almost feel the air brushing past my face i as i skate around endofinput it me of something retro mixed with something new age endofinput this reminded me of th…
Model B: i see a loading screen for a an anime girl sitting on a seat in the window knees to her chest its cozy but also futuristic outside the window it seems to be raining above a cityscape we seem to be very high above the ground the clouds are blocking the view downwards endofinput i felt a spacey and ch…
[9] Sim=0.8585 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / movie vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i was thinking of being at a warehouse project gig with someone playing old synthy house music it felt fun and enjoyable | i can see undertale on my computer screen i am fighting sans but the music is not quite right i am not running my usual pacifist run so i have to attack him the sounds of my hit…
── Original B: me and my friends playing mario kart while i am trying to win | it sounds like music from a 90s video game or an arcade machine | pac man some annoying game from the 80s very irritating music a sort of pixelated game | i imagined a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right like paper …
Model A: i was of being at a warehouse project gig with someone old synthy house it felt fun and enjoyable endofinput i can see undertale on my computer screen i am fighting sans but the is not quite right i am not running my usual pacifist run so i have to attack him the of my hitting him are satisfying hes…
Model B: me and my friends mario kart while i am trying to win endofinput it from a 90s or an arcade machine endofinput pac man some annoying from the 80s very irritating a sort of pixelated endofinput i a pixelated combination scroller moving from left to right paper mario and fighting mortal kombat endofin…
[10] Sim=0.8584 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_02 / concert vs Jaz_MED_07 / concert
── Original A: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles | first thought was the greatest video game of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s jazz club or a prohibition era speakeasy | at first i could imagine a browser window with a cafe ambient video playing and then i coul…
── Original B: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
Model A: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles endofinput first was the greatest of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s club or a prohibition era speakeasy endofinput at first i a browser window with a cafe ambient and then i see my universtys starbucks in full vi…
Model B: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.3373 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / bar vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: the music felt really 80s and so it was an image of a 80s style hawaiian bar with hula style decor | the music evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends | it made me think about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this music sound | i imagined mys…
── Original B: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
Model A: the felt really 80s and so it was an of a 80s style hawaiian with hula style decor endofinput the evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends endofinput it me about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this endofinput i myself and a few friends in a …
Model B: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
[2] Sim=0.3971 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs Jaz_LOW_21 / movie
── Original A: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
── Original B: very peppy like lift music again feels busy like you need to do something maybe walking through a shopping center listening to this in the background | fun supermarket shopping scene in a coming of age movie | reminds me of a tom jerry show i used to watch the sound track playing in the background w…
Model A: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
Model B: very peppy lift again feels busy you need to do something maybe walking through a shopping center listening to this in the background endofinput fun supermarket shopping in a coming of age endofinput me of a tom jerry show i used to watch the track in the background while tom and jerry are being mis…
[3] Sim=0.4029 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
Model A: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
Model B: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
[4] Sim=0.4157 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
── Original B: in a jazz bar again or maybe just a cocktail bar sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time | the song reminds me of goofy old cartoons and makes me think of the looney toons | i think this is what elevator music should be and sound like i enjoyed this very much | instantly the chuckle brothers ca…
Model A: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
Model B: in a again or maybe just a cocktail sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time endofinput the me of goofy old cartoons and me of the looney toons endofinput i this is what elevator should be and i enjoyed this very much endofinput instantly the chuckle brothers came tor mind and then a cat cafe wh…
[5] Sim=0.4202 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / concert vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: sounds like minecraft | late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window | sounds like the music youd hear in an indie game | i imagined a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes | the music r…
── Original B: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
Model A: minecraft endofinput late at night in my bedroom and i can hear the rain come down and tap my bedroom window endofinput the youd hear in an indie endofinput i a track for something taking place on the beach on an overcast blue grey day with cold waters and cold breezes endofinput the of shared and c…
Model B: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
[6] Sim=0.4209 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / concert vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: i thought about being in a rock concert with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the guitar solo | one of those white people music concerts where the artist plays a guitar …
── Original B: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
Model A: i about being in a with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the solo endofinput one of those white people where the artist a and they go wild but its a niche thing only kno…
Model B: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
[7] Sim=0.4215 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / bar vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged | made me imagine a high end bar with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young bar staff dressed in black and white | reminds me of back in the days my dad used to constantly play kenny…
── Original B: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
Model A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged endofinput me a high end with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young staff dressed in black and white endofinput me of back in the days my dad used to constantly kenny gs i wanted to …
Model B: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
[8] Sim=0.4247 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_21 / bar vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: phoning some company for help and then being put on hold for a long time while this music plays | it sounds like elevator music or the music you get on a call when you are put on hold would also fit a generic supermarket in a movie | music in some sort of speakeasy if you have ever watched broad cit…
── Original B: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
Model A: phoning some company for help and then being put on hold for a long time while this endofinput it elevator or the you get on a call when you are put on hold also fit a generic supermarket in a endofinput in some sort of speakeasy if you have ever watched broad city theres an episode where abi turns …
Model B: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
[9] Sim=0.4286 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / bar vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: i think about an old 80s movie that takes place in a bar i think about a couple dancing and having a good time this music brings feelings of nostalgia and good times | sounds like a jazz bar but particularly the outdoor seating area everyone is having cocktails or wine and its a warm evening with a …
── Original B: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
Model A: i about an old 80s that takes place in a i about a couple dancing and having a good time this brings feelings of nostalgia and good times endofinput a but particularly the outdoor seating area everyone is having cocktails or wine and its a warm evening with a slight breeze cobblestone streets endofi…
Model B: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
[10] Sim=0.4289 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / concert vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles | first thought was the greatest video game of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s jazz club or a prohibition era speakeasy | at first i could imagine a browser window with a cafe ambient video playing and then i coul…
── Original B: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
Model A: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles endofinput first was the greatest of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s club or a prohibition era speakeasy endofinput at first i a browser window with a cafe ambient and then i see my universtys starbucks in full vi…
Model B: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_A8_mpnet.png
Data: combMIMC_lvl1a.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
Fine-tuned for paraphrase detection — identifying when two sentences express the same meaning in different words. Closest analogue to the MIMC task objective.
=================================================================A9 — paraphrase-mpnet-base-v2 (combMIMC_lvl1a)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (64, 768) Pairs: 2,016 | skipped — identical: 0 | short (<5 words): 0 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.8745 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / movie vs 80s_LOW_02 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like a movie scene set in a big city where the main character is depressed or wandering the streets at night | i could see a camera panning around a raining city somewhere hidden along the street is a bar where a detective is having a drink hes down on his luck and think the culprit is going …
── Original B: sounds very mysterious | breaking up with someone who i have been dating for a long time and then they start crying | it was a bit noir esque like a dark detective movie set in the 40s or 50s in the us | the music felt like a game where you play as a detective the game was very noir and black and wh…
Model A: a set in a big city where the main character is depressed or wandering the streets at night endofinput i see a camera panning around a raining city somewhere hidden along the street is a where a detective is having a drink hes down on his luck and the culprit is going to get away but a woman is abou…
Model B: very mysterious endofinput breaking up with someone who i have been dating for a long time and then they start crying endofinput it was a bit noir esque a dark detective set in the 40s or 50s in the us endofinput the felt a where you as a detective the was very noir and black and white endofinput i …
[2] Sim=0.8612 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_LOW_02 / bar vs Jaz_MED_02 / bar
── Original A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged | made me imagine a high end bar with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young bar staff dressed in black and white | reminds me of back in the days my dad used to constantly play kenny…
── Original B: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
Model A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged endofinput me a high end with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young staff dressed in black and white endofinput me of back in the days my dad used to constantly kenny gs i wanted to …
Model B: very dynamic be swaying to the with someone you care about be sat with a drink alone about your life something important endofinput again in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting endofinput i my self watching a live and feeling nostalgic while n…
[3] Sim=0.8474 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / bar vs Ele_MED_19 / movie
── Original A: this felt like i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing | a rainy day and a forest | i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the sky or is it t…
── Original B: well made quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad scene or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be | initially imagined it to be a piece playing over a sad moment of the movie however as the beat was added it fit more with …
Model A: this felt i was listening to a lofi beats spotify playlist its quite relaxing endofinput a rainy day and a forest endofinput i can see myself in a car as a passenger rain rolling down the windows as we drive on the interstate just outside of boston the sky is gloomy and there is so much fog in the s…
Model B: well quite sad and dynamic maybe a sad or something is being revealed doing something important maybe walking in the rain or going to do something you should not be endofinput initially it to be a over a sad moment of the however as the beat was added it fit more with a coming of age endofinput me o…
[4] Sim=0.8442 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Jaz_MED_02 / movie
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
Model A: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
Model B: i was of a in a christmas where two people are in a posh restaurant endofinput a or slow dance in a endofinput i can see a stage the on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to endofinput i myself in a smokey club just enjoying the vibes endofinput this see…
[5] Sim=0.8442 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs 80s_LOW_02 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: sounds very mysterious | breaking up with someone who i have been dating for a long time and then they start crying | it was a bit noir esque like a dark detective movie set in the 40s or 50s in the us | the music felt like a game where you play as a detective the game was very noir and black and wh…
Model A: i about a mystery or crime i about a black and white where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman the is in a red dress at a it seemed very old school to me endofinput a character sitting in a drinking all alone after a bad news he received endofinput it the that in a lowkey sp…
Model B: very mysterious endofinput breaking up with someone who i have been dating for a long time and then they start crying endofinput it was a bit noir esque a dark detective set in the 40s or 50s in the us endofinput the felt a where you as a detective the was very noir and black and white endofinput i …
[6] Sim=0.8442 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Met_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: very heavy rock not for me somewhere that i do not belong did not enjoy | middle aged men who ride motorbikes with long grey beards mosh pits dark night time concert loud headbanging | i imagined my self watching a bunch of heavy metal songs with my favorite headset on | it felt like i was at a meta…
── Original B: i imagined that i was watching a film that has a montage scene like an action comedy one i could not actively imagine being at a concert like this | a heavy metal gig or festival | when i hear this i think of my sister and i as kids listening to music like this banging our heads pretending to play a…
Model A: very heavy not for me somewhere that i do not belong did not enjoy endofinput middle aged men who ride motorbikes with long grey beards mosh pits dark night time loud headbanging endofinput i my self watching a bunch of heavy with my favorite headset on endofinput it felt i was at a to a melodic dea…
Model B: i that i was watching a that has a montage an action comedy one i not actively being at a this endofinput a heavy gig or festival endofinput when i hear this i of my sister and i as kids listening to this banging our heads pretending to air our hair get all crazy but it was always so much fun to hav…
[7] Sim=0.8435 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / bar vs 80s_LOW_02 / movie
── Original A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged | made me imagine a high end bar with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young bar staff dressed in black and white | reminds me of back in the days my dad used to constantly play kenny…
── Original B: sounds like a movie scene set in a big city where the main character is depressed or wandering the streets at night | i could see a camera panning around a raining city somewhere hidden along the street is a bar where a detective is having a drink hes down on his luck and think the culprit is going …
Model A: kind of sad melancholy not happy or upbeat emotionally charged endofinput me a high end with atmospheric lighting with candles or small lamps on tables cocktails old fashioned etc young staff dressed in black and white endofinput me of back in the days my dad used to constantly kenny gs i wanted to …
Model B: a set in a big city where the main character is depressed or wandering the streets at night endofinput i see a camera panning around a raining city somewhere hidden along the street is a where a detective is having a drink hes down on his luck and the culprit is going to get away but a woman is abou…
[8] Sim=0.8416 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / bar vs 80s_LOW_02 / movie
── Original A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
── Original B: sounds like a movie scene set in a big city where the main character is depressed or wandering the streets at night | i could see a camera panning around a raining city somewhere hidden along the street is a bar where a detective is having a drink hes down on his luck and think the culprit is going …
Model A: i about a mystery or crime i about a black and white where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman the is in a red dress at a it seemed very old school to me endofinput a character sitting in a drinking all alone after a bad news he received endofinput it the that in a lowkey sp…
Model B: a set in a big city where the main character is depressed or wandering the streets at night endofinput i see a camera panning around a raining city somewhere hidden along the street is a where a detective is having a drink hes down on his luck and the culprit is going to get away but a woman is abou…
[9] Sim=0.8413 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / movie vs Met_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i was thinking of being at a warehouse project gig with someone playing old synthy house music it felt fun and enjoyable | i can see undertale on my computer screen i am fighting sans but the music is not quite right i am not running my usual pacifist run so i have to attack him the sounds of my hit…
── Original B: i was thinking of a scene from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago | i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams do…
Model A: i was of being at a warehouse project gig with someone old synthy house it felt fun and enjoyable endofinput i can see undertale on my computer screen i am fighting sans but the is not quite right i am not running my usual pacifist run so i have to attack him the of my hitting him are satisfying hes…
Model B: i was of a from pokemon maybe in a battle maybe from an episode i wouldve watched 15 to 20 years ago endofinput i can see a big futuristic boss with a well armed character who is flitting around dodging slamming sword attacks whilst managing to get in a few attacks themselves the boss slams down his…
[10] Sim=0.8406 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / bar vs Jaz_LOW_21 / concert
── Original A: i think about an old 80s movie that takes place in a bar i think about a couple dancing and having a good time this music brings feelings of nostalgia and good times | sounds like a jazz bar but particularly the outdoor seating area everyone is having cocktails or wine and its a warm evening with a …
── Original B: a video game but not one in particular | i thought about a classic jazz band playing in a bar everyone is just enjoying the music and each others company had to think of a scene in my head because nothing came to me right away | for this i imagined a ragtime like scene in black and white with some c…
Model A: i about an old 80s that takes place in a i about a couple dancing and having a good time this brings feelings of nostalgia and good times endofinput a but particularly the outdoor seating area everyone is having cocktails or wine and its a warm evening with a slight breeze cobblestone streets endofi…
Model B: a but not one in particular endofinput i about a classic in a everyone is just enjoying the and each others company had to of a in my head because nothing came to me right away endofinput for this i a ragtime in black and white with some comedic aspects going on in a nice restaurant similar to the l…
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.3878 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: very heavy rock not for me somewhere that i do not belong did not enjoy | middle aged men who ride motorbikes with long grey beards mosh pits dark night time concert loud headbanging | i imagined my self watching a bunch of heavy metal songs with my favorite headset on | it felt like i was at a meta…
── Original B: in a jazz bar again or maybe just a cocktail bar sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time | the song reminds me of goofy old cartoons and makes me think of the looney toons | i think this is what elevator music should be and sound like i enjoyed this very much | instantly the chuckle brothers ca…
Model A: very heavy not for me somewhere that i do not belong did not enjoy endofinput middle aged men who ride motorbikes with long grey beards mosh pits dark night time loud headbanging endofinput i my self watching a bunch of heavy with my favorite headset on endofinput it felt i was at a to a melodic dea…
Model B: in a again or maybe just a cocktail sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time endofinput the me of goofy old cartoons and me of the looney toons endofinput i this is what elevator should be and i enjoyed this very much endofinput instantly the chuckle brothers came tor mind and then a cat cafe wh…
[2] Sim=0.3885 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / movie vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: a mix of things that should not be together does not sound right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a movie it would fit sounded confusing | the clip reminds me of a popular jason statham action movie i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or …
── Original B: in a jazz bar again or maybe just a cocktail bar sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time | the song reminds me of goofy old cartoons and makes me think of the looney toons | i think this is what elevator music should be and sound like i enjoyed this very much | instantly the chuckle brothers ca…
Model A: a mix of things that should not be together does not right or meshed well to me too much going on not sure what part of a it fit confusing endofinput the me of a popular jason statham action i watched a few years ago the main actor being chased by the bad guys or the cops endofinput this is what som…
Model B: in a again or maybe just a cocktail sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time endofinput the me of goofy old cartoons and me of the looney toons endofinput i this is what elevator should be and i enjoyed this very much endofinput instantly the chuckle brothers came tor mind and then a cat cafe wh…
[3] Sim=0.4032 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about being in a rock concert with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the guitar solo | one of those white people music concerts where the artist plays a guitar …
── Original B: in a jazz bar again or maybe just a cocktail bar sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time | the song reminds me of goofy old cartoons and makes me think of the looney toons | i think this is what elevator music should be and sound like i enjoyed this very much | instantly the chuckle brothers ca…
Model A: i about being in a with friends i can see myself looking to my right and left and being in the middle of a huge body of people i can see me and my friends jumping up and down and enjoying the solo endofinput one of those white people where the artist a and they go wild but its a niche thing only kno…
Model B: in a again or maybe just a cocktail sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time endofinput the me of goofy old cartoons and me of the looney toons endofinput i this is what elevator should be and i enjoyed this very much endofinput instantly the chuckle brothers came tor mind and then a cat cafe wh…
[4] Sim=0.4188 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame vs Met_LOW_09 / videogame
── Original A: in a jazz bar again or maybe just a cocktail bar sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time | the song reminds me of goofy old cartoons and makes me think of the looney toons | i think this is what elevator music should be and sound like i enjoyed this very much | instantly the chuckle brothers ca…
── Original B: i thought about playing guitar hero with friends in my friends garage this made me nostalgic to my junior high days where everything was easy there were no bills and i just spent time with friends doing dumb things | the music that starts just before an epic boss fight and the boss is revealed and s…
Model A: in a again or maybe just a cocktail sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time endofinput the me of goofy old cartoons and me of the looney toons endofinput i this is what elevator should be and i enjoyed this very much endofinput instantly the chuckle brothers came tor mind and then a cat cafe wh…
Model B: i about hero with friends in my friends garage this me nostalgic to my junior high days where everything was easy there were no bills and i just spent time with friends doing dumb things endofinput the that starts just before an epic boss fight and the boss is revealed and starts hunting down the ma…
[5] Sim=0.4220 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
── Original B: in a jazz bar again or maybe just a cocktail bar sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time | the song reminds me of goofy old cartoons and makes me think of the looney toons | i think this is what elevator music should be and sound like i enjoyed this very much | instantly the chuckle brothers ca…
Model A: a car chase action endofinput driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic endofinput it was a science fiction cyberpunk style space building up to some massive fight endofinput seemed an adventure maybe a from blade runner endofinput the only thing i can of is a dance night club w…
Model B: in a again or maybe just a cocktail sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time endofinput the me of goofy old cartoons and me of the looney toons endofinput i this is what elevator should be and i enjoyed this very much endofinput instantly the chuckle brothers came tor mind and then a cat cafe wh…
[6] Sim=0.4228 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_14 / concert vs Jaz_MED_07 / concert
── Original A: i thought about an old sonic game i thought about the original sonic map and sonic running around i thought about the jumping noise that he makes | myself playing contra its a video game in my bedroom sitting on the floor with my back against my bed | a rave lots of strobe lighting and people jumpin…
── Original B: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
Model A: i about an old sonic i about the original sonic map and sonic running around i about the jumping noise that he endofinput myself contra its a in my bedroom sitting on the floor with my back against my bed endofinput a rave lots of strobe lighting and people jumping up and down its a huge room and it…
Model B: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
[7] Sim=0.4290 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: in a jazz bar again or maybe just a cocktail bar sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time | the song reminds me of goofy old cartoons and makes me think of the looney toons | i think this is what elevator music should be and sound like i enjoyed this very much | instantly the chuckle brothers ca…
── Original B: when i was much younger playing guitar hero | sounds like boss fight music straight out a jrpg like yakuza | a heavy metal guitar hero game playing guitar hero on the wii | i could imagine the screen for guitar hero on display and someone playing with their friend | this music evokes the sense of fr…
Model A: in a again or maybe just a cocktail sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time endofinput the me of goofy old cartoons and me of the looney toons endofinput i this is what elevator should be and i enjoyed this very much endofinput instantly the chuckle brothers came tor mind and then a cat cafe wh…
Model B: when i was much younger hero endofinput boss fight straight out a jrpg yakuza endofinput a heavy hero hero on the wii endofinput i the screen for hero on display and someone with their friend endofinput this evokes the sense of freedom and adventure endofinput bursting with fireon top of the worldca…
[8] Sim=0.4407 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_19 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined that i was watching a film that has a montage scene like an action comedy one i could not actively imagine being at a concert like this | a heavy metal gig or festival | when i hear this i think of my sister and i as kids listening to music like this banging our heads pretending to play a…
── Original B: in a jazz bar again or maybe just a cocktail bar sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time | the song reminds me of goofy old cartoons and makes me think of the looney toons | i think this is what elevator music should be and sound like i enjoyed this very much | instantly the chuckle brothers ca…
Model A: i that i was watching a that has a montage an action comedy one i not actively being at a this endofinput a heavy gig or festival endofinput when i hear this i of my sister and i as kids listening to this banging our heads pretending to air our hair get all crazy but it was always so much fun to hav…
Model B: in a again or maybe just a cocktail sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time endofinput the me of goofy old cartoons and me of the looney toons endofinput i this is what elevator should be and i enjoyed this very much endofinput instantly the chuckle brothers came tor mind and then a cat cafe wh…
[9] Sim=0.4451 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / movie vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: i thought about being at corp nightclub in sheffield on a saturday night aka my worst nightmare grimy and music that i absolutely hate | i thought of a superhero movie but then when the vocals came in my mind went blank | our hero has reached a breaking point and plans to kick so major butt someone …
── Original B: in a jazz bar again or maybe just a cocktail bar sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time | the song reminds me of goofy old cartoons and makes me think of the looney toons | i think this is what elevator music should be and sound like i enjoyed this very much | instantly the chuckle brothers ca…
Model A: i about being at corp nightclub in sheffield on a saturday night aka my worst nightmare grimy and that i absolutely hate endofinput i of a superhero but then when the vocals came in my mind went blank endofinput our hero has reached a breaking point and plans to kick so major butt someone messed wit…
Model B: in a again or maybe just a cocktail sipping cocktails and having a relaxing time endofinput the me of goofy old cartoons and me of the looney toons endofinput i this is what elevator should be and i enjoyed this very much endofinput instantly the chuckle brothers came tor mind and then a cat cafe wh…
[10] Sim=0.4455 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs Met_LOW_09 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
── Original B: i thought about playing guitar hero with friends in my friends garage this made me nostalgic to my junior high days where everything was easy there were no bills and i just spent time with friends doing dumb things | the music that starts just before an epic boss fight and the boss is revealed and s…
Model A: i myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh endofinput in my mind i see a similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the air is filled wit…
Model B: i about hero with friends in my friends garage this me nostalgic to my junior high days where everything was easy there were no bills and i just spent time with friends doing dumb things endofinput the that starts just before an epic boss fight and the boss is revealed and starts hunting down the ma…Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_A9_para.png
All Group A models share the same 64-document dataset (or a 64-document dataset with the same row ordering), so pair indices are consistent. TF-IDF is used as the reference for the side-by-side heatmap as it is the most interpretable baseline.
=================================================================
Group A — Rank Correlation of Pair Similarity Orderings
=================================================================
Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/groupA_rank_correlation.png
RANK CORRELATION MATRIX — Group A
(Pearson r on ranked pairwise similarity scores)
TF-IDF W2V-lvl2a W2V-lvl1a BERT BERTweet para-MiniLM MiniLM mpnet para-mpnet
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TF-IDF 1.000* 0.701* 0.604* 0.554* 0.175* 0.324* 0.282* 0.303* 0.556*
W2V-lvl2a 1.000* 0.891* 0.705* 0.135* 0.328* 0.335* 0.436* 0.672*
W2V-lvl1a 1.000* 0.703* 0.147* 0.235* 0.243* 0.371* 0.596*
BERT 1.000* 0.264* 0.266* 0.306* 0.540* 0.651*
BERTweet 1.000* 0.252* 0.212* 0.224* 0.231*
para-MiniLM 1.000* 0.765* 0.304* 0.439*
MiniLM 1.000* 0.338* 0.457*
mpnet 1.000* 0.630*
para-mpnet 1.000*
* p < .05
Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/groupA_jaccard_top.png
Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/groupA_jaccard_bottom.png
Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/groupA_distributions.png
SUMMARY STATISTICS — Group A
Model Mean Median SD Min Max
------------------------------------------------------------------
TF-IDF 0.1257 0.1212 0.0360 0.0501 0.3213
W2V-lvl2a 0.9196 0.9233 0.0260 0.8114 0.9782
W2V-lvl1a 0.9652 0.9670 0.0118 0.9117 0.9882
BERT 0.9611 0.9625 0.0104 0.9095 0.9834
BERTweet 0.9427 0.9446 0.0131 0.8649 0.9725
para-MiniLM 0.4699 0.4662 0.1020 0.1532 0.7614
MiniLM 0.4316 0.4315 0.1073 0.1373 0.7548
mpnet 0.7045 0.7142 0.0790 0.3373 0.8993
para-mpnet 0.6561 0.6571 0.0764 0.3878 0.8745
Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/groupA_cross_model_heatmap.png
CROSS-MODEL SCORES — Group A (reference: TF-IDF top/bottom 10 pairs)
================================================================================
[TOP]
A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
B: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
TF-IDF 0.3213
W2V-lvl2a 0.9646
W2V-lvl1a 0.9809
BERT 0.9750
BERTweet 0.9587
para-MiniLM 0.6496
MiniLM 0.6372
mpnet 0.8032
para-mpnet 0.8168
[TOP]
A: feels very busy like i am driving around doing something important something is happening going on or i have a task i need to do urgently | makes me think of those gaming bars where you drink and they have old games consoles like pac man etc or in a 70s 80s 90s themed bar | i imagined being in rave …
B: i thought about an old sonic game i thought about the original sonic map and sonic running around i thought about the jumping noise that he makes | myself playing contra its a video game in my bedroom sitting on the floor with my back against my bed | a rave lots of strobe lighting and people jumpin…
TF-IDF 0.3080
W2V-lvl2a 0.9655
W2V-lvl1a 0.9850
BERT 0.9659
BERTweet 0.9633
para-MiniLM 0.6376
MiniLM 0.5345
mpnet 0.7473
para-mpnet 0.7599
[TOP]
A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
B: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
TF-IDF 0.2920
W2V-lvl2a 0.9713
W2V-lvl1a 0.9871
BERT 0.9720
BERTweet 0.9584
para-MiniLM 0.4649
MiniLM 0.4504
mpnet 0.8024
para-mpnet 0.7288
[TOP]
A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
B: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
TF-IDF 0.2891
W2V-lvl2a 0.9643
W2V-lvl1a 0.9791
BERT 0.9753
BERTweet 0.9661
para-MiniLM 0.4574
MiniLM 0.5036
mpnet 0.7617
para-mpnet 0.7752
[TOP]
A: sounds cosy | in my bedroom studying for an important exam with various books open while i read | it was the music youd expect to hear as the hero entered a villains bar or lounge in a noir movie | a movie scene in a speakeasy black and white or the brown filter whose name i cannot remember maybe a …
B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
TF-IDF 0.2845
W2V-lvl2a 0.9688
W2V-lvl1a 0.9835
BERT 0.9770
BERTweet 0.9399
para-MiniLM 0.5819
MiniLM 0.6071
mpnet 0.7596
para-mpnet 0.7661
[TOP]
A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
TF-IDF 0.2837
W2V-lvl2a 0.9730
W2V-lvl1a 0.9852
BERT 0.9771
BERTweet 0.9525
para-MiniLM 0.6180
MiniLM 0.5109
mpnet 0.7390
para-mpnet 0.8136
[TOP]
A: very dynamic could be swaying to the music with someone you care about could be sat with a drink alone thinking about your life something important | again jazz bar in new york city cocktails flowing older clientele everyone nicely dressed atmospheric lighting | i imagined my self watching a live ba…
B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
TF-IDF 0.2818
W2V-lvl2a 0.9782
W2V-lvl1a 0.9843
BERT 0.9744
BERTweet 0.9401
para-MiniLM 0.7195
MiniLM 0.6530
mpnet 0.8059
para-mpnet 0.8189
[TOP]
A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
B: it did not sound like a video game if anything maybe the end credits or something again sounded like something sad or emotional youd hear being played in a bar makes you reflect on your life while having a drink alone | does not fit with what i would imagine for a video game but does make me imagine…
TF-IDF 0.2811
W2V-lvl2a 0.9738
W2V-lvl1a 0.9841
BERT 0.9717
BERTweet 0.9384
para-MiniLM 0.6291
MiniLM 0.4345
mpnet 0.7647
para-mpnet 0.7030
[TOP]
A: sounds like a car chase action scene | driving a flying car in the future and weaving through traffic | it was like a science fiction cyberpunk style space scene music building up to some massive fight | seemed like an adventure film maybe a scene from blade runner | the only thing i can think of is…
B: very charged sounds like a song i have heard before in an advert about you would not steal a blank feels like its telling you something feels important or like you need to be paying attention | gave much more upbeat energy imagining a car racing through the streets at night with neon lights around o…
TF-IDF 0.2752
W2V-lvl2a 0.9648
W2V-lvl1a 0.9839
BERT 0.9726
BERTweet 0.9575
para-MiniLM 0.5799
MiniLM 0.4259
mpnet 0.6323
para-mpnet 0.7276
[TOP]
A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
B: i was thinking of a scene in a christmas film where two people are in a posh restaurant | a jazz bar or slow dance in a movie scene | i can see a jazz stage the instruments on the side a curtain slowing raising show a beautifully dressed woman who is about to sing | i could imagine myself in a smoke…
TF-IDF 0.2745
W2V-lvl2a 0.9678
W2V-lvl1a 0.9866
BERT 0.9750
BERTweet 0.9684
para-MiniLM 0.7614
MiniLM 0.6384
mpnet 0.8245
para-mpnet 0.8442
[BOTTOM]
A: very heavy rock not for me somewhere that i do not belong did not enjoy | middle aged men who ride motorbikes with long grey beards mosh pits dark night time concert loud headbanging | i imagined my self watching a bunch of heavy metal songs with my favorite headset on | it felt like i was at a meta…
B: i could see a loading screen for a video game an anime girl sitting on a seat in the window knees to her chest its cozy but also futuristic outside the window it seems to be raining above a cityscape we seem to be very high above the ground the clouds are blocking the view downwards | i felt a space…
TF-IDF 0.0501
W2V-lvl2a 0.8770
W2V-lvl1a 0.9494
BERT 0.9599
BERTweet 0.9426
para-MiniLM 0.3340
MiniLM 0.3865
mpnet 0.5810
para-mpnet 0.5345
[BOTTOM]
A: i imagined myself in a restaurant maybe in the usa rather than the uk a calm evening meal probably at somewhere quite posh | in my mind i could see a jazz bar similar to one you might see in the 1920s there is a couple dancing nearby there is colored woman on stage taking a break from singing the ai…
B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good | not sure where this would fit cannot especially imagine it working very well | sort of reminds me of a few racing mobile games i used to play on my first real smartphone very nostalgic | tha…
TF-IDF 0.0507
W2V-lvl2a 0.8674
W2V-lvl1a 0.9328
BERT 0.9308
BERTweet 0.9403
para-MiniLM 0.2384
MiniLM 0.1680
mpnet 0.5739
para-mpnet 0.4868
[BOTTOM]
A: when i was a kid spending an afternoon with my grandma doing jigsaw puzzles | first thought was the greatest video game of all time la noir its straight out of a 40s jazz club or a prohibition era speakeasy | at first i could imagine a browser window with a cafe ambient video playing and then i coul…
B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good | not sure where this would fit cannot especially imagine it working very well | sort of reminds me of a few racing mobile games i used to play on my first real smartphone very nostalgic | tha…
TF-IDF 0.0543
W2V-lvl2a 0.8790
W2V-lvl1a 0.9380
BERT 0.9449
BERTweet 0.9236
para-MiniLM 0.3636
MiniLM 0.3350
mpnet 0.6940
para-mpnet 0.5699
[BOTTOM]
A: very peppy like lift music again feels busy like you need to do something maybe walking through a shopping center listening to this in the background | fun supermarket shopping scene in a coming of age movie | reminds me of a tom jerry show i used to watch the sound track playing in the background w…
B: i thought about being at corp nightclub in sheffield on a saturday night aka my worst nightmare grimy and music that i absolutely hate | i thought of a superhero movie but then when the vocals came in my mind went blank | our hero has reached a breaking point and plans to kick so major butt someone …
TF-IDF 0.0545
W2V-lvl2a 0.8925
W2V-lvl1a 0.9538
BERT 0.9621
BERTweet 0.9314
para-MiniLM 0.4860
MiniLM 0.5685
mpnet 0.7113
para-mpnet 0.6284
[BOTTOM]
A: i thought about a mystery or crime film i thought about a black and white film where the main character is a detective from the 50s and the woman playing the piano is in a red dress at a bar it seemed very old school to me | a movie character sitting in a bar drinking all alone after a bad news he r…
B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good | not sure where this would fit cannot especially imagine it working very well | sort of reminds me of a few racing mobile games i used to play on my first real smartphone very nostalgic | tha…
TF-IDF 0.0574
W2V-lvl2a 0.8694
W2V-lvl1a 0.9433
BERT 0.9423
BERTweet 0.9334
para-MiniLM 0.4594
MiniLM 0.3158
mpnet 0.6101
para-mpnet 0.5733
[BOTTOM]
A: phoning some company for help and then being put on hold for a long time while this music plays | it sounds like elevator music or the music you get on a call when you are put on hold would also fit a generic supermarket in a movie | music in some sort of speakeasy if you have ever watched broad cit…
B: i thought about being at corp nightclub in sheffield on a saturday night aka my worst nightmare grimy and music that i absolutely hate | i thought of a superhero movie but then when the vocals came in my mind went blank | our hero has reached a breaking point and plans to kick so major butt someone …
TF-IDF 0.0590
W2V-lvl2a 0.8757
W2V-lvl1a 0.9551
BERT 0.9639
BERTweet 0.9394
para-MiniLM 0.4579
MiniLM 0.5127
mpnet 0.7339
para-mpnet 0.6654
[BOTTOM]
A: very dynamic could see people dancing to this in a bar or somewhere similar jazzy very fun and upbeat | jazz club cocktails and high end ladies in fancy dresses and men in suits potentially some people up dancing at the front in a swing style | i imagined my self in the audience watching a live orch…
B: i could see a loading screen for a video game an anime girl sitting on a seat in the window knees to her chest its cozy but also futuristic outside the window it seems to be raining above a cityscape we seem to be very high above the ground the clouds are blocking the view downwards | i felt a space…
TF-IDF 0.0594
W2V-lvl2a 0.9052
W2V-lvl1a 0.9611
BERT 0.9618
BERTweet 0.9488
para-MiniLM 0.4168
MiniLM 0.4934
mpnet 0.5639
para-mpnet 0.5607
[BOTTOM]
A: sounds quite magical and whimsical | playing a video game and entering a new zone area | it sounded like an extended version of a 90s console start up sound | i imagined an 80s esque piece abstract at first with a navy blue background fog and cold white blue ambient lighting the last 13th of the son…
B: very charged maybe you have won something or won a battle hyped up possibly ending credits meant to be good | not sure where this would fit cannot especially imagine it working very well | sort of reminds me of a few racing mobile games i used to play on my first real smartphone very nostalgic | tha…
TF-IDF 0.0594
W2V-lvl2a 0.9013
W2V-lvl1a 0.9508
BERT 0.9532
BERTweet 0.9507
para-MiniLM 0.5247
MiniLM 0.4445
mpnet 0.7434
para-mpnet 0.6350
[BOTTOM]
A: i thought about my dad being in a jazz concert my dad loved jazz and wherever i hear it i think about him this song brought feelings of nostalgia and curiosity | i imagined myself walking into an empty church building where the music instruments are being tested before church service | it did not hi…
B: i thought about being at corp nightclub in sheffield on a saturday night aka my worst nightmare grimy and music that i absolutely hate | i thought of a superhero movie but then when the vocals came in my mind went blank | our hero has reached a breaking point and plans to kick so major butt someone …
TF-IDF 0.0595
W2V-lvl2a 0.8857
W2V-lvl1a 0.9614
BERT 0.9655
BERTweet 0.9433
para-MiniLM 0.3835
MiniLM 0.3643
mpnet 0.7837
para-mpnet 0.7051
[BOTTOM]
A: the music felt really 80s and so it was an image of a 80s style hawaiian bar with hula style decor | the music evokes the feeling of wanting to dance with friends | it made me think about my husband and i miss him wanted to dance and laugh with him just listening to this music sound | i imagined mys…
B: when i was much younger playing guitar hero | sounds like boss fight music straight out a jrpg like yakuza | a heavy metal guitar hero game playing guitar hero on the wii | i could imagine the screen for guitar hero on display and someone playing with their friend | this music evokes the sense of fr…
TF-IDF 0.0598
W2V-lvl2a 0.8279
W2V-lvl1a 0.9262
BERT 0.9284
BERTweet 0.9442
para-MiniLM 0.3312
MiniLM 0.3383
mpnet 0.4782
para-mpnet 0.5558
Data: dataMIMC_preprocessed.csv | Preprocessing: lvl2a (aggressive)
TF-IDF on individual ~10–50 word texts. Most pairs will share zero or very few words, producing near-uniform low similarity. This demonstrates empirically why TF-IDF is unsuitable for individual-level analysis.
=================================================================B1 — TF-IDF (individual, lvl2a)================================================================= Pairs: 1,764,380 | skipped — identical: 11 | short (<5 words): 128,094 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_19 / videogame vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: it sounds like the music from a car racing game
── Original B: i imagined a car racing game for this scene
Model A: car racing
Model B: car racing
[2] Sim=1.0000 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / videogame vs Jaz_MED_07 / movie
── Original A: i am watching a romantic movie from the 90s and this is playing
── Original B: watching a romantic scene on a movie
Model A: watch romantic
Model B: watch romantic
[3] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_19 / concert
── Original A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
Model A: energetic strong beat powerful electric
Model B: energetic strong beat powerful electric
[4] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_19 / bar vs 80s_LOW_02 / movie
── Original A: when am in a restaurant
── Original B: sounded like music at a bar restaurant
Model A: restaurant
Model B: restaurant
[5] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs 80s_LOW_02 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like a song that plays for the credits at the end of a movie
── Original B: imagined end credits of a game
Model A: credit end
Model B: end credit
[6] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: sounds like a song that plays for the credits at the end of a movie
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: credit end
Model B: end credit
[7] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_19 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: the music is in the arcade game
── Original B: sounded just like arcade video game music
Model A: arcade
Model B: arcade
[8] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: imagined end credits of a game
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: end credit
Model B: end credit
[9] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / movie vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: in a band when i was watching a movie
── Original B: i thought of watching movie with that sound
Model A: watch
Model B: watch
[10] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_MED_20 / videogame vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like it would be in guitar hero
── Original B: i am playing guitar hero to this song i am rocking out
Model A: hero
Model B: hero
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / videogame vs Met_MED_20 / bar
── Original A: while playing swede video games with my friends
── Original B: i would say it is still an instrumental music mostly presented in a stage with live audience
Model A: swede friend
Model B: say still mostly present stage live audience
[2] Sim=0.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / videogame vs Met_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: while playing swede video games with my friends
── Original B: i pictured music performed live on stage
Model A: swede friend
Model B: perform live stage
[3] Sim=0.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / videogame vs Jaz_LOW_19 / bar
── Original A: while playing swede video games with my friends
── Original B: the beginning had a sinister vibe it reminded me of bowser castle in mario cart however the jazz music brought a happier tone vibe
Model A: swede friend
Model B: beginning sinister vibe bowser castle mario cart however bring happier tone vibe
[4] Sim=0.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / videogame vs Ele_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: while playing swede video games with my friends
── Original B: reminded me of the matrix or blade runner someone running down the street in pursuit of something someone technological and modern devices
Model A: swede friend
Model B: matrix blade runner someone run street pursuit something someone technological modern device
[5] Sim=0.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_MED_08 / videogame vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: while playing swede video games with my friends
── Original B: instantly the chuckle brothers came tor mind and then a cat cafe which is white and has cats everywhere light hearted cheery vibe
Model A: swede friend
Model B: instantly chuckle brother come tor mind cat cafe white cat everywhere light hearted cheery vibe
[6] Sim=0.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / videogame vs Met_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: while playing swede video games with my friends
── Original B: reminded me of an iron maiden acdc concert overwhelmed and too loud
Model A: swede friend
Model B: iron maiden acdc overwhelm loud
[7] Sim=0.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / videogame vs 80s_LOW_02 / movie
── Original A: while playing swede video games with my friends
── Original B: reminded me of a cowboy riding his horse over a sand hill into the desert smoking western style
Model A: swede friend
Model B: cowboy rid horse sand hill desert smoking western style
[8] Sim=0.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / videogame vs Ele_LOW_09 / concert
── Original A: while playing swede video games with my friends
── Original B: being at a rave tightly packed in and surrounded by people lots of light rays from the stage going over the crowd overwhelmed and uncomfortable
Model A: swede friend
Model B: rave tightly pack surround people lot light ray stage go crowd overwhelm uncomfortable
[9] Sim=0.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / videogame vs Ele_MED_19 / bar
── Original A: while playing swede video games with my friends
── Original B: i instantly imagined myself sat in a bar by myself feeling pretty down and then when the beat dropped i imagined locking eyes with someone this music feels like meeting someone special for the first time
Model A: swede friend
Model B: instantly sit feel pretty beat drop lock eye someone feel meet someone special first time
[10] Sim=0.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / movie vs Met_LOW_09 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined a documentary mostly about fun facts or historic information
── Original B: i imagined a wrestling show
Model A: documentary mostly fun fact historic information
Model B: wrestling showSaved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_B1_tfidf.png
lvl2a)Data: dataMIMC_preprocessed.csv | Preprocessing: lvl2a (aggressive)
Word2Vec on individual texts with aggressive preprocessing. Short texts provide fewer words to average, making the mean vector less stable and representative.
=================================================================B2 — Word2Vec lvl2a (individual)=================================================================Warning: 3 zero vectors. Pairs: 1,764,380 | skipped — identical: 11 | short (<5 words): 128,094 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_19 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: the music is in the arcade game
── Original B: sounded just like arcade video game music
Model A: arcade
Model B: arcade
[2] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_19 / bar vs 80s_LOW_02 / movie
── Original A: when am in a restaurant
── Original B: sounded like music at a bar restaurant
Model A: restaurant
Model B: restaurant
[3] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_MED_20 / videogame vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like it would be in guitar hero
── Original B: i am playing guitar hero to this song i am rocking out
Model A: hero
Model B: hero
[4] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_19 / concert
── Original A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
Model A: energetic strong beat powerful electric
Model B: energetic strong beat powerful electric
[5] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_19 / videogame vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: it sounds like the music from a car racing game
── Original B: i imagined a car racing game for this scene
Model A: car racing
Model B: car racing
[6] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / movie vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: in a band when i was watching a movie
── Original B: i thought of watching movie with that sound
Model A: watch
Model B: watch
[7] Sim=1.0000 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / videogame vs Jaz_MED_07 / movie
── Original A: i am watching a romantic movie from the 90s and this is playing
── Original B: watching a romantic scene on a movie
Model A: watch romantic
Model B: watch romantic
[8] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: imagined end credits of a game
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: end credit
Model B: end credit
[9] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs 80s_LOW_02 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like a song that plays for the credits at the end of a movie
── Original B: imagined end credits of a game
Model A: credit end
Model B: end credit
[10] Sim=1.0000 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: sounds like a song that plays for the credits at the end of a movie
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: credit end
Model B: end credit
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=-0.1265 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs Ele_LOW_14 / concert
── Original A: playing a gta and minecraft game
── Original B: the music put me in mind of an before school
Model A: gta minecraft
Model B: put mind school
[2] Sim=-0.1215 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / concert vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like a curtain raising track at a concert
── Original B: playing a gta and minecraft game
Model A: curtain raise track
Model B: gta minecraft
[3] Sim=-0.1205 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: playing a gta and minecraft game
── Original B: reminds me of my graduation day
Model A: gta minecraft
Model B: graduation day
[4] Sim=-0.1204 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_21 / movie vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined like i was in a farm
── Original B: playing a gta and minecraft game
Model A: farm
Model B: gta minecraft
[5] Sim=-0.1168 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs Met_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: playing a gta and minecraft game
── Original B: rock music at a concert like yungblud uplifting and energetic music at a rock concert
Model A: gta minecraft
Model B: yungblud uplifting energetic
[6] Sim=-0.1150 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: it made me think remember a few raves i have been to such as dreamland and boomtown
── Original B: sounded like video game music but could also be concert music
Model A: raf dreamland boomtown
Model B: also
[7] Sim=-0.1145 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: reminds me of large gatherings and crowd
── Original B: playing a gta and minecraft game
Model A: large gathering crowd
Model B: gta minecraft
[8] Sim=-0.1138 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds more like the music played at the end of old school movies
── Original B: playing a gta and minecraft game
Model A: end old school
Model B: gta minecraft
[9] Sim=-0.1136 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined walking slowly through a peaceful garden while listening to the sounds
── Original B: playing a gta and minecraft game
Model A: walk slowly peaceful garden listen
Model B: gta minecraft
[10] Sim=-0.1127 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs Ele_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: playing a gta and minecraft game
── Original B: transition music at a concert
Model A: gta minecraft
Model B: transitionSaved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_B2_w2v_lvl2a.png
lvl1a)Data: dataMIMC_preprocessed.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
Word2Vec on light-preprocessed individual texts. Comparing B2 vs B3 shows the preprocessing effect at the individual level. Comparing B3 vs B4 (BERT) isolates contextualisation on identical individual-level inputs.
=================================================================B3 — Word2Vec lvl1a (individual)=================================================================Warning: 2 zero vectors. Pairs: 1,764,380 | skipped — identical: 11 | short (<5 words): 128,094 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.9658 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: imagined end credits of a game
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: end credits of a
Model B: the end credits of a
[2] Sim=0.9528 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_19 / concert
── Original A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
Model A: its an energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
Model B: it a energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
[3] Sim=0.9443 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_20 / concert vs Met_MED_19 / movie
── Original A: my mind instantly went to avenged sevenfold they were one of my favorite bands growing up and this sounded exactly like something i have heard before the guitar solos really gave me an uplifting mood and made me sit up in my chair i love music like this especially while working out or driving in the…
── Original B: my mind instantly went back to avenged sevenfold from a previous song in this study i love this kind of music and instantly got me hyped up more i envisioned myself in my car listening to something like this after work and jamming out to the drums especially
Model A: my mind instantly went to avenged sevenfold they were one of my favorite bands growing up and this exactly something i have heard before the solos really gave me an uplifting mood and me sit up in my chair i love this especially while working out or driving in the afternoons
Model B: my mind instantly went back to avenged sevenfold from a previous in this study i love this kind of and instantly got me hyped up more i envisioned myself in my car listening to something this after work and jamming out to the especially
[4] Sim=0.9431 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / bar vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: my exboyfriends step dad loved the band kiss and he would always play their music in his room and that is exactly what i thought about when i heard this song playing it brought some sad memories because our relationship did not end well
── Original B: this sounded kind of like the last one so it made me think about the same thing someone i used to know that was in love with the band kiss part of those memories were not good so this just made me sad again i thought about sitting in the living room and hearing him jamming in his room
Model A: my exboyfriends step dad loved the kiss and he always their in his room and that is exactly what i about when i heard this it brought some sad because our relationship did not end well
Model B: this kind of the last one so it me about the same thing someone i used to know that was in love with the kiss part of those were not good so this just me sad again i about sitting in the living room and hearing him jamming in his room
[5] Sim=0.9368 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_19 / videogame vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: the context was video game but i think even without that i would have pictured games because it sounded very typical of an older action fighting type game or maybe a science fiction racing game or something i really liked the music and imagined what kind of game it would suit as a soundtrack based o…
── Original B: it said movie so i imagined what type of movie it would fit as a soundtrack and figured probably action or science fiction but then it also gave me strong video game vibes so i started picturing that a bit too i have been very interested in terminator lately so i imagined parts of that movie and the…
Model A: the context was but i even without that i have because it very typical of an older action fighting type or maybe a science fiction racing or something i really liked the and what kind of it suit as a soundtrack based on i have played in the past and my modest experience as a hobby designer
Model B: it said so i what type of it fit as a soundtrack and figured probably action or science fiction but then it also gave me strong vibes so i started that a bit too i have been very interested in terminator lately so i parts of that and the based on it especially the retro ones although it does not fit…
[6] Sim=0.9336 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / movie vs Ele_LOW_09 / bar
── Original A: i can see undertale on my computer screen i am fighting sans but the music is not quite right i am not running my usual pacifist run so i have to attack him the sounds of my hitting him are satisfying hes going down soon oh no i have just lost so much health to him i have to do this i can do this is…
── Original B: this is the most common music that i listen to when i work out i instantly start thinking of when i am doing cardio and syncing the time that i start to speed up to the bass drop music like this makes me want to keep going even when i am tired which is why i love it so much
Model A: i can see undertale on my computer screen i am fighting sans but the is not quite right i am not running my usual pacifist run so i have to attack him the of my hitting him are satisfying hes going down soon oh no i have just lost so much health to him i have to do this i can do this is all i can
Model B: this is the most common that i listen to when i work out i instantly start of when i am doing cardio and syncing the time that i start to speed up to the bass drop this me want to keep going even when i am tired which is why i love it so much
[7] Sim=0.9329 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / movie vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: i do not know why but this just simply reminded me of a movie character walking down the street in a movie that was jolly and happy because of something that has just happened one thing that led to was me thinking about spiderman and how there is a scene where peter parker is walking down the road t…
── Original B: this sounded kind of like the last one so it made me think about the same thing someone i used to know that was in love with the band kiss part of those memories were not good so this just made me sad again i thought about sitting in the living room and hearing him jamming in his room
Model A: i do not know why but this just simply reminded me of a character walking down the street in a that was jolly and happy because of something that has just happened one thing that led to was me about spiderman and how there is a where peter parker is walking down the road to the raindrops keep fallin…
Model B: this kind of the last one so it me about the same thing someone i used to know that was in love with the kiss part of those were not good so this just me sad again i about sitting in the living room and hearing him jamming in his room
[8] Sim=0.9285 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_19 / bar vs 80s_MED_13 / bar
── Original A: at first when it was just the piano i could image it playing at an upscale and quiet bar as i could imagine a piano player performing the piece but then as the rest of the instrumental came in i could imagine it being played at a fun and lighthearted jazz bar where there is seating but also space fo…
── Original B: i was thinking that this could play at an upscale bar initially with the delicate music that was playing initially maybe at a place with a low stage and a piano with seating around it later as the vocals came in i thought it could really set the mood for a scene in some fiction where two characters …
Model A: at first when it was just the i it at an upscale and quiet as i a player performing the but then as the rest of the came in i it being played at a fun and lighthearted where there is seating but also space for people to get up and dance to the
Model B: i was that this at an upscale initially with the delicate that was initially maybe at a place with a low stage and a with seating around it later as the vocals came in i it really set the mood for a in some fiction where two characters meet for the first time
[9] Sim=0.9279 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs Met_MED_20 / movie
── Original A: it said movie so i imagined what type of movie it would fit as a soundtrack and figured probably action or science fiction but then it also gave me strong video game vibes so i started picturing that a bit too i have been very interested in terminator lately so i imagined parts of that movie and the…
── Original B: the context said movie but it did not sound movie like so i just listened to it passively mostly although it did remind me of the band falling in reverse and i thought about how it would not really suit being on a movie soundtrack as it sounded too generic
Model A: it said so i what type of it fit as a soundtrack and figured probably action or science fiction but then it also gave me strong vibes so i started that a bit too i have been very interested in terminator lately so i parts of that and the based on it especially the retro ones although it does not fit…
Model B: the context said but it did not so i just listened to it passively mostly although it did me of the falling in reverse and i about how it not really suit being on a soundtrack as it too generic
[10] Sim=0.9273 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_09 / bar vs Met_LOW_14 / bar
── Original A: the context prompt said typically heard in a bar but the music sounded like heavy metal so i wasnt sure what to imagine since i have never been to a bar that played music like that so i kind of just let my mind wander and do its thing which brought images of a rock concert by a band like kiss or dis…
── Original B: my exboyfriends step dad loved the band kiss and he would always play their music in his room and that is exactly what i thought about when i heard this song playing it brought some sad memories because our relationship did not end well
Model A: the context prompt said typically heard in a but the heavy so i wasnt sure what to since i have never been to a that played that so i kind of just let my mind wander and do its thing which brought of a by a kiss or disturbed and that was cool
Model B: my exboyfriends step dad loved the kiss and he always their in his room and that is exactly what i about when i heard this it brought some sad because our relationship did not end well
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=-0.1151 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / concert vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like a curtain raising track at a concert
── Original B: playing a gta and minecraft game
Model A: a curtain raising track at a
Model B: a gta and minecraft
[2] Sim=-0.0980 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_21 / movie vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: a person walking to work in a joyful mood
── Original B: playing a gta and minecraft game
[3] Sim=-0.0956 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs Ele_MED_19 / bar
── Original A: playing a gta and minecraft game
── Original B: a rainy day and a forest
Model A: a gta and minecraft
Model B: a rainy day and a forest
[4] Sim=-0.0826 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs 80s_LOW_02 / videogame
── Original A: playing a gta and minecraft game
── Original B: imagined end credits of a game
Model A: a gta and minecraft
Model B: end credits of a
[5] Sim=-0.0811 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs Ele_MED_20 / videogame
── Original A: playing a gta and minecraft game
── Original B: transition music at a concert
Model A: a gta and minecraft
Model B: transition at a
[6] Sim=-0.0801 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: reminds me of large gatherings and crowd
── Original B: playing a gta and minecraft game
Model A: me of large gatherings and crowd
Model B: a gta and minecraft
[7] Sim=-0.0774 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: playing a gta and minecraft game
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: a gta and minecraft
Model B: the end credits of a
[8] Sim=-0.0765 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs Met_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: playing a gta and minecraft game
── Original B: rock music at a concert like yungblud uplifting and energetic music at a rock concert
Model A: a gta and minecraft
Model B: at a yungblud uplifting and energetic at a
[9] Sim=-0.0747 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs Met_MED_20 / bar
── Original A: playing a gta and minecraft game
── Original B: thoughts of a live performance in a bar with a young and very energetic band
Model A: a gta and minecraft
Model B: thoughts of a live performance in a with a young and very energetic
[10] Sim=-0.0743 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / bar
── Original A: playing a gta and minecraft game
── Original B: a peaceful somber scene with a bunch of friends hanging out in the afternoon
Model A: a gta and minecraft
Model B: a peaceful somber with a bunch of friends hanging out in the afternoonSaved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_B3_w2v_lvl1a.png
Data: dataMIMC_preprocessed.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
BERT with mean-pooling on individual MIMC descriptions. Same architecture as A4 but on individual texts. Comparing A4 vs B4 shows how BERT behaves across scales; comparing B4 vs B5 (MiniLM) isolates the effect of similarity fine-tuning.
=================================================================B4 — BERT (individual)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (1946, 768) Pairs: 1,764,380 | skipped — identical: 11 | short (<5 words): 128,094 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.9662 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_19 / concert
── Original A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
Model A: its an energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
Model B: it a energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
[2] Sim=0.9378 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_MED_20 / bar vs Jaz_LOW_21 / bar
── Original A: i imagined hanging out at a laidback bar with friends on a weekend the music is smooth and relaxed setting a chill mood where everyones just talking laughing and unwinding people were sitting at the bar sipping drinks and just enjoying the easygoing vibe
── Original B: this music made me think of relaxing in a cozy bar with friends the jazz vibe is smooth and mellow making the whole place feel warm and welcoming people are chatting laughing and enjoying their drinks while the music plays softly in the background
Model A: i hanging out at a laidback with friends on a weekend the is smooth and relaxed setting a chill mood where everyones just talking laughing and unwinding people were sitting at the sipping drinks and just enjoying the easygoing vibe
Model B: this me of relaxing in a cozy with friends the vibe is smooth and mellow the whole place feel warm and welcoming people are chatting laughing and enjoying their drinks while the softly in the background
[3] Sim=0.9284 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_MED_19 / videogame vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: the context was video game but i think even without that i would have pictured games because it sounded very typical of an older action fighting type game or maybe a science fiction racing game or something i really liked the music and imagined what kind of game it would suit as a soundtrack based o…
── Original B: it said movie so i imagined what type of movie it would fit as a soundtrack and figured probably action or science fiction but then it also gave me strong video game vibes so i started picturing that a bit too i have been very interested in terminator lately so i imagined parts of that movie and the…
Model A: the context was but i even without that i have because it very typical of an older action fighting type or maybe a science fiction racing or something i really liked the and what kind of it suit as a soundtrack based on i have played in the past and my modest experience as a hobby designer
Model B: it said so i what type of it fit as a soundtrack and figured probably action or science fiction but then it also gave me strong vibes so i started that a bit too i have been very interested in terminator lately so i parts of that and the based on it especially the retro ones although it does not fit…
[4] Sim=0.9239 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: imagined end credits of a game
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: end credits of a
Model B: the end credits of a
[5] Sim=0.9227 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_MED_19 / videogame vs 80s_LOW_02 / videogame
── Original A: the context was video game but i think even without that i would have pictured games because it sounded very typical of an older action fighting type game or maybe a science fiction racing game or something i really liked the music and imagined what kind of game it would suit as a soundtrack based o…
── Original B: the context prompt said video game but it did not really remind me of any video games i have played in the past so i tried to imagine what a game with it as a soundtrack might look and play like in the end i settled on a visual novel style game as it certainly had atmosphere but i could not picture …
Model A: the context was but i even without that i have because it very typical of an older action fighting type or maybe a science fiction racing or something i really liked the and what kind of it suit as a soundtrack based on i have played in the past and my modest experience as a hobby designer
Model B: the context prompt said but it did not really me of any i have played in the past so i tried to what a with it as a soundtrack might look and in the end i settled on a visual novel style as it certainly had atmosphere but i not mechanics to go with it and visual novel style are by nature less kineti…
[6] Sim=0.9207 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_19 / videogame vs 80s_LOW_02 / videogame
── Original A: i play a lot of video games so when i heard this piece along with the context prompt i naturally started to imagine what type of game it would suit and what part of the game inspired by games i have played in the past i found myself imagining a boss battle in a jrpg at first since it sounded dramati…
── Original B: the context prompt said video game but it did not really remind me of any video games i have played in the past so i tried to imagine what a game with it as a soundtrack might look and play like in the end i settled on a visual novel style game as it certainly had atmosphere but i could not picture …
Model A: i a lot of so when i heard this along with the context prompt i naturally started to what type of it suit and what part of the inspired by i have played in the past i found myself a boss battle in a jrpg at first since it dramatic with an edge of danger and action but once the more jazzy part kicked…
Model B: the context prompt said but it did not really me of any i have played in the past so i tried to what a with it as a soundtrack might look and in the end i settled on a visual novel style as it certainly had atmosphere but i not mechanics to go with it and visual novel style are by nature less kineti…
[7] Sim=0.9181 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_09 / videogame vs Jaz_LOW_19 / videogame
── Original A: it reminded me heavily of an edm concert type of drop so for a video game i was envisioning things like halo or tron legacy but i do not have experience with these games so something that follows similar ideas that allows multiplayer shooting games or objective based games like teams claiming territ…
── Original B: i play a lot of video games so when i heard this piece along with the context prompt i naturally started to imagine what type of game it would suit and what part of the game inspired by games i have played in the past i found myself imagining a boss battle in a jrpg at first since it sounded dramati…
Model A: it reminded me heavily of an edm type of drop so for a i was envisioning things halo or tron legacy but i do not have experience with these so something that follows similar ideas that allows multiplayer shooting or objective based teams claiming territory but more futuristic 100 futuristic the prov…
Model B: i a lot of so when i heard this along with the context prompt i naturally started to what type of it suit and what part of the inspired by i have played in the past i found myself a boss battle in a jrpg at first since it dramatic with an edge of danger and action but once the more jazzy part kicked…
[8] Sim=0.9177 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / videogame vs 80s_LOW_02 / concert
── Original A: immediately i imaged a dimly lit bar of sorts with a small intimate stage at the front small tables with two seats an orange lit lamp on each once people quietly conversing over whiskeys on ice while a band of musicians played on stage
── Original B: i imagined a band on stage in an intimate venue the audience was sat at small tables drinking wine and cocktails there was ambient warm lighting and the sound of quiet chatter over the music
Model A: immediately i a dimly lit of sorts with a small intimate stage at the front small tables with two seats an orange lit lamp on each once people quietly conversing over whiskeys on ice while a of musicians played on stage
Model B: i a on stage in an intimate venue the audience was sat at small tables drinking wine and cocktails there was ambient warm lighting and the of quiet chatter over the
[9] Sim=0.9173 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_02 / concert vs 80s_MED_13 / concert
── Original A: an introduction song at a concert the crowd is beginning to buzz with excitement as the band are all making their way to the stage loud cheers are erupting each time one of the band members enters the feeling of tension within the crowd as they anticipate the entrance of the band is lifting
── Original B: another introduction style song to play as the band are entering the stage people are getting excited there is a bustling among the crowd as the band members are entering the stage
Model A: an introduction at a the crowd is beginning to buzz with excitement as the are all their way to the stage loud cheers are erupting each time one of the members enters the feeling of tension within the crowd as they anticipate the entrance of the is lifting
Model B: another introduction style to as the are entering the stage people are getting excited there is a bustling among the crowd as the members are entering the stage
[10] Sim=0.9168 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_MED_19 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / concert
── Original A: i pictured myself at a big concert kind of like a summer music festival the crowd is moving to the beat lights flashing everywhere and people are singing along it feels fun a little hyped and everyones having a good time
── Original B: i pictured being at a packed concert with a lot of energy in the crowd people are jumping around singing along and just letting loose the whole place feels alive with bright lights and everyone feeding off the bands energy
Model A: i myself at a big kind of a summer festival the crowd is moving to the beat lights flashing everywhere and people are singing along it feels fun a little hyped and everyones having a good time
Model B: i being at a packed with a lot of energy in the crowd people are jumping around singing along and just letting loose the whole place feels alive with bright lights and everyone feeding off the bands energy
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.1631 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: i saw a silhouette of thor as he raised his hammer and lightning struck revealing his visage a warrior wearing an elk skull rose from the ground with his mighty axe in hand and he began charging
── Original B: sounded just like arcade video game music
[2] Sim=0.1896 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: i imagined my self watching a live band and feeling nostalgic while nodding my head to the rhythm of the instruments
── Original B: sounded just like arcade video game music
Model A: i my self watching a live and feeling nostalgic while nodding my head to the rhythm of the
Model B: just arcade
[3] Sim=0.2032 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / movie vs Ele_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: sounded just like arcade video game music
── Original B: for this i could imagine an older man with medium length grey hair and glasses pictured in a cafe diner with a hot drink with steam coming out pondering something with serious intent i could image from this the scene zooms out showing him through the window an a wider shot of the city which looks li…
Model A: just arcade
Model B: for this i an older man with medium length grey hair and glasses in a cafe diner with a hot drink with steam coming out pondering something with serious intent i from this the zooms out showing him through the window an a wider shot of the city which looks a gotham new york type of city is displayed…
[4] Sim=0.2110 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined my self watching a live band and feeling nostalgic while nodding my head to the rhythm of the instruments
── Original B: playing a gta and minecraft game
Model A: i my self watching a live and feeling nostalgic while nodding my head to the rhythm of the
Model B: a gta and minecraft
[5] Sim=0.2116 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / bar
── Original A: i imagined my self watching a live band and feeling nostalgic while nodding my head to the rhythm of the instruments
── Original B: it sounded like classic video game music
Model A: i my self watching a live and feeling nostalgic while nodding my head to the rhythm of the
Model B: it classic
[6] Sim=0.2127 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_MED_20 / movie vs Ele_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: i managed to pull out excalibur in a moment that it was needed most to fend off the undead horde as i raise it to the sky lightning strikes down and my eyes glow i begin charging and decapitating the ghouls with ease
── Original B: sounded just like arcade video game music
[7] Sim=0.2128 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: i found it quite hard to imagine this being played in a bar it felt more suited towards a pub or some kind of music specialist place however i could picture lots of people at the bar dressed in black leather studded clothing and rocking their heads back and forth with tattoos
── Original B: sounded just like arcade video game music
Model A: i found it quite hard to this being played in a it felt more suited towards a pub or some kind of specialist place however i lots of people at the dressed in black leather studded clothing and rocking their heads back and forth with tattoos
Model B: just arcade
[8] Sim=0.2133 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_14 / bar vs Ele_MED_19 / bar
── Original A: it sounded like classic video game music
── Original B: i imagined myself sitting in a brunch bar drinking a milkshake and waiting for a grilled sandwich the bar was somewhat dark in colour trendy
Model A: it classic
Model B: i myself sitting in a brunch drinking a milkshake and waiting for a grilled sandwich the was somewhat dark in colour trendy
[9] Sim=0.2149 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / videogame vs Ele_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: i could see a loading screen for a video game an anime girl sitting on a seat in the window knees to her chest its cozy but also futuristic outside the window it seems to be raining above a cityscape we seem to be very high above the ground the clouds are blocking the view downwards
── Original B: sounded just like arcade video game music
Model A: i see a loading screen for a an anime girl sitting on a seat in the window knees to her chest its cozy but also futuristic outside the window it seems to be raining above a cityscape we seem to be very high above the ground the clouds are blocking the view downwards
Model B: just arcade
[10] Sim=0.2153 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / videogame vs Ele_LOW_14 / concert
── Original A: i imagined walking through a forest at night time at first with a crackling fire nearby then the pace of the music picked up and i imagined myself walking with more purpose and admiring the night sky
── Original B: the music sounds like a cartoon music
Model A: i walking through a forest at night time at first with a crackling fire nearby then the pace of the picked up and i myself walking with more purpose and admiring the night sky
Model B: the a cartoonSaved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_B4_bert.png
Data: dataMIMC_preprocessed.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
BERTweet pretrained on informal short text. At the individual level, where MIMC descriptions are short and conversational, the domain match is more relevant than at the combMIMC level. Comparing B4 vs B5 isolates pretraining domain while holding architecture constant at the individual scale.
=================================================================B5 — BERTweet (individual)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (1946, 768) Pairs: 1,764,380 | skipped — identical: 11 | short (<5 words): 128,094 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.9791 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_19 / concert
── Original A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
Model A: its an energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
Model B: it a energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
[2] Sim=0.9675 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: the tune gives a driving experience
── Original B: the tune gives a cinematic experience
[3] Sim=0.9675 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_LOW_06 / concert vs Met_LOW_09 / concert
── Original A: the tune gives a driving experience
── Original B: the tune gives a cinematic experience
[4] Sim=0.9619 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / movie vs Met_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds like a music played on background of a cinema movie
── Original B: sounds a music played on a background of an action movie
Model A: a played on background of a cinema
Model B: a played on a background of an action
[5] Sim=0.9564 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_19 / bar vs 80s_MED_13 / bar
── Original A: at first when it was just the piano i could image it playing at an upscale and quiet bar as i could imagine a piano player performing the piece but then as the rest of the instrumental came in i could imagine it being played at a fun and lighthearted jazz bar where there is seating but also space fo…
── Original B: i was thinking that this could play at an upscale bar initially with the delicate music that was playing initially maybe at a place with a low stage and a piano with seating around it later as the vocals came in i thought it could really set the mood for a scene in some fiction where two characters …
Model A: at first when it was just the i it at an upscale and quiet as i a player performing the but then as the rest of the came in i it being played at a fun and lighthearted where there is seating but also space for people to get up and dance to the
Model B: i was that this at an upscale initially with the delicate that was initially maybe at a place with a low stage and a with seating around it later as the vocals came in i it really set the mood for a in some fiction where two characters meet for the first time
[6] Sim=0.9564 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_MED_20 / bar vs 80s_LOW_06 / bar
── Original A: i imagined hanging out at a laidback bar with friends on a weekend the music is smooth and relaxed setting a chill mood where everyones just talking laughing and unwinding people were sitting at the bar sipping drinks and just enjoying the easygoing vibe
── Original B: i imagined sitting in a cozy bar with dim lights and a relaxed crowd the music has a smooth jazz feel like something youd hear late at night when everyones just unwinding people were chatting quietly sipping cocktails and just enjoying the atmosphere
Model A: i hanging out at a laidback with friends on a weekend the is smooth and relaxed setting a chill mood where everyones just talking laughing and unwinding people were sitting at the sipping drinks and just enjoying the easygoing vibe
Model B: i sitting in a cozy with dim lights and a relaxed crowd the has a smooth feel something youd hear late at night when everyones just unwinding people were chatting quietly sipping cocktails and just enjoying the atmosphere
[7] Sim=0.9558 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_02 / concert vs 80s_MED_13 / concert
── Original A: an introduction song at a concert the crowd is beginning to buzz with excitement as the band are all making their way to the stage loud cheers are erupting each time one of the band members enters the feeling of tension within the crowd as they anticipate the entrance of the band is lifting
── Original B: another introduction style song to play as the band are entering the stage people are getting excited there is a bustling among the crowd as the band members are entering the stage
Model A: an introduction at a the crowd is beginning to buzz with excitement as the are all their way to the stage loud cheers are erupting each time one of the members enters the feeling of tension within the crowd as they anticipate the entrance of the is lifting
Model B: another introduction style to as the are entering the stage people are getting excited there is a bustling among the crowd as the members are entering the stage
[8] Sim=0.9552 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: the context prompt said video game but it did not really remind me of any video games i have played in the past so i tried to imagine what a game with it as a soundtrack might look and play like in the end i settled on a visual novel style game as it certainly had atmosphere but i could not picture …
── Original B: it said movie so i imagined what type of movie it would fit as a soundtrack and figured probably action or science fiction but then it also gave me strong video game vibes so i started picturing that a bit too i have been very interested in terminator lately so i imagined parts of that movie and the…
Model A: the context prompt said but it did not really me of any i have played in the past so i tried to what a with it as a soundtrack might look and in the end i settled on a visual novel style as it certainly had atmosphere but i not mechanics to go with it and visual novel style are by nature less kineti…
Model B: it said so i what type of it fit as a soundtrack and figured probably action or science fiction but then it also gave me strong vibes so i started that a bit too i have been very interested in terminator lately so i parts of that and the based on it especially the retro ones although it does not fit…
[9] Sim=0.9548 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_19 / bar vs Ele_MED_19 / bar
── Original A: at first when it was just the piano i could image it playing at an upscale and quiet bar as i could imagine a piano player performing the piece but then as the rest of the instrumental came in i could imagine it being played at a fun and lighthearted jazz bar where there is seating but also space fo…
── Original B: i was thinking that initially i could see this being played a piano at a small and intimate venue but when the beat and other elements of the instrumental kicked in i was visualising this playing over a set of speakers in a midsized bar full of younger patrons
Model A: at first when it was just the i it at an upscale and quiet as i a player performing the but then as the rest of the came in i it being played at a fun and lighthearted where there is seating but also space for people to get up and dance to the
Model B: i was that initially i see this being played a at a small and intimate venue but when the beat and other elements of the kicked in i was this over a set of speakers in a midsized full of younger patrons
[10] Sim=0.9546 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_MED_20 / bar vs Jaz_LOW_21 / bar
── Original A: i imagined hanging out at a laidback bar with friends on a weekend the music is smooth and relaxed setting a chill mood where everyones just talking laughing and unwinding people were sitting at the bar sipping drinks and just enjoying the easygoing vibe
── Original B: this music made me think of relaxing in a cozy bar with friends the jazz vibe is smooth and mellow making the whole place feel warm and welcoming people are chatting laughing and enjoying their drinks while the music plays softly in the background
Model A: i hanging out at a laidback with friends on a weekend the is smooth and relaxed setting a chill mood where everyones just talking laughing and unwinding people were sitting at the sipping drinks and just enjoying the easygoing vibe
Model B: this me of relaxing in a cozy with friends the vibe is smooth and mellow the whole place feel warm and welcoming people are chatting laughing and enjoying their drinks while the softly in the background
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=0.1750 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs 80s_LOW_02 / videogame
── Original A: black ops 3 zombie music
── Original B: i can sort of imagine a romantic scene in a movie or some kind of slow paced scene in a bar i know the actual context was a video game but it did not actually make me think of a video game necessarily it made me think of a cutscene within a video game which is kind of like a movie based cinematic in…
Model A: black ops 3 zombie
Model B: i can sort of a romantic in a or some kind of slow paced in a i know the actual context was a but it did not actually me of a necessarily it me of a cutscene within a which is kind of a based cinematic in a sense it did not me feel too much i was on the fence whether to select yes or no
[2] Sim=0.1806 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Ele_LOW_09 / concert
── Original A: black ops 3 zombie music
── Original B: i felt like i was at a drum and bass concert i do not like that music or similar like in the clip and have never had enough energy to enjoy such a concert so it felt more annoying than emotionally good
Model A: black ops 3 zombie
Model B: i felt i was at a and bass i do not that or similar in the and have never had enough energy to enjoy such a so it felt more annoying than emotionally good
[3] Sim=0.1831 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs 80s_MED_13 / bar
── Original A: black ops 3 zombie music
── Original B: i was thinking that this could play at an upscale bar initially with the delicate music that was playing initially maybe at a place with a low stage and a piano with seating around it later as the vocals came in i thought it could really set the mood for a scene in some fiction where two characters …
Model A: black ops 3 zombie
Model B: i was that this at an upscale initially with the delicate that was initially maybe at a place with a low stage and a with seating around it later as the vocals came in i it really set the mood for a in some fiction where two characters meet for the first time
[4] Sim=0.2009 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Jaz_MED_07 / concert
── Original A: black ops 3 zombie music
── Original B: i was thinking that i could easily see the scene where a female singer is on stage and the instrumental to the song she is about to perform is playing behind her are her live band who are playing the instrumental she herself is standing at her microphone stand nodding to the music and ready to come …
Model A: black ops 3 zombie
Model B: i was that i easily see the where a female is on stage and the to the she is about to perform is behind her are her live who are the she herself is standing at her microphone stand nodding to the and ready to come in when it is her cue
[5] Sim=0.2039 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Met_MED_19 / videogame
── Original A: black ops 3 zombie music
── Original B: the context was video game but i think even without that i would have pictured games because it sounded very typical of an older action fighting type game or maybe a science fiction racing game or something i really liked the music and imagined what kind of game it would suit as a soundtrack based o…
Model A: black ops 3 zombie
Model B: the context was but i even without that i have because it very typical of an older action fighting type or maybe a science fiction racing or something i really liked the and what kind of it suit as a soundtrack based on i have played in the past and my modest experience as a hobby designer
[6] Sim=0.2043 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs 80s_LOW_02 / concert
── Original A: black ops 3 zombie music
── Original B: even though there was not one present in the music itself i visualised a huge orchestra in the background of a man with a saxophone on a huge stadium like stage the man was lit in limelight and playing with passion the piano player was also lit up with smaller stage lighting and there was a lot of m…
Model A: black ops 3 zombie
Model B: even though there was not one present in the itself i a huge orchestra in the background of a man with a on a huge stadium stage the man was lit in limelight and with passion the player was also lit up with smaller stage lighting and there was a lot of mist in the air fog machine the featured a lot …
[7] Sim=0.2046 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Jaz_LOW_21 / movie
── Original A: black ops 3 zombie music
── Original B: slap stick comedy type of montage of clips during a film perhaps doing some funny events or combining a bunch of scenes into one loft lobby hotel music so could be very effective in this scene location as well also gave me feelings of old french films or perhaps european non english speaking film pe…
Model A: black ops 3 zombie
Model B: slap stick comedy type of montage of during a perhaps doing some funny events or combining a bunch of into one loft lobby hotel so be very effective in this location as well also gave me feelings of old french or perhaps european non english speaking perhaps still comedy or black and white vintage o…
[8] Sim=0.2088 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Ele_LOW_09 / concert
── Original A: black ops 3 zombie music
── Original B: i really could see this being the extended remix of a really hype song that plays at a kpop or jpop concert i was really clearly picturing this as the opening for a song designed for the idols to show off a complicated dance routine with many backup dancers to create a visual spectacle
Model A: black ops 3 zombie
Model B: i really see this being the extended remix of a really hype that at a kpop or jpop i was really clearly this as the opening for a designed for the idols to show off a complicated dance routine with many backup dancers to create a visual spectacle
[9] Sim=0.2092 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Met_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: black ops 3 zombie music
── Original B: i could easily imagine this being a punk band maybe like fall out boy during an instrumental section of their song the band i was imagining are somewhat close to the edge of the stage with fans equally pressed up against the edge of the stage i was imagining the band really into what they were playi…
Model A: black ops 3 zombie
Model B: i easily this being a punk maybe fall out boy during an section of their the i was are somewhat close to the edge of the stage with fans equally pressed up against the edge of the stage i was the really into what they were completely lost in the
[10] Sim=0.2102 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_02 / bar vs Jaz_LOW_19 / bar
── Original A: black ops 3 zombie music
── Original B: at first when it was just the piano i could image it playing at an upscale and quiet bar as i could imagine a piano player performing the piece but then as the rest of the instrumental came in i could imagine it being played at a fun and lighthearted jazz bar where there is seating but also space fo…
Model A: black ops 3 zombie
Model B: at first when it was just the i it at an upscale and quiet as i a player performing the but then as the rest of the came in i it being played at a fun and lighthearted where there is seating but also space for people to get up and dance to theSaved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_B5_bertweet.png
Data: dataMIMC_preprocessed.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
Paraphrase-tuned variant of MiniLM. At the individual level, different participants describing the same mental experience in different words is precisely a paraphrase task. Comparing B6 vs B7 (all-MiniLM) isolates fine-tuning objective within the same architecture on identical individual-level inputs.
=================================================================B6 — paraphrase-MiniLM-L6-v2 (individual)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (1946, 384) Pairs: 1,764,380 | skipped — identical: 11 | short (<5 words): 128,094 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.9833 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_19 / concert
── Original A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
Model A: its an energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
Model B: it a energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
[2] Sim=0.9808 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: imagined end credits of a game
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: end credits of a
Model B: the end credits of a
[3] Sim=0.9498 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / videogame vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: a band playing on a stage more of a rock heavy metal band
── Original B: a band on stage playing the song with big guitars like a heavy rock band
Model A: a on a stage more of a heavy
Model B: a on stage the with big a heavy
[4] Sim=0.9158 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_19 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a powerful electric guitar
Model A: it a energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
Model B: it a energetic with a powerful electric
[5] Sim=0.8969 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_19 / concert vs Jaz_MED_02 / bar
── Original A: jazz music played in classy restaurants and events
── Original B: sounds more like cool and classy jazz music played in classy events and restaurants
Model A: played in classy restaurants and events
Model B: more cool and classy played in classy events and restaurants
[6] Sim=0.8942 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a powerful electric guitar
Model A: its an energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
Model B: it a energetic with a powerful electric
[7] Sim=0.8883 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_21 / bar vs Met_LOW_09 / bar
── Original A: it reminds me of my early twenties when i was in college i used to party a lot and go to the bars
── Original B: reminds me of my college days when i used to party a lot
Model A: it me of my early twenties when i was in college i used to party a lot and go to the
Model B: me of my college days when i used to party a lot
[8] Sim=0.8747 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / bar vs 80s_LOW_02 / concert
── Original A: people dancing romantically in a bar
── Original B: a romantic scene people dancing in each others arms
Model A: people dancing romantically in a
Model B: a romantic people dancing in each others arms
[9] Sim=0.8744 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds from a pac man arcade machine
── Original B: playing a video game such as pac man in an arcade
Model A: from a pac man arcade machine
Model B: a such as pac man in an arcade
[10] Sim=0.8676 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_MED_19 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: this also sounded like the opening scene of an anime
── Original B: sounds like the opening for a shonen anime
Model A: this also the opening of an anime
Model B: the opening for a shonen anime
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=-0.2935 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_MED_20 / concert vs Ele_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: this is the kind of background music you hear when some big tech company makes some major innovation in the sphere and decides to make a five minute long info dump explaining why this 1000 dollars smartphone is different from the one you just bought
── Original B: the scene i imaged would be at a chilled music festival in the countryside or woodlands and calmly dancing
Model A: this is the kind of background you hear when some big tech company some major innovation in the sphere and decides to a five minute long info dump explaining why this 1000 dollars smartphone is different from the one you just bought
Model B: the i be at a chilled festival in the countryside or woodlands and calmly dancing
[2] Sim=-0.2572 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_19 / movie
── Original A: the sound was really soothing and made me imagined playing it for my pet to sleep
── Original B: a woman in a movie scene moving across the street in a round skirt seeing a handsome man on the other end
Model A: the was really soothing and me it for my pet to sleep
Model B: a woman in a moving across the street in a round skirt seeing a handsome man on the other end
[3] Sim=-0.2537 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Ele_MED_20 / bar
── Original A: very heavy rock not for me somewhere that i do not belong did not enjoy
── Original B: the scene was a new computer operating system start up sound with that song being the start up sound
Model A: very heavy not for me somewhere that i do not belong did not enjoy
Model B: the was a new computer operating system start up with that being the start up
[4] Sim=-0.2479 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Ele_LOW_09 / bar
── Original A: very heavy rock not for me somewhere that i do not belong did not enjoy
── Original B: sounds like the kind of music tech companies play when announcing a new phone
Model A: very heavy not for me somewhere that i do not belong did not enjoy
Model B: the kind of tech companies when announcing a new phone
[5] Sim=-0.2462 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / movie vs 80s_MED_08 / bar
── Original A: i imagined the main character of a dark action movie getting their weapons and tools ready so they can plot out how to take down their enemy
── Original B: the music is a county music it is very enjoyable
Model A: i the main character of a dark action getting their weapons and tools ready so they can plot out how to take down their enemy
Model B: the is a county it is very enjoyable
[6] Sim=-0.2435 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs 80s_MED_13 / bar
── Original A: breaking up with someone who i have been dating for a long time and then they start crying
── Original B: i definitely did not imagine a bar but i did envision watching one of the early 2000s educational science videos in elementary school it felt magical and nostalgic
[7] Sim=-0.2410 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_21 / movie vs Met_LOW_09 / bar
── Original A: i could imagine this playing in a grocery store as a family is walking down an aisle looking for groceries
── Original B: i imagined a dragon flying in the air with its wings flapping and a camera shot panning on to its sharp and white teeth it also started to breathe out flames during the part of the song wear the vocalist was slightly screaming
Model A: i this in a grocery store as a family is walking down an aisle looking for groceries
Model B: i a dragon flying in the air with its wings flapping and a camera shot panning on to its sharp and white teeth it also started to breathe out flames during the part of the wear the vocalist was slightly screaming
[8] Sim=-0.2397 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_14 / movie vs 80s_LOW_02 / movie
── Original A: a video game specifically a fighting game but on the character selection screen
── Original B: i imagined driving home after a stressful day at work and with the thoughts of how life has been unfair with me in areas where i gave in my all and did not get to achieve my goals
Model A: a specifically a fighting but on the character selection screen
Model B: i driving home after a stressful day at work and with the thoughts of how life has been unfair with me in areas where i gave in my all and did not get to achieve my goals
[9] Sim=-0.2375 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Ele_LOW_14 / bar vs Met_MED_19 / bar
── Original A: a bunch of little aliens performing a tech concert
── Original B: it felt like my blood was rising a bit overwhelming but also like i needed to just let lose crash out and enjoy myself
Model A: a bunch of little aliens performing a tech
Model B: it felt my blood was rising a bit overwhelming but also i needed to just let lose crash out and enjoy myself
[10] Sim=-0.2373 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / videogame vs Met_MED_20 / movie
── Original A: i imagined a hacker trying his hardest to hack into a company to find out something about one of his friends it gets more and more intense as his screen shows a lot of windows and numbers with him trying his best to figure this code out he finally achieves this
── Original B: i enjoyed this instrumental sound it is suitable for rock and band musicals
Model A: i a hacker trying his hardest to hack into a company to find out something about one of his friends it gets more and more intense as his screen shows a lot of windows and numbers with him trying his best to figure this code out he finally achieves this
Model B: i enjoyed this it is suitable for and musicalsSaved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_B6_para_minilm.png
Data: dataMIMC_preprocessed.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
Fine-tuned for semantic similarity. Comparing B4 vs B7 on identical inputs isolates the effect of similarity fine-tuning at the individual level.
=================================================================B7 — all-MiniLM-L6-v2 (individual)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (1946, 384) Pairs: 1,764,380 | skipped — identical: 11 | short (<5 words): 128,094 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.9901 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_19 / concert
── Original A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
Model A: its an energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
Model B: it a energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
[2] Sim=0.9556 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: imagined end credits of a game
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: end credits of a
Model B: the end credits of a
[3] Sim=0.9199 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / videogame vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: a band playing on a stage more of a rock heavy metal band
── Original B: a band on stage playing the song with big guitars like a heavy rock band
Model A: a on a stage more of a heavy
Model B: a on stage the with big a heavy
[4] Sim=0.9052 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_19 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a powerful electric guitar
Model A: it a energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
Model B: it a energetic with a powerful electric
[5] Sim=0.8981 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a powerful electric guitar
Model A: its an energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
Model B: it a energetic with a powerful electric
[6] Sim=0.8740 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / bar vs 80s_LOW_02 / concert
── Original A: people dancing romantically in a bar
── Original B: a romantic scene people dancing in each others arms
Model A: people dancing romantically in a
Model B: a romantic people dancing in each others arms
[7] Sim=0.8684 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / movie vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: sounds like a song that plays for the credits at the end of a movie
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: a that for the credits at the end of a
Model B: the end credits of a
[8] Sim=0.8490 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_LOW_19 / concert vs Jaz_MED_02 / bar
── Original A: jazz music played in classy restaurants and events
── Original B: sounds more like cool and classy jazz music played in classy events and restaurants
Model A: played in classy restaurants and events
Model B: more cool and classy played in classy events and restaurants
[9] Sim=0.8408 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds from a pac man arcade machine
── Original B: playing a video game such as pac man in an arcade
Model A: from a pac man arcade machine
Model B: a such as pac man in an arcade
[10] Sim=0.8314 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_20 / movie vs 80s_MED_08 / bar
── Original A: i remembered my girlfriend love this beat so much
── Original B: my sister who loves songs with this beat
Model A: i my girlfriend love this beat so much
Model B: my sister who loves with this beat
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=-0.2099 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / videogame vs Jaz_MED_07 / concert
── Original A: a giant man plodding along the street with a cheery grin on his face greeting everyone as he walks past
── Original B: i thought of film noir crime and mystery films as well as two television series that used similar music matlock the series that aired in the 1980s and 90s and in the heat of the night this sounds like the soundtrack for a mystery or crime drama
[2] Sim=-0.1988 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / videogame vs Jaz_MED_07 / bar
── Original A: its the ending title sequence of a movie its playing character bloopers in between the credits
── Original B: made me think of jazz clubs where you can play poker and have food as well as smoke cigarettes in an underground poker club very cosy and relaxing atmosphere cigars smoke in the air
Model A: its the ending title sequence of a its character bloopers in between the credits
Model B: me of clubs where you can poker and have food as well as smoke cigarettes in an underground poker club very cosy and relaxing atmosphere cigars smoke in the air
[3] Sim=-0.1882 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / movie vs 80s_LOW_06 / concert
── Original A: rainy stormy windows in a city apartment a girl feel reenergised and at peace by it
── Original B: people are dancing at the disco people perform the soul train on the stage
[4] Sim=-0.1876 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / videogame vs Met_LOW_14 / movie
── Original A: people are relaxing at the jazz club people are watching the band perform
── Original B: an evil character making plans to kill someone in a cartoon
Model A: people are relaxing at the club people are watching the perform
Model B: an evil character plans to kill someone in a cartoon
[5] Sim=-0.1864 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
80s_MED_08 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: the character arrives at the beach section
── Original B: i thought about my mum she had tons of records that sounded exactly like this we would listen to these nonstop back then
[6] Sim=-0.1813 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / movie vs Ele_MED_20 / bar
── Original A: someone playing the guitar someone that looks like jason momoa probably because i have watched game of thrones recently then also occasionally some anime scenes
── Original B: feel like i am at a work conference where a company is launching a new product not bar like at all
Model A: someone the someone that looks jason momoa probably because i have watched of thrones recently then also occasionally some anime
Model B: feel i am at a work conference where a company is launching a new product not at all
[7] Sim=-0.1797 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / videogame vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: i could picture a guy struggling but preparing himself for the physical challenge he is embarking on
── Original B: my thoughts were when i attended a concert they always play tunes like that
Model A: i a guy struggling but preparing himself for the physical challenge he is embarking on
Model B: my thoughts were when i attended a they always tunes that
[8] Sim=-0.1796 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / movie vs Ele_MED_19 / concert
── Original A: it brought a memory where things were in a chaotic mess for me i had just lost my job and i could not think straight back then so i usually play hard rock music i thought that could make my worry less
── Original B: the pianist is on stage playing his keys while the singer and dancers are waiting for their cue to begin performing
Model A: it brought a where things were in a chaotic mess for me i had just lost my job and i not straight back then so i usually hard i that my worry less
Model B: the is on stage his keys while the and dancers are waiting for their cue to begin performing
[9] Sim=-0.1769 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / bar vs 80s_LOW_06 / movie
── Original A: i saw a silhouette of thor as he raised his hammer and lightning struck revealing his visage a warrior wearing an elk skull rose from the ground with his mighty axe in hand and he began charging
── Original B: scenes of the city a tropical city like miami and or los angeles
[10] Sim=-0.1750 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Met_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: i once attended a concert and have definitely heard similar sounds i was trying to remember when it was but i could not
── Original B: i imagined the main character of a dark action movie getting their weapons and tools ready so they can plot out how to take down their enemy
Model A: i once attended a and have definitely heard similar i was trying to when it was but i not
Model B: i the main character of a dark action getting their weapons and tools ready so they can plot out how to take down their enemySaved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_B7_minilm.png
Data: dataMIMC_preprocessed.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
Quality ceiling for the individual-level sentence-embedding models.
=================================================================B8 — all-mpnet-base-v2 (individual)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (1946, 768) Pairs: 1,764,380 | skipped — identical: 11 | short (<5 words): 128,094 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.9837 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_19 / concert
── Original A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
Model A: its an energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
Model B: it a energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
[2] Sim=0.8766 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: imagined end credits of a game
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: end credits of a
Model B: the end credits of a
[3] Sim=0.8760 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / videogame vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: a band playing on a stage more of a rock heavy metal band
── Original B: a band on stage playing the song with big guitars like a heavy rock band
Model A: a on a stage more of a heavy
Model B: a on stage the with big a heavy
[4] Sim=0.8387 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs 80s_LOW_02 / videogame
── Original A: i imagined myself seated in my house balcony while my mind is being overcame by thoughts
── Original B: i imagined myself seated in my house just meditating about my life
Model A: i myself seated in my house balcony while my mind is being overcame by thoughts
Model B: i myself seated in my house just meditating about my life
[5] Sim=0.8298 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_14 / movie vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: i imagined a movie scene where the protagonist is chasing after the villain
── Original B: i imagined an action movie where someone is being pursued by villains
Model A: i a where the protagonist is chasing after the villain
Model B: i an action where someone is being pursued by villains
[6] Sim=0.8247 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs 80s_LOW_06 / videogame
── Original A: it reminded me of 80s music videos for some reason
── Original B: it reminded me of a 70s era vibe
Model A: it reminded me of 80s for some reason
Model B: it reminded me of a 70s era vibe
[7] Sim=0.8229 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / concert vs 80s_MED_13 / bar
── Original A: the music is melodious and seems to be played during colorful wedding
── Original B: the music seems to be played in occasional events like wedding
Model A: the is melodious and seems to be played during colorful wedding
Model B: the seems to be played in occasional events wedding
[8] Sim=0.8210 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_09 / videogame vs Ele_LOW_09 / bar
── Original A: dimly lit dance hall bright flashing led lights a dj hyping the people up in the crowd almost a rave air about it
── Original B: dark room with some strobe lighting and a dance floor with a dj sitting behind it theres a lot of people and its really crowded everyone is drinking or sitting next to the bar
[9] Sim=0.8191 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / movie vs 80s_LOW_02 / concert
── Original A: sounds like music played at a bar or fancy restaurant
── Original B: played at a jazz club or a bistro
Model A: played at a or fancy restaurant
Model B: played at a club or a bistro
[10] Sim=0.8169 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_14 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: stage lights are flashing and strobing the crowd are getting really into the music a small part of the crowd near the front are moshing whilst other dotted throughout the crowd are headbanging
── Original B: its a rock concert the crowd is one big mass and everyone is surging forward lots of lights and some fire around the stage while the band is dancing and playing
Model A: stage lights are flashing and strobing the crowd are getting really into the a small part of the crowd near the front are moshing whilst other dotted throughout the crowd are headbanging
Model B: its a the crowd is one big mass and everyone is surging forward lots of lights and some fire around the stage while the is dancing and
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=-0.2387 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / movie vs Ele_MED_19 / bar
── Original A: an evil character making plans to kill someone in a cartoon
── Original B: it felt really good to listen i imagined a scene where i was on vacation with my partner in a cozy setting fireplace and good music vibes
Model A: an evil character plans to kill someone in a cartoon
Model B: it felt really good to listen i a where i was on vacation with my partner in a cozy setting fireplace and good vibes
[2] Sim=-0.2005 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / movie vs 80s_MED_08 / bar
── Original A: an evil character making plans to kill someone in a cartoon
── Original B: this was interesting imagined myself dancing in a bar with a beautiful lady holding each other closely
Model A: an evil character plans to kill someone in a cartoon
Model B: this was interesting myself dancing in a with a beautiful lady holding each other closely
[3] Sim=-0.1957 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_14 / movie vs Ele_MED_20 / movie
── Original A: an evil character making plans to kill someone in a cartoon
── Original B: getting a massage from a masseuse it felt very much like the music they play rhythmic but calming
Model A: an evil character plans to kill someone in a cartoon
Model B: getting a massage from a masseuse it felt very much the they rhythmic but calming
[4] Sim=-0.1918 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs Met_MED_19 / movie
── Original A: a man walking down a dark street in heavy rain looking upset the only light is the street lighting
── Original B: i think it would be cool to learn how to play the guitar as well but i do not know if its too late to learn now being in a band sounds very cool
[5] Sim=-0.1856 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / movie vs 80s_LOW_02 / concert
── Original A: an evil character making plans to kill someone in a cartoon
── Original B: it made me feel like i was walking through a forest as it was so calming and surreal sounding i could imagine the sun on my face
Model A: an evil character plans to kill someone in a cartoon
Model B: it me feel i was walking through a forest as it was so calming and surreal i the sun on my face
[6] Sim=-0.1809 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Ele_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: it sounds like a lonely man is in a bar reflecting on his life
── Original B: an action movie with neon lighting people are racing cars down the street
Model A: it a lonely man is in a reflecting on his life
Model B: an action with neon lighting people are racing cars down the street
[7] Sim=-0.1750 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_07 / movie vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: smoky bar room old movies glam women in dresses
── Original B: a kid playing a video game on his tablet or ipad
Model A: smoky room old glam women in dresses
Model B: a kid a on his tablet or ipad
[8] Sim=-0.1739 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_14 / movie vs 80s_LOW_02 / bar
── Original A: an evil character making plans to kill someone in a cartoon
── Original B: yes i could picture walking into a posh drinking bar with this type of music playing its relaxing
Model A: an evil character plans to kill someone in a cartoon
Model B: yes i walking into a posh drinking with this type of its relaxing
[9] Sim=-0.1732 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / movie vs Jaz_LOW_21 / concert
── Original A: a black and white mafia film where the protagonist gets told by the woman hes been slowly falling in love with that shes happily married he watches her walk away its bittersweet
── Original B: i wanted a xylophone as a child i think it would still be cool to have one or to be able to play an instrument in general
Model A: a black and white mafia where the protagonist gets told by the woman hes been slowly falling in love with that shes happily married he watches her walk away its bittersweet
Model B: i wanted a as a child i it still be cool to have one or to be able to an in general
[10] Sim=-0.1715 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_14 / movie vs Jaz_MED_07 / movie
── Original A: an evil character making plans to kill someone in a cartoon
── Original B: i felt like i was in a calm high end bar after a stressful day drinking a luxury drink while enjoying my evening listening to soothing music
Model A: an evil character plans to kill someone in a cartoon
Model B: i felt i was in a calm high end after a stressful day drinking a luxury drink while enjoying my evening listening to soothingSaved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_B8_mpnet.png
Data: dataMIMC_preprocessed.csv | Preprocessing: lvl1a (light)
Fine-tuned for paraphrase detection. At the individual level, the paraphrase objective is especially relevant — different participants describing the same experience in their own words is structurally a paraphrase task.
=================================================================B9 — paraphrase-mpnet-base-v2 (individual)=================================================================Loaded from cache: (1946, 768) Pairs: 1,764,380 | skipped — identical: 11 | short (<5 words): 128,094 | same person/cell: 0
TOP 10:
[1] Sim=0.9891 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Jaz_LOW_19 / concert
── Original A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
── Original B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
Model A: its an energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
Model B: it a energetic with a strong beat and a powerful electric
[2] Sim=0.9415 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs 80s_MED_08 / concert
── Original A: imagined end credits of a game
── Original B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
Model A: end credits of a
Model B: the end credits of a
[3] Sim=0.9286 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / videogame vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: a band playing on a stage more of a rock heavy metal band
── Original B: a band on stage playing the song with big guitars like a heavy rock band
Model A: a on a stage more of a heavy
Model B: a on stage the with big a heavy
[4] Sim=0.9273 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_LOW_21 / bar vs Met_LOW_09 / bar
── Original A: it reminds me of my early twenties when i was in college i used to party a lot and go to the bars
── Original B: reminds me of my college days when i used to party a lot
Model A: it me of my early twenties when i was in college i used to party a lot and go to the
Model B: me of my college days when i used to party a lot
[5] Sim=0.8912 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Jaz_MED_02 / movie vs 80s_LOW_02 / concert
── Original A: sounds like music played at a bar or fancy restaurant
── Original B: played at a jazz club or a bistro
Model A: played at a or fancy restaurant
Model B: played at a club or a bistro
[6] Sim=0.8908 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Met_MED_19 / concert vs Met_MED_20 / concert
── Original A: this also sounded like the opening scene of an anime
── Original B: sounds like the opening for a shonen anime
Model A: this also the opening of an anime
Model B: the opening for a shonen anime
[7] Sim=0.8781 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / concert vs 80s_LOW_06 / bar
── Original A: i imagined an instrumentalist performing for a singer the sound plays before the singer starts
── Original B: i imagined an instrumentalist performing a song at a bar
Model A: i an instrumentalist performing for a the before the starts
Model B: i an instrumentalist performing a at a
[8] Sim=0.8696 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs 80s_LOW_06 / videogame
── Original A: it reminded me of 80s music videos for some reason
── Original B: it reminded me of a 70s era vibe
Model A: it reminded me of 80s for some reason
Model B: it reminded me of a 70s era vibe
[9] Sim=0.8689 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
Jaz_MED_02 / concert vs 80s_MED_13 / concert
── Original A: an introduction song at a concert the crowd is beginning to buzz with excitement as the band are all making their way to the stage loud cheers are erupting each time one of the band members enters the feeling of tension within the crowd as they anticipate the entrance of the band is lifting
── Original B: another introduction style song to play as the band are entering the stage people are getting excited there is a bustling among the crowd as the band members are entering the stage
Model A: an introduction at a the crowd is beginning to buzz with excitement as the are all their way to the stage loud cheers are erupting each time one of the members enters the feeling of tension within the crowd as they anticipate the entrance of the is lifting
Model B: another introduction style to as the are entering the stage people are getting excited there is a bustling among the crowd as the members are entering the stage
[10] Sim=0.8657 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Ele_LOW_14 / bar vs Ele_LOW_14 / videogame
── Original A: sounds from a pac man arcade machine
── Original B: playing a video game such as pac man in an arcade
Model A: from a pac man arcade machine
Model B: a such as pac man in an arcade
BOTTOM 10:
[1] Sim=-0.2481 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / videogame vs Jaz_LOW_21 / concert
── Original A: for this i could imagine an older man with medium length grey hair and glasses pictured in a cafe diner with a hot drink with steam coming out pondering something with serious intent i could image from this the scene zooms out showing him through the window an a wider shot of the city which looks li…
── Original B: a ballet class with kids dancing around in tutus
Model A: for this i an older man with medium length grey hair and glasses in a cafe diner with a hot drink with steam coming out pondering something with serious intent i from this the zooms out showing him through the window an a wider shot of the city which looks a gotham new york type of city is displayed…
Model B: a ballet class with kids dancing around in tutus
[2] Sim=-0.1740 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / movie vs Jaz_LOW_21 / concert
── Original A: another detective story the detectives partner had just been murdered and he sits alone smoking in a bar they were friends maybe a bit more than that in another life time he knows he cannot work this case but damn it if he wont try everything he can to catch the killer
── Original B: a ballet class with kids dancing around in tutus
Model A: another detective the detectives partner had just been murdered and he sits alone smoking in a they were friends maybe a bit more than that in another life time he knows he can not work this case but damn it if he wont try everything he can to catch the killer
Model B: a ballet class with kids dancing around in tutus
[3] Sim=-0.1685 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / videogame vs Jaz_LOW_21 / concert
── Original A: for this i could imagine an older man with medium length grey hair and glasses pictured in a cafe diner with a hot drink with steam coming out pondering something with serious intent i could image from this the scene zooms out showing him through the window an a wider shot of the city which looks li…
── Original B: i imagined children doing ballet dancing at school
Model A: for this i an older man with medium length grey hair and glasses in a cafe diner with a hot drink with steam coming out pondering something with serious intent i from this the zooms out showing him through the window an a wider shot of the city which looks a gotham new york type of city is displayed…
Model B: i children doing ballet dancing at school
[4] Sim=-0.1512 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Ele_MED_19 / movie vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: very confusing i immediately imagined oh they be dead and its so sad and everyone is at the funeral and mourning then there was this beat that was so entirely unexpected it became they be dead yes but they loved a kick drum
── Original B: a kid playing a video game on his tablet or ipad
Model A: very confusing i immediately oh they be dead and its so sad and everyone is at the funeral and mourning then there was this beat that was so entirely unexpected it became they be dead yes but they loved a kick
Model B: a kid a on his tablet or ipad
[5] Sim=-0.1492 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / movie vs Jaz_LOW_21 / concert
── Original A: i imagined a motorbike scene from a movie the motorbike moving fast paced through a city
── Original B: a ballet class with kids dancing around in tutus
Model A: i a motorbike from a the motorbike moving fast paced through a city
Model B: a ballet class with kids dancing around in tutus
[6] Sim=-0.1445 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: a man walking down a dark street in heavy rain looking upset the only light is the street lighting
── Original B: the sounds draws my attention to the time i was around my niece and how much they love spending time on screen watching kids entertainment
[7] Sim=-0.1428 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs Jaz_LOW_21 / concert
── Original A: a man walking down a dark street in heavy rain looking upset the only light is the street lighting
── Original B: a ballet class with kids dancing around in tutus
[8] Sim=-0.1396 | ✗ diff clip ✓ same context
80s_LOW_02 / videogame vs Jaz_LOW_21 / videogame
── Original A: a man walking down a dark street in heavy rain looking upset the only light is the street lighting
── Original B: it was very joyful and reminded me of playing childhood computer games
[9] Sim=-0.1373 | ✗ diff clip ✗ diff context
80s_LOW_06 / concert vs Met_LOW_14 / bar
── Original A: a random day in a sunny shopping district
── Original B: my exboyfriends step dad loved the band kiss and he would always play their music in his room and that is exactly what i thought about when i heard this song playing it brought some sad memories because our relationship did not end well
[10] Sim=-0.1340 | ✓ same clip ✗ diff context
Met_LOW_09 / concert vs Met_LOW_09 / movie
── Original A: i once attended a concert and have definitely heard similar sounds i was trying to remember when it was but i could not
── Original B: our hero has reached a breaking point and plans to kick so major butt someone messed with the wrong person hes packing a bag putting clothes medical supplies weapons anything he may need to take down the big guy before leaving his industrial style apartment and getting on his big motorcycle and driv…
Model A: i once attended a and have definitely heard similar i was trying to when it was but i not
Model B: our hero has reached a breaking point and plans to kick so major butt someone messed with the wrong person hes packing a bag putting clothes medical supplies weapons anything he may need to take down the big guy before leaving his industrial style apartment and getting on his big motorcycle and driv…Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/pairs_B9_para.png
All Group B models share the same individual-level dataset. BERT is used as the reference model for the heatmap so the fine-tuning effect (B4 vs B5) and the lexical-vs-semantic contrast (B1/B2 vs B4/B5) are both immediately visible.
=================================================================
Group B — Rank Correlation of Pair Similarity Orderings
=================================================================
Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/groupB_rank_correlation.png
RANK CORRELATION MATRIX — Group B
(Pearson r on ranked pairwise similarity scores)
TF-IDF W2V-lvl2a W2V-lvl1a BERT BERTweet para-MiniLM MiniLM mpnet para-mpnet
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TF-IDF 1.000* 0.397* 0.301* 0.283* 0.234* 0.227* 0.244* 0.227* 0.229*
W2V-lvl2a 1.000* 0.743* 0.655* 0.517* 0.313* 0.355* 0.344* 0.322*
W2V-lvl1a 1.000* 0.734* 0.659* 0.279* 0.321* 0.329* 0.312*
BERT 1.000* 0.737* 0.297* 0.351* 0.391* 0.356*
BERTweet 1.000* 0.275* 0.304* 0.325* 0.327*
para-MiniLM 1.000* 0.707* 0.592* 0.726*
MiniLM 1.000* 0.714* 0.670*
mpnet 1.000* 0.712*
para-mpnet 1.000*
* p < .05
Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/groupB_jaccard_top.png
Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/groupB_jaccard_bottom.png
Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/groupB_distributions.png
SUMMARY STATISTICS — Group B
Model Mean Median SD Min Max
------------------------------------------------------------------
TF-IDF 0.0093 0.0000 0.0337 0.0000 1.0000
W2V-lvl2a 0.3818 0.3838 0.1365 -0.1537 1.0000
W2V-lvl1a 0.5581 0.5784 0.1536 -0.1537 1.0000
BERT 0.6354 0.6470 0.1018 0.0601 1.0000
BERTweet 0.7700 0.7883 0.0871 0.1421 1.0000
para-MiniLM 0.1842 0.1760 0.1251 -0.2935 1.0000
MiniLM 0.1725 0.1629 0.1097 -0.2099 1.0000
mpnet 0.1874 0.1753 0.1174 -0.2387 1.0000
para-mpnet 0.2356 0.2246 0.1171 -0.2481 1.0000
Saved: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison/groupB_cross_model_heatmap.png
CROSS-MODEL SCORES — Group B (reference: MiniLM top/bottom 10 pairs)
================================================================================
[TOP]
A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
TF-IDF 1.0000
W2V-lvl2a 1.0000
W2V-lvl1a 0.9528
BERT 0.9662
BERTweet 0.9791
para-MiniLM 0.9833
MiniLM 0.9901
mpnet 0.9837
para-mpnet 0.9891
[TOP]
A: imagined end credits of a game
B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
TF-IDF 1.0000
W2V-lvl2a 1.0000
W2V-lvl1a 0.9658
BERT 0.9239
BERTweet 0.9073
para-MiniLM 0.9808
MiniLM 0.9556
mpnet 0.8766
para-mpnet 0.9415
[TOP]
A: a band playing on a stage more of a rock heavy metal band
B: a band on stage playing the song with big guitars like a heavy rock band
TF-IDF 0.8116
W2V-lvl2a 0.9041
W2V-lvl1a 0.8494
BERT 0.8561
BERTweet 0.9325
para-MiniLM 0.9498
MiniLM 0.9199
mpnet 0.8760
para-mpnet 0.9286
[TOP]
A: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a powerful electric guitar
TF-IDF 0.8129
W2V-lvl2a 0.8791
W2V-lvl1a 0.9090
BERT 0.8354
BERTweet 0.9264
para-MiniLM 0.9158
MiniLM 0.9052
mpnet 0.7090
para-mpnet 0.7464
[TOP]
A: its an energetic rock song with a strong beat and a powerful electric guitar
B: it sounded like a energetic rock song with a powerful electric guitar
TF-IDF 0.8129
W2V-lvl2a 0.8791
W2V-lvl1a 0.8711
BERT 0.8315
BERTweet 0.8911
para-MiniLM 0.8942
MiniLM 0.8981
mpnet 0.6970
para-mpnet 0.7196
[TOP]
A: people dancing romantically in a bar
B: a romantic scene people dancing in each others arms
TF-IDF 0.2377
W2V-lvl2a 0.7790
W2V-lvl1a 0.7892
BERT 0.8493
BERTweet 0.8260
para-MiniLM 0.8747
MiniLM 0.8740
mpnet 0.7203
para-mpnet 0.8047
[TOP]
A: sounds like a song that plays for the credits at the end of a movie
B: sounded like the end credits of a movie
TF-IDF 1.0000
W2V-lvl2a 1.0000
W2V-lvl1a 0.8494
BERT 0.7979
BERTweet 0.9148
para-MiniLM 0.8193
MiniLM 0.8684
mpnet 0.7313
para-mpnet 0.8254
[TOP]
A: jazz music played in classy restaurants and events
B: sounds more like cool and classy jazz music played in classy events and restaurants
TF-IDF 0.9014
W2V-lvl2a 0.9108
W2V-lvl1a 0.9108
BERT 0.8588
BERTweet 0.9079
para-MiniLM 0.8969
MiniLM 0.8490
mpnet 0.7598
para-mpnet 0.8235
[TOP]
A: sounds from a pac man arcade machine
B: playing a video game such as pac man in an arcade
TF-IDF 0.8274
W2V-lvl2a 0.9400
W2V-lvl1a 0.8099
BERT 0.7983
BERTweet 0.8486
para-MiniLM 0.8744
MiniLM 0.8408
mpnet 0.5996
para-mpnet 0.8657
[TOP]
A: i remembered my girlfriend love this beat so much
B: my sister who loves songs with this beat
TF-IDF 0.4345
W2V-lvl2a 0.8524
W2V-lvl1a 0.8192
BERT 0.7296
BERTweet 0.8957
para-MiniLM 0.7096
MiniLM 0.8314
mpnet 0.6461
para-mpnet 0.7720
[BOTTOM]
A: a giant man plodding along the street with a cheery grin on his face greeting everyone as he walks past
B: i thought of film noir crime and mystery films as well as two television series that used similar music matlock the series that aired in the 1980s and 90s and in the heat of the night this sounds like the soundtrack for a mystery or crime drama
TF-IDF 0.0000
W2V-lvl2a 0.3427
W2V-lvl1a 0.5302
BERT 0.6293
BERTweet 0.6972
para-MiniLM -0.0882
MiniLM -0.2099
mpnet -0.0430
para-mpnet -0.0135
[BOTTOM]
A: its the ending title sequence of a movie its playing character bloopers in between the credits
B: made me think of jazz clubs where you can play poker and have food as well as smoke cigarettes in an underground poker club very cosy and relaxing atmosphere cigars smoke in the air
TF-IDF 0.0000
W2V-lvl2a 0.1925
W2V-lvl1a 0.3997
BERT 0.5915
BERTweet 0.7904
para-MiniLM -0.0634
MiniLM -0.1988
mpnet -0.0737
para-mpnet 0.1169
[BOTTOM]
A: rainy stormy windows in a city apartment a girl feel reenergised and at peace by it
B: people are dancing at the disco people perform the soul train on the stage
TF-IDF 0.0000
W2V-lvl2a 0.4139
W2V-lvl1a 0.5451
BERT 0.6853
BERTweet 0.8139
para-MiniLM -0.0188
MiniLM -0.1882
mpnet -0.0817
para-mpnet 0.0439
[BOTTOM]
A: people are relaxing at the jazz club people are watching the band perform
B: an evil character making plans to kill someone in a cartoon
TF-IDF 0.0000
W2V-lvl2a 0.3122
W2V-lvl1a 0.3508
BERT 0.6239
BERTweet 0.7909
para-MiniLM 0.0657
MiniLM -0.1876
mpnet -0.1241
para-mpnet 0.1547
[BOTTOM]
A: the character arrives at the beach section
B: i thought about my mum she had tons of records that sounded exactly like this we would listen to these nonstop back then
TF-IDF 0.0000
W2V-lvl2a 0.3127
W2V-lvl1a 0.4373
BERT 0.3790
BERTweet 0.7098
para-MiniLM -0.0607
MiniLM -0.1864
mpnet 0.0131
para-mpnet 0.0124
[BOTTOM]
A: someone playing the guitar someone that looks like jason momoa probably because i have watched game of thrones recently then also occasionally some anime scenes
B: feel like i am at a work conference where a company is launching a new product not bar like at all
TF-IDF 0.0000
W2V-lvl2a 0.3453
W2V-lvl1a 0.6059
BERT 0.6683
BERTweet 0.7689
para-MiniLM -0.0206
MiniLM -0.1813
mpnet -0.0123
para-mpnet -0.0225
[BOTTOM]
A: i could picture a guy struggling but preparing himself for the physical challenge he is embarking on
B: my thoughts were when i attended a concert they always play tunes like that
TF-IDF 0.0000
W2V-lvl2a 0.3406
W2V-lvl1a 0.5760
BERT 0.5463
BERTweet 0.8035
para-MiniLM -0.0838
MiniLM -0.1797
mpnet -0.0157
para-mpnet 0.0264
[BOTTOM]
A: it brought a memory where things were in a chaotic mess for me i had just lost my job and i could not think straight back then so i usually play hard rock music i thought that could make my worry less
B: the pianist is on stage playing his keys while the singer and dancers are waiting for their cue to begin performing
TF-IDF 0.0000
W2V-lvl2a 0.4113
W2V-lvl1a 0.5699
BERT 0.5630
BERTweet 0.8183
para-MiniLM -0.1990
MiniLM -0.1796
mpnet -0.0195
para-mpnet -0.0229
[BOTTOM]
A: i saw a silhouette of thor as he raised his hammer and lightning struck revealing his visage a warrior wearing an elk skull rose from the ground with his mighty axe in hand and he began charging
B: scenes of the city a tropical city like miami and or los angeles
TF-IDF 0.0000
W2V-lvl2a 0.2215
W2V-lvl1a 0.3154
BERT 0.5112
BERTweet 0.7409
para-MiniLM -0.0608
MiniLM -0.1769
mpnet -0.0335
para-mpnet -0.0650
[BOTTOM]
A: i once attended a concert and have definitely heard similar sounds i was trying to remember when it was but i could not
B: i imagined the main character of a dark action movie getting their weapons and tools ready so they can plot out how to take down their enemy
TF-IDF 0.0000
W2V-lvl2a 0.4125
W2V-lvl1a 0.6233
BERT 0.5809
BERTweet 0.7701
para-MiniLM -0.1015
MiniLM -0.1750
mpnet -0.0588
para-mpnet -0.0276
FULL MODEL COMPARISON SUMMARY (9 models × 2 data levels)================================================================================
Group A: 64 combMIMC documents | Group B: 1946 individual responses | Top/bottom N: 10
Model Preproc --- Group A (combMIMC) --- --- Group B (individual) --- Mean SD Min Max Mean SD Min Max ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- TF-IDF lvl2a 0.126 0.036 0.050 0.321 0.009 0.034 0.000 1.000
W2V lvl2a 0.920 0.026 0.811 0.978 0.382 0.137 -0.154 1.000
W2V lvl1a 0.965 0.012 0.912 0.988 0.558 0.154 -0.154 1.000
BERT lvl1a 0.961 0.010 0.909 0.983 0.635 0.102 0.060 1.000
BERTweet lvl1a 0.943 0.013 0.865 0.973 0.770 0.087 0.142 1.000
para-MiniLM lvl1a 0.470 0.102 0.153 0.761 0.184 0.125 -0.293 1.000
MiniLM lvl1a 0.432 0.107 0.137 0.755 0.173 0.110 -0.210 1.000
mpnet lvl1a 0.705 0.079 0.337 0.899 0.187 0.117 -0.239 1.000
para-mpnet lvl1a 0.656 0.076 0.388 0.874 0.236 0.117 -0.248 1.000
Outputs saved to: /Users/hazelaileenvanderwalle/Library/CloudStorage/OneDrive-Personal/work/study/PhD/_PROJECT/_framedListening_NLP/context-framed-listening/NLP_outputs/model_comparison pairs_top/bottom_<ID>.csv — pair lists for each of the 18 model runs pairs_<ID>.png — bar charts groupA/B_rank_correlation.png — Pearson r on ranked pair orderings groupA/B_jaccard_top/bottom.png — agreement heatmaps groupA/B_distributions.png — score distributions groupA/B_cross_model_heatmap.png — side-by-side score heatmaps groupA/B_cross_model_scores.csv — full comparison tables